
In recent years, Harvard University has attracted great public interest, especially during the short (2001-2006), but saturated with the events of the presidency of Lorence Summers . Two widely known professors of jurisprudence were suspected of "incomplete use of other people's statements" in their books, and the famous professor of the economy was accused by the US government of fraud when working on one of the Harvard projects. In the first case, the teaching committee decided that "the case smells of plagiarism," but accused the professors only of "violation of the borders of authorship of scientific research", and the "violators" were forced to apologize. In the second case, the university did not take any action against the aforementioned professor, but the government won the case, and Harvard had to pay $ 26.5 million by decision.
But incidents with the participation of Summers were even more public attention. One of them was that the Summers tried to convince one famous member of the Professor Corps to switch attention from rap music and agitation for presidential candidate to some kind of activity more close to science; The furious professor left Harvard, happy with his presence by another citadel of knowledge. The attempts of the Summers attracted no less attention to raise a painful question about anti -Semitism in university campuses, including the Harvard campus. Two years after that, the Summers uttered a small speech at dinner, in which he indulged in analytical thoughts about why there are so few women among outstanding scientists. Having dared to touch on such a delicate topic, the Summers turned the aspen nest and brought to himself the fury of the feminists, to which he first answered in futile attempts to explain, and then I will somehow bribe the ladies attacked at him. Thanks to these and other actions that were considered by the President’s unwritten code of behavior, the Faculty of Arts and Sciences (Faculty of Arts and Sciences), he brought him a votum of no confidence in March 2005, and soon after that the Summers was forced to announce his resignation.
As a result, the squeezing the oldest and famous university of the country of squabbles around the unseemly behavior of professors, the escapad of the president, participation in fierce cultural wars and, finally, the "faculty riot" - obscured that with a healthier moral climate could become an important breakthrough in organizing the educational process: the Summers sought to use the period of his presidency to conduct radical Reforms, which, perhaps, served as the true reason for the dissatisfaction of his colleagues and the faculty "riot on the ship". In short, Summers tried to reconsider training programs.
The beginning might seem promising. The newly made president called for "the most serious review of Harvard's training programs over the past hundred years." The dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences accepted the challenge and promised to give a comprehensive answer to the sacramental question: "What does it mean to be an educated person in the 21st century?" However, after three years of work of the teaching committee, the presenter author of the report acknowledged that the team could not develop a single concept. In this regard, one stinging student described the Committee’s report as: "Sixty pages of surprisingly toothless and inaudible recommendations adhering to the middle line between non -infinitability and non -comprehensibility."
Harvard University Dean Harry R. Lewis seems to have agreed with such an assessment. In the recently published book about Harvard’s decline “soulless superiority: how the great university forgot about education” [ Excellence Without a Soul: How a Great University Forgot Education ] 1 Lewis quotes the explanation proposed by one of the member of the teaching committee: “We decided that the best thing is that the best is that it was the best that the best is that it was the best that the best is that the best You can do it - this is to set a number of empty bottles and see how certain teachers will fill them out. " Lewis sarcastically remarks:
"Empty bottles could be filled with anything from the assortment that was proposed by the Department of Education. ... But Harvard cannot expect that students will know at least something really necessary after three courses of natural sciences and three humanitarian, freely chosen from the general catalog. The proposed general requirements are based on the complete rejection of any mandatory knowledge, values or even values or even values or even The aspirations, according to which any knowledge acquired by a student is no better and no worse than any others, with a fundamental unwillingness to distinguish important Harvard, actually declares that it can be considered an educated person of the XXI century, knowing nothing about the genome, chromosomes and Shakespeare. "
Is it really so important - that Harvard program is in fact an empty vessel? Indeed, in the end, it is no secret that students' training is a matter of a matter for the university at best. That - chickens to laugh! - called the core Curriculum, is distinguished by the absence of the core: there are no subjects or objects whose knowledge would be mandatory for everyone (it was this core program and tried to revise the Summers). Moreover, in practice, very many courses are conducted by old -story students - and not as assistants to professors, but quite independently determining the content of training. Although they are called 'mentors' ('tutors') - which causes associations with a noble wise man who shares his wisdom with the eye of his face - they actually act as inexperienced leaders of discussion or pseudo -distinguishing groups. The vast majority of these young people (and girls) who are entrusted to a significant share of students' training will never become permanent members of the professorship due to the lack of necessary abilities.
