
It is necessary to reduce the number of poor in three years! It is not easy to decipher a slight smile on the face of the president, who publicly cherished Mr. Gref , who was reasonably careful and tried to use the grammatical wealth of the Russian language in order to avoid dangerous certainty. “You yourself presented calculations,” the president insisted. What is true, it was true, such calculations were ...
I have no doubt that there is no other way: only set a goal, which is impossible to achieve. Then there is a hope that for some reason it will decrease.
What will decrease?
What poverty proportion should be considered normal? Normal is by no means in comparison with a wonderful dream of universal happiness, but in correlation with the civilizational standard of rich countries. To ask such a question is unpleasant, but it is necessary.
It is clear that poverty of poverty is different. The entire first course of the institute and half of the second in the late 50s I finished trousers from the school uniform, in the early 60s, when my wife ended “maternity” payments, and I was a distributed young specialist, a friend’s coming could be noted only with two bottles of beer. Poverty was aware of, of course, but, firstly, in the same way it was for most peers, and secondly, it was to some extent motivated optimism: it would be better! This optimism was personal, but it was spilled in the air. The three of us, with a son, huddled in one of the rooms of a communal apartment; This room with considerable tricks has obtained father -in -law for us. But there was no doubt: it would be better!
In the early 70s, poverty meant the difficulty of getting female boots and the constancy of the “black cash desks” in the service (I already burst out of this, others could not ...
Since the beginning of the 90s, poverty meant that, having lost, along with the comfortable, conditional savings, the poor people realized that they could not accumulate something. Now, in Russia, poverty in Russia is much greater means the impossibility of acquiring housing than difficulties with the purchase of a car of second freshness.
Despite a certain number of sociological studies, knowledge of real poverty is shrouded in fog today. FOM conducted a survey in 100 settlements of 44 constituent entities of the Federation. 36 percent officially living within one thousand per month believe that three thousand rubles per soul per month is already a way out of poverty. 38 percent of those who are officially from one to two thousand - that this is from three to five thousand. A third of all respondents - that from five to eight thousand. Well, what follows from this, in addition to the fact that appetites grow during food in proportion to opportunities?
In 2001, at the graduation evening in the Mordovian Ruzayevka, no dress was cheaper than $ 200-250 for any girl. What does that mean? And a lot, and nothing. Nothing, because it is likely that in many families such a dress was "built" with the same difficulty as in my childhood "built" a suit or coat. A lot, because if such an effort is still made, there is no need to talk about complete poverty. In the Chuvash veners for the school dinner, a lyceum student from the budget is allocated, as almost everywhere, an insignificant amount of 1 p. 40 kopecks. Only half of the parents agree to contribute 50 rubles a month, and this should be considered a sign of extreme poverty. But it should only: thanks to the inseparable heroism of the directorate, the lyceum contains a good subsidiary farm, sells something in the market, holds a good cook, adolescents are fed and dressed in a pretty uniform made of inexpensive material, but by a special order. As for those parents who do not bring his fifty dollars to the box office, this does not mean that none of them can do it - there are many who simply believe that the authorities are obliged to do this. It is necessary to understand in each individual case, which, incidentally, makes the authorities so unreliable faith in the effectiveness of targeted social assistance. Such assistance can be both effective and targeted only with the participation of mature public services, which is not too much visible on our horizon.
The seriousness of the problem with the poor is beyond doubt. But so that it is really serious, does not come down to public wringing hands, something should be understood. Does the poor widow-pensioner in Moscow, or even a four-room apartment belongs to the circle of the poor? From her own point of view and from the point of view of our statistics, it is undoubted. But from the point of view of the American charitable organization - in any case. From this pragmatic position, the elderly lady has the full opportunity to sell her apartment, get a house somewhere in the old Rus, put the difference in the bank on the deposit, retaining a couple of thousand on acquisitions, and to exist quite tolerance, having an increase in a pension of three hundred dollars. Of course, the senior researcher at the Research Institute of anything serious is objectively and doubly poor in self -awareness, especially if he has children, but his pragmatic American point of view would not have ranked infringed on people, since his poverty is the result of free choice, and not fatal inevitability.
But we are not the USA.
By the way, New York, of course, represents one of the richest places on Earth. The TRP of New York is $ 400 billion, so this nine-million "country" objectively occupies the 13th position among all countries of the world. For all that in New York, 8.4 percent of the unemployed - more than in any other of the largest cities in the United States. According to official figures, as of January 1, 2003, 20.2 percent of New York residents had income below the federal poverty level, another 13 percent were slightly higher than this feature. In 2001, one million received his stew in charity canteens daily - and another 350 thousand did not receive this stew, since they did not have enough food. There were 600 thousand low -paid employees, of which 56 percent did not have medical insurance, and 52 percent did not have a fixed fee. Yes, 61.2% of the unemployed are black and latinos, but almost 40% are white. There were 38 thousand homeless people in the city, etc. 1
Curious: our experts estimate the fraction of the poor in the Russian population from 20 percent to 30, which just coincides with the data for New York.
No one claims that New York, and the USA as a whole, is an example to follow, but, on the other hand, not with Holland to relate ourselves to us.
I believe that honesty is better than evasion. It is better to honestly assess the number of beggars and set the task of the movement of this number to zero in a meaningful period of time. It is better to honestly estimate the fraction of the poor, determining them with a measure of access to tolerable housing, and set the task of increasing the number of people, especially young people, under a decent roof, whether it is owned or for urgent hiring. I’m afraid that preserving the vague in poverty conversations will turn into troubles in the office of ministers, which, in principle, can be avoided.
Notes:
1 urban update, #4, Feb. 2004, Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars., P.9.