From the editorial office. May 9 marks the 65th anniversary of the end of the most tragic historical event for Russia - the Great Patriotic War. According to the updated reports of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation during the war years, the Soviet Union lost 26.5 million people. So we still suffer from what happened more than half a century ago.
Unfortunately, this truly great holiday, which should unite Russians, disconnects them. The reason for this is the personality of the Supreme Commander -in -Chief of the Red Army forces during the Great Patriotic War Joseph Stalin.
In the year of the 65th anniversary of the victory of Debata about his role in the war, erupted with renewed vigor. Fans consider Stalin a great commander and statesman, without whom the USSR would lose war. Opponents insist on the destructive nature of Stalin’s activity in the pre -war era and point out the erroneous decisions made by him as the supreme commander in chief, which cost thousands and thousands of lives. The political scientist and publicist Konstantin Krylov shared his opinion on this issue with the editors of the Russian Journal.
* * *
The whole vanity around the name of Stalin or any other historical characters who have long left the historical arena is a PR campaign to cover some rather unpleasant things. After all, neither Stalin nor Stalinism are neither an urgent topic, nor relevant practice. They say about the past mainly then, so as not to think about the present and future.
As for Stalin specifically, it is currently used as a universal stimulus. This is a figure that society will quarrel very well and very successfully, because everyone sees different things in it: someone who wants to see, and someone what he does not want to see. At the same time, all this attitude is very weak towards real Stalin and real Stalinism.
By and large, we can say that there are a number of Stalin, starting from Stalin, relatively speaking, Khrushchevsky, and ending with Stalin from the 1990s. And all these stalls are stalin - whose Stalin is cooler, or whose Stalin is worse, or whose Stalin, on the contrary, is more magnificent - are just a means of distraction from the current problems .
But people are trying to distract from a fairly banal thing. At the moment, the entire Soviet ideological system is completely dismantled in Russia. The only myth remained from her as a lonely peak - the theme of the Great Patriotic War and victory in it. This is the only thing that was not touched in the 1990s, which was not touched in the 2000s and which they are trying to strengthen now.
This is due to many reasons. In particular, with the need for the ideological support of “anti -fascism” and “anti -extramism”, the real ideology that the Russian Federation professes. In addition, there is an unpleasant situation that boils down to the fact that, according to the results of the Cold War and the defeat of the Soviet Union, it began to revise the results of the Second World War in it. This process is unpleasant, but inevitable. Of course, now they are trying to brake it, and to slow down in a very definite direction.
Thanks to this coincidence of the external and internal vectors, we get that with the absolute collapse of the entire Soviet ideological system, a lonely rock remains - the victory of the Soviet people in the Great Patriotic War. And Stalin is a borderline here. The fact is that, on the one hand, according to the general anti-Soviet ideology of the 1990s-2000s, it is subject to dumping from the ship of our time with Lenin. On the other hand, he is in some way involved in this very myth, and it is impossible to dump it.
But how to relate to all this? You need to ask yourself a simple question, what does Stalin have to do with our problems today? An honest answer to it is as follows: about the same as Napoleon Bonaparte. You can also argue about Napoleon. By the way, the debate about him lasted quite a long time until, finally, they were crystallized in the form of a cake and cognac . At the moment, for example, a storm of emotions associated with this name, descendants are simply incomprehensible. In this case, regardless of a personal attitude to Stalin, someone may be aesthetically pleasant to hate him, and someone, on the contrary, is pretty, needs to be aware of: he is an irrelevant figure. However, the point in the debate could be placed by inventing the Stalin cognac and safely forgetting about Stalin himself. On the one hand, this would reassure his opponents, since this would not concern public debate, on the other hand, supporters, because the memory of him would still be preserved.
Nevertheless, I do not think that Stalin’s figure will soon be erased from historical memory, as the names of Russian emperors were erased. However, the wording with which it will be submitted in history textbooks may be as follows: it was a ruler of Russia, in which the Great Patriotic War was going on. As for the personal participation of Stalin in the war, both popular formulations now (Stalin won the war and the Soviet people won the war, to which Stalin interfered with all his might) are equally idiotic.
It is completely clear that the second wording is simply fantastic: the people win the war, although Stalin from all their might interferes with him, apparently, wanting to surrender to Hitler. But the idea that Stalin wins the war with genius, and the generals, the people and everything else are in the way, are no less fantastic. It is quite obvious that without the efforts of Stalin, probably quite significant, equally and as without what is the feat of the whole people, the war would not be won.
At the same time, we must not forget that Stalin had a personal concrete interest to win this war. In contrast, for example, Hogensollerne, who, after the lost First World War, was left alive and made it possible to calmly survive his age in Holland, Stalin did not have such a chance. Stalin could not count on the condescension of anyone - nor Hitler, nor union powers. This is a person who was forced, he wanted him or not, or to win or die. But the people had a choice either to throw off the Bolsheviks and, as they say, put the Germans on their neck, or still fight with the Germans. The Germans managed to prove to the Russian people that they were worse than the Bolsheviks. Thanks to this, I would say, “heroic” and “unprecedented” efforts of the German army, the Russian people made their choice. And this choice was correct.