But, no matter how Harvard’s internal problems solve, what is happening there - especially how they work with students - is of great importance for other colleges. The respectable age, a glorious reputation, the high quality of the teaching and student composition, wealth and prestige made Harvard a model, which is always closely observed and which is equal in their work. After the Second World War, when the General Education program was adopted at Harvard - the predecessor of the current stupid core program - this changed the nature of students' training in the whole country.
Therefore, we can consider so intriguing and instructive the fact that Harvard’s former dean falls up with a sharp criticism of the program developed by the teaching committee: according to Lewis, this program characterizes Harvard as “university without a sense of broad prospects in education and without a systemic connection between its components of its main elements”. It is no less intriguing that Derek K. Bok, the former and, after the resignation of Summers, the current president of Harvard, shared his own anxieties about the same problem. 2
After his first presidency in Harvard (1971-1991), the side became a kind of self-proclaimed emergency master of national scale: he knows how to find a solution to any problems-social ["Federal Assembly" (The State of the Nation)], political [("What is not so with the government" (The Trooble with Govenment) and pedagogical) [See the book "The Shape of the River), written together with William G. Bowen, former President of Princeton, and" Universities on the Market Square "(Universities in the MarketPlace)]. and as a doctor; he gives statistics and the results of scientific research to find out the origins of the current disease and recommend medicines for its treatment. Heavily sick (if not at death), or blamed in the ailment of the patient himself, or is recommended for his treatment too painful and potent drugs.
Skeptics, among which Allan Bloom, the author of the book “ Closing the American Mind ” [The Closing of the American Mind (1987)], is constantly aching, and their complaints are not visible: their complaints are not visible: their complaints
"In their opinion, the conversation about campus is seriously difficult to orthodoxy of political correctness. The program of affirmative actions undermined the unity of the requirements when hiring. The great canonical masterpieces of artistic creativity are belittled and forced to squeeze out, giving way to insignificant works, the main (if not the only) whose dignity is a woman or an African American or a representative of" third Mira. "High ideals of truth and objectivity, along with established judgments about quality, are shaken by incessant attacks on the part of deconstructivists, Marxists, feminists and other literary theorists, which deny the significance of any criteria."
It may seem that there are serious reasons for the expressed concern. But such judgments do not bother too much. First of all, he writes, such critics are unilateral polemists who, as a rule, see "a little positive in the work of universities and professors who work there." In addition, if such sharp critical judgments were “close to the truth, ambitious students and their parents would have rebelled for a long time ... and the number of students applying for admission to universities would not be so large and also constantly increasing.” In fact, according to sociological research, the vast majority of recent graduates are satisfied with the results of their studies in colleges. Parents also do not complain, and former pets demonstrate their satisfaction by donating more and more money for Alma Mater's needs.
But if everyone is so happy, why was it to write this book? As it turns out, there are more than enough reasons for this. Although the side shows a faint interest in topics that most exciting the most insightful critics - such as the politicization of professors, the restriction of freedom of expression, the absence or actual suppression of freedom of exchanging ideas - and more revives when it comes to questions like: "How intensively do students do?" Or “What should really be done to increase the efficiency of classes?”, He, nevertheless, also expresses concern and sees many unresolved problems in the beautiful groves of the Academy:
"Many graduate from universities, not being able to write well enough to satisfy the requirements of the employer. Many do not know how to consistently express their thoughts or analyze comprehensive non-lactic problems, although professors consider the development of critical thinking the priority task of university education. Few graduates who have received a degree can speak or write in some foreign language. Most graduates did not take courses in mathematical logic and did not acquire and did not acquire The knowledge necessary in order to be considered a fairly informed citizen of a democratic country.
In short, there is a feeling that our colleges ultimately remain “unsuccessful” - and that even their allegedly happy customers know this. Less than half of recent graduates, according to statistics, which are always at hand, believe that they have advanced significantly in the ability to write, and some think that they began to write even worse than before. Employers confirm this self -esteem and complain that graduates of the colleges that they hire are poorly owned by speech. As for critical thinking, "the vast majority of students who graduate from universities remain naive relativists and do not find the ability to critically analyze their own assessments and judgments when they are faced with unstructured problems characteristic of everyday life." In the field of teaching foreign languages, less than ten percent of senior students believe that they have advanced significantly in the knowledge of languages, and less than fifteen percent managed to go to classes with a more advanced study of the language. No better the results and sphere of general education, which is the most vulnerable target for criticism. According to one sociological study, only about a third of senior students learned to understand literature or find pleasure in reading, visiting concerts, exhibitions or theatrical performances. The side came in this regard to such a pessimistic conclusions that it considered it necessary to give a quote from Daniel Bell, who called the typical university program the “Swedish table”, cultivating “readiness for intellectual defeat”.
