About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
12/24/2008
Author
Роберт Каттнер
Source
Russkii Zhurnal
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Rubin team


As progressives, we can consider the new economic team of the elected President Obama from two points of view. Or he disappointed us, gathering a group working with Clinton - the very people who brought us the abolition of state control, which led to financial collapse; Financial conservatives, who in the 1990s considered the budget balance more important than the restoration of state institutions. Or we can conclude that he with great insight has selected a team of technically competent centrists to manage as a progressive in the pragmatist mask - as he shifts the political center to the left.

Which of the options will we choose? Definitely, Obama’s press messages are phenomenal, and the Republicans are almost more delighted than democrats. When Arianna Haffington and I talked with George Will and David Brooks at George Stefanopulos on the program “This Week” on Sunday morning, conservatives, in any case, approved the choice of Obama than we.

On another channel, one could see how the Republican Guru Ed Rollins triumphed about the Obama cabinet. I even had strange debates with Pat Buchenen about hardball, during which I learned that, in his opinion, Hilary Clinton is a magnificent candidate for the Secretary of State. Now Obama has the highest ratings among all the elected presidents, the entire republican expert community is delighted with him.

Of course, the honeymoon cannot last forever, because soon Obama will have to make a very tough choice: whether to spend huge amounts of federal money on exit from depression; whether to use large -scale scarce expenses as a temporary incentive, and then continue to rebuild state investments so that we have the corresponding 21st century infrastructure, energy and the necessary areas of services; Whether to take financial regulation seriously so that the economy never collapses under the influence of excessive speculation. Whether to save the automobile industry, imposing very stringent conditions in exchange for state aid.

To do all this correctly, he may need to nationalize one or two bank instead of just throwing state money to Wall Street in the manner of Polson. Requested assistance to automobile companies exceeds the cost of their total fixed capital. We need a plan for the transition to energy-efficient cars, so that most of the state-owned companies make up state representatives in exchange for state subsidies; This, in turn, violates the norms of "free trade", introducing industrial policy into the sin. And we need direct state refinancing of overdue mortgages, and not assistance to shares and banks.

Will Obama make any of this? He is a realist. He will have to think and take radical actions to save the economy. By January 20, we will balance on the edge of depression. The whole conservative paradigm is discredited. Republicans can support a large initial package of incentives, because their areas suffer from the districts of democrats. But they will want this to be mainly carried out in the form of a decrease in taxes, not state investments; And they will probably oppose a large part of the rest of the Obama program. The bolder it will be, the right his opposition will be. By January, like George Will and David Brooks will be horrified (I hope).

Obama can call himself a pragmatist who crosses the limits of ideology and relieves obstacles between differences. But it is impossible to deny the simple fact that only progressive means, large -scale state injections and strict state regulation will fix the broken one.

What returns me to the Economic team of Obama. According to leaks, it will include Tim Gaitner as the Minister of Finance; Lawrence Summers as a senior adviser to the White House, possibly the head of the National Economic Council; Peter Orsazag as a director of administrative and budget management; Jason Ferman, Osten Gulsby and Jack Lew will take high economic posts. All of them are relative centrists. And they all, with the exception of Gulby, have a common one: each of them is a protege of the former Minister of Finance and the current executive director of Citigroup Robert Rubin. Even Hilary Clinton, becoming the president, could have gathered a foster group.

What magic does this ruby ​​have? For democrats, he was one of the key authors of the strategy of extreme termination of financial regulation, which led the economy to the current state. In Citigroup , he was one of the great strategists in the field of speculation by securitized loans and tricks with the dews of balances that led Citigroup to the brink of bankruptcy. And yet he continues to climb up. Of course, Barack Obama was supposed to notice that Rubin was a false prophet. So why is the entire top of his economic group a Rubin group?

On the first page of the Sunday New York Times on November 23, two articles are placed in the shocking proximity. The first, " Citigroup pays for the desire for risk", describes the central role of Rubin in the destruction of the leading bank of America. Another, “Obama swears to take actions to introduce a large stimulus package,” says that one after another, Obama’s highest economic figures were Rubin's people.

In good conscience, adults are not just the tools of their bosses. In recent months, Lari Summers did not agree with Rubin on the issue of a scale of necessary incentives. Tim Gaiter advocates much more regulation than ruby. Jason Farman, although Rubin offered him a position of director of economic policy for his campaign, actually devoted most of his career to Joseph Stilitz, and not to Robert Rubin. Peter Orsazag brilliantly worked as the director of the budget office of the congress and does not nourish antipathy for large state expenses.

Obama is the president, and he will do what he considers necessary. In my articles during the campaign, I sometimes found that I was trying to guess Obama’s strategy - and he invariably turned out to be smarter than me.

Obama is also famous for listening to a wide range of opinions. Other people who hold leading positions in his team, such as the legislative director Phil Shiliro, closer to the left. But this economic team will have an influence - in the proposal of options, the performance of the role of a watchman, writing positioning documents, moreover, these people will, like an echo, reflect each other's voices.

Obama is smart enough to come to their own conclusions, and they will rather cause heartburn from conservative Republicans than those who were so hard to work to choose Obama. But it would be useful if at least one person who was not a member of the same Center Club - Joseph Stiglitz, Jamie Galbrait, Jeremed Bernstein or Sheila Beir were among the leaders of his economic team. Soon we will see whether the president himself and his own economic advisers will be the most interesting team of rivals in the White House of Obama.