From the editorial office. Russian political scientists suddenly unanimously started talking about the rapprochement of Russia and the European Union. It was as if before that, before that, our country oriented against Asia unexpectedly turned to face to Europeans. Indeed, cooperation with Europe is strengthened. We need European technologies for the implementation of plans to modernize the country. But what in return can the EU demand? And is Russia so important for him? The Russian Journal talks about this with the head of the Center for International Security of the Institute of World Economics and International Relations (IMEMO RAS) Alexei Arbatov .
* * *
RG: Dear Alexei Georgievich, events in Kyrgyzstan and Ukraine show that Russia can play with the West "Four Hands." Can something like this be repeated in Belarus or in Georgia?
Alexei Arbatov: Russia's strategy in the post -Soviet space is to fully expand its economic, political and, if possible, military influence, but not take over excessive obligations that can draw Russia into unwanted conflicts and become excessive burden for its economy and finance.
The fact that Russia carried out an operation in Georgia in August 2008 and at the same time not a single state of the post -Soviet space recognized the independence of these two republics means that Russia remained alone. This means that the serious fundamental issues of our relations with neighboring republics are not thought out .
Therefore, there is a strategy, but in each case, tactical considerations, momentary plans often prevail. By inertia, in Moscow, they think of categories of space, coalitions, unions under the leadership of Russia. Inside the post -Soviet space, some perceive this as a threat to their sovereignty, others as an invitation to use Russia as a dairy cow in exchange for symbolic gestures of loyalty.
Relations are getting better with America, it seems to be with Europe too. And to seriously think about how to avoid repeating such situations as in 2008, no one has time or opportunity. The world around us is not clear what specific practical interests in Russia has in every country neighboring Russia. Russia had to specifically formulate these interests for a long time. Then it would be possible to play “in four hands”, as you put it.
RG: Since 2008, the administration has changed in the United States. After that, events occurred in Ukraine and in Kyrgyzstan, where there was no conflict between Russia and the West. Does this mean that the situation has changed?
A.A.: The situation changes so dynamically that, I repeat, there is not even time to think about that conflict and its results. But in the South Caucasus a difficult problem is frozen, which will interfere with us each time, including in promoting our ideas regarding the new European security architecture.
The problem of Kosovo is largely similar. Kosovo created a precedent, and it was a big mistake of the West. But a third of the UN states recognized Kosovo as an independent country. And no one except Nicaragua, Venezuela and the island of Nauru.
Yes, Russia improves relations with the United States, and relations with Europe are improving. And in Ukraine there have been positive changes, tension slept, although it is not excluded in the future. But you need to think about excluding the repetition of such situations in the post -Soviet space, where we will be alone.
RG: Can we talk about some kind of consolidated strategy of Europe?
A.A.: It is impossible. But this should not console us, but excite us . If Europe had some kind of clear, thoughtful line, then we could, starting from this line, formulate our interests, to accept it in some ways, and in some ways to oppose it. But, since the scatter is here and there, the general “porridge” is obtained .
Our export-raw economy is our terrible problem. And the super -bureaucratic state mechanism that has developed on its basis, which does not allow this problem to solve, because it is interested in this model existing is our main problem. Our problems threaten our national existence, sovereignty, territorial integrity in a long -term plan. And European problems are the problems of the economic crisis, it is a cyclic phenomenon, it is the problems of economic growth and the problems of reassigning relations between twenty seven members of the unique community of states.
RG: Does this “reassignment” turn into a kind of Pax Germanica?
A.A.: No. It’s just that Germany has the strongest economy in the EU, and the biggest burden falls on it. But there is no doubt that Europe will come out of this position. Where twenty -seven not the most stupid elites work, it is easier to achieve the right results, without making decisions that will turn out to be counter -productive.
RG: Nevertheless, the European Union has not become a leader comparable to the United States ...
A.A.: In economically, he became. For a share in the global GDP - became. As for the political role, if we assume that the role of the state is to get into the war, and then not get out of it, then yes, Europe did not create this. And if we consider in the XXI century the political role of states by their contribution to peacekeeping operations, then Europe is far ahead of the United States. If you think aircraft carriers and battleships and count the role in the world from this, then you will have the same results. And if you consider new functions, the fight against new threats, a reasonable environmental and social policy, then you will have other criteria.
RG: Do you see a certain reorientation of Russian foreign policy in the last two years from the United States to Europe or vice versa?
A.A.: In the past two years, reorientation has just occurred in the United States. Negotiations, new agreements, important breakthroughs pushed Europe to a more active policy towards Russia. After the 2008 crisis, relations with the United States were actually frozen, we approached the new Cold War. Europe played the role of an intermediary, and in politically, Europe and I had more active relations. Then the administration in the United States was replaced, the overpassing of Russian-American relations began, relations with the United States became a locomotive. But if we assume that the basis of political events are economic interests, then in this regard, no one will ever replace Europe - neither the USA, China, nor even more than Iran or Nigeria. Europe is a source of investment, the main trading partner, the main source of new technologies in order to modernize the economy and change the economic model .
RG: Why is it not visible to real specific steps from Europe, which could take advantage of the reboot of Russian-American relations?
A.A.: Europe is too busy now with its own economic crisis. She is not up to Russia. Now in the current policy, Russia is in the background, but it will not go anywhere. We are nearby, we have a common space - historical, cultural, civilizational, economic, security space. Only the Cold War can share us. I hope she will not be.
Europe faced unique problems after a very long period of consolidation, growth and strengthening of the European Union. Now there has been a period of testing and the need to take some qualitative step in the development of this union. I am sure that they will make it, the European Union will not break up, the euro will not collapse . When the current problems inside the EU will be adjusted, a new wave of rapprochement and integration of Russia with Europe will begin - I have no doubt about this.
RG: Sergey Lavrov recently called for the humanitarian basis of European integration to become the Council of Europe. How real is this initiative?
A.A.: The European Union was and will remain the center of the entire European space. And Russia will gradually get closer to this center. Entering the EU for Russia in the foreseeable period will hardly be possible, because the economy is too different. But if you look at all our proclaimed plans for the modernization of the economy, then, in essence, they suggest the creation of conditions in Russia that will make its unification with the European Union with a quite logical step .
RSH: Is Europe ready to let Russia go to itself?
A.A.: Not yet ready. But because Russia is not ready for this either. Russia is a huge country. This will be an integration on a bilateral basis, when Russia will open for the European Union, and the European Union - for Russia.
Boris Volkhonsky talked