The basis of a significant share of intellectual shortcomings inherent in college graduates are the shortcomings of their character. According to sides, recent graduates lack self -discipline. The employers complain that they are inclined to be late, lazy and unable to carefully listen to the instructions of the leadership, nor to fulfill them exactly.
The side of teaching in universities blames this: reducing the requirements for thesis undermined the standards, and the professional irresponsibility of teachers gave rise to a careless attitude to study. "If a student can be highly appreciated for weak work and constantly provide deferrals if the task is not completed on time, if he is not punished for unworthy behavior, is it worth it to be surprised that employers find graduates undisciplined?" - asks the rhetorical question side by side.
The picture drawn sideways is surprisingly gloomy. What in this case to do? One obvious answer, very popular among critics of the existing state of affairs in campus, is to reconsider the order in which the professorship is allowed to devote more and more research work and less and less - teaching.
Half a century ago, when I entered college, my professor led five courses to the semester and conducted classes in classes fifteen hours a week. In Penn State, where I started my teaching activities, I had four courses. In 1960, when I moved to Cornell, their number decreased to three. In Yale, we led two courses in the semester, and only one in difficult subjects. Today, the university of the highest category offers the professor a pass of at least one semester out of every seven; In those days when I started, it was one semester every seven years. In general, today university teachers lead no more than half of the number of classes that their predecessors conducted half a century ago.
The side, however, has another opinion on this. He claims that the problem is not how teachers spend their time, but in their reluctance or a direct refusal to monitor what students really do, or to examine them regularly in order to be able to control their development. What we really need, he writes is a reform program, "not at all like those that are offered by the famous critics of universities or teaching committees that have clearly lost the task assigned to them." According to the sides, the professors themselves will figure out how to achieve the best results with empirical research.
He jokingly puts forward a number of sentences. For example, on the initiative of their president, colleagues could take a long study of the situation, experimentation and reform. "They could offer professors to use cash resources and free time to find new and best forms of conducting classes. They could hire highly qualified instructors for the full time instead of using senior students and" nomadic teachers "who are ready to take up subjects that are ready The permanent employees of the universities (for example, the courses of essays and foreign languages).
But will such measures be effective? The side itself silently admits that it is unlikely. At the end of his book, he writes that the “lack of real incentives for improving students' education” helps to explain the not too responsible attitude of professors to the needs of students; their neglect of basic courses intended to provide students with the opportunity to acquire useful mental skills; their reluctance to even discuss the problems of pedagogy; lack of interest in success (or failure) of students; and finally, unwrittenness; обращать внимание на то, что происходит за пределами их аудитории". Бок проиллюстрировал эту проблему, рассказав случай их жизни одного вуза, в котором администрация внесла новый вопрос в стандартную форму, используемую студентами общеобразовательных курсов для оценки своих преподавателей. Новый вопрос был сформулирован следующим образом: "Насколько этот курс содействовал развитию способности критически мыслить и анализировать проблемы?" О существенном развитии этой способности сообщили менее десяти процентов студентов. Бок комментирует:
"Когда подавляющее большинство учащихся считает, что общеобразовательная программа не достигает своей главной цели, следовало бы задуматься, что должны делать преподаватели и администрация для решения этой проблемы. Вместо этого вопрос просто исчез из стандартной оценочной формы и больше не возникал".
Но Бок отказывается видеть, о чем свидетельствует это обстоятельство. В лучшем случае он признает, в присущем ему спокойном, джентльменском тоне, что президенты и деканы, склонные к реформированию, часто наталкиваются на сопротивление и даже "бунты" со стороны преподавателей. Но "большинство профессоров - умные, думающие люди. Они не будут бесконечно занимать неплодотворную позицию, раз уж вопрос был поднят". На самом деле, однако, если его книга что-то и доказывает, так только то, что профессора по большей части лишены необходимого чувства профессиональной ответственности и служат главным препятствием для усовершенствования работы вузов. Если бы это было не так, проблем, о которых говорит Бок, просто не существовало бы.
Нельзя сказать, что он не осознает реального положения дел, которое намного хуже, чем можно заключить из его книги. "Возможно, недостатки в образовании студентов вполне реальны, - пишет он в одном месте, - однако они служат жизненно важным интересам профессорского состава" (подчеркнуто автором книги). В этом-то все и дело! Бок констатирует здесь существующую суровую реальность: именно профессорскому составу принадлежит в последние тридцать-сорок лет власть над университетскими кампусами. Поначалу складывается впечатление, что президенты, ректоры, деканы или попечители, имеющие более широкие взгляды на стоящие перед вузами цели, могли бы позаботиться о том, чтобы преподаватели более тесно сотрудничали с администрацией ради достижения этих целей. Но Бок ясно дает понять, что администрация по большому счету бессильна в этом отношении, равно как и попечительские советы. "Абсолютная власть над процессом обучения и его программами принадлежит профессорскому составу", в то время как администраторы и попечители парализованы "страхом вызвать недовольство преподавателей, которое могло бы привлечь нежелательное общественное внимание, встревожить потенциальных спонсоров и даже лишить их работы". В таких условиях трудно ожидать, что найдется много президентов колледжей или деканов, готовых вступить в бой с профессорским составом. Мне неизвестно, чтобы сам Бок делал что-нибудь подобное за двадцать лет своего президентства - чем и объясняется тот факт, что в это время в Гарварде царила тишь, гладь и божья благодать.
При таком положении вещей можно считать гарантированной полную бездеятельность перед лицом катастрофического снижения качества образования. Не видно никаких реформистских "инициатив снизу" - по той простой причине, что это неблагодарное дело: "успехи в повышении уровня образования студентов вознаграждаются крайне редко". В таких условиях можно только "катиться дальше вниз", ибо для президента университета самый верный способ добиться собственного увольнения - это вступить в конфликт с преподавательским составом. Если кто-то в этом еще сомневался, то события последних лет в Гарварде позволили всем заинтересованным лицам твердо усвоить соответствующий урок.
И Гарри Льюис, и Дерек Бок нарисовали ужасающую картину управления современными университетами - более ужасающую и саморазоблачительную, чем она сами это осознают. При том, что они иногда в отчаянии заламывают руки, позволяют себе завуалированную критику преподавательских комитетов и даже порой "профессуры как класса", - никто из этих временных администраторов не готов выступить с прямыми обвинениями против тех, кто сегодня реально управляет колледжами и университетами. В этом смысле они остаются слугами той самой системы, которая приводит к осуждаемым ими результатам.
Льюис, например, обрушивается с резкой критикой на Саммерса, который, будучи президентом Гарварда, по крайней мере пытался поколебать сложившуюся систему. Зато он в восторге как от Бока, так и от его преемника Нила Руденстайна, в годы управления которых ничто не нарушало безмятежного покоя профессуры, хотя вал отрицательных явлений, аккуратно запротоколированных тем же Льюисом, неизменно нарастал как по величине, так и по интенсивности.
Это не борьба за контроль над теми или иными "зонами" территории академии. Сама эта территория находится под угрозой. Перед университетом стоят две задачи: передача знаний и свободное культивирование идей. Выполнение обеих доверено профессуре - и обе ею провалены. Всемогущество профессорского корпуса, отвечающего на обоснованную критику в адрес образовательных программ "расслабляющей установкой на то, что студенты и дальше могут делать все, что им заблагорассудится" (Льюис), с тем чтобы сохранить за профессорами свободу преподавать только то, что им хочется, и при этом в удобное для них время, и - хотя Льюис об этом не упоминает - иметь возможность отбирать в качестве коллег только тех, кто разделяют их узкие политические взгляды, - более не служит задачам высшего образования. Вместо этого оно стало фактором, ведущим к их деградации.
При сложившейся системе ни одному президенту не удастся обуздать всемогущий профессорский корпус; почти никто из них и не пытается это сделать; и никто из принадлежащих к миру университетов или зараженных их замкнутой на себя культурой не встанет и не скажет "Довольно!", а если и скажет, то его никто не поддержит. Спасение, если оно еще возможно, должно прийти извне.
1 Public Affairs, 305 pp.
2 "Наши неуспевающие колледжи: правдивый рассказ о том, сколько занимаются студенты и почему они должны заниматься больше". (Our Underachieving Colleges: A Candid Look at How Much Students Learn and Why They Should Be Learning More). Princeton University Press, 424 pp.