From the editorial office. On September 21, 2009, a discussion on the topic "Is the post -Curular world will take place in the" Russian Institute "?" On the eve of the discussion, the Russian Journal offers readers an article by one of the main participants in the upcoming discussion - Pavel Kostylev, senior researcher at the Faculty of Philosophy of Moscow State University named after M.V. Lomonosov.
* * *
In recent years, we again and again return to the same seemingly long -leveling question: what is happening in the modern world with religion? Did the religion go forever - or on the contrary, returns from the ghetto, where did it try to drive it out? Religion becomes interesting: from a hobby and a secondary sign of conservative orientation, it again turns to the subject of conversation. Talking about religion, about its role in society is fashionable, and the easiest way to solve the problem is to publicly declare that religion has returned from the unknown and hardly beautiful to our daily life.
Today there are several ways to talk about religion:
In the firebox of the post -consumer world
The first is to talk about her in the format of the idea of the lost prodigal son, who, stena and bombing, suddenly falls to his native threshold and - suddenly, turns out to be a hero who is capable of all our problems overnight and without visible effort. When ours did not (kind), the honest ancestors drove religion and religious thinking into the ghetto of reason, religion dutifully left - but, from the point of view, he left to return (including because the apocalyptic principle of “ i'll be back ” has not yet been canceled).
As part of the picture of the return of the prodigal son, religion acts as a good wizard, who, in the means of moving the dubious color quickly, radically and, at first glance, will solve all our problems for free. Family problems? Turn to religion, and they will explain (and, perhaps, they will clearly demonstrate) that a strong family should be religious, because religion ensures the legitimization of social establishments - for example, marriage - not legally, and not even ethically, but ontologically, “from above”.
Work problems? The analogue of the Protestant ethics and the spirit of capitalism has not yet been reproduced by all religious traditions, but to explain that highly paid work does not contribute to the salvation of the soul in a state of almost everything . Children? It is time to introduce them into the cultural environment through religious education. Personal happiness? There is a confessor or a community. Would you like a strange one? Sorry, this is not to us.
Indeed, the picture of the returned religion warms the soul for several simple reasons. Firstly, society (as its intellectual layer often believes) needs an external legitimator, society cannot legitim itself, because the snake that bites its own tail exists only in the format of alchemical symbols, and not in real life. Religion naturally acts as a legitimator, since for the best, or rather - its upper half, it is declared as a transcendental, which society is not able to influence.
The second reason is the need for localization of space, within the framework of which a citizen has the right not to be himself. The sinner may be forgiven (the civil court does not provide forgiveness), the killer is equalized in the possibility of achieving paradise with other citizens in case of adoption of his repentance by God (and this is an aspect not amenable to empirical verification and therefore already encouraging). Finally, if religious norms are legitimized by public, the space of belonging to the sacred world of religious values will be relieved of legal, calculative in its very nature of social reality.
The post -seular world is an obsessive dream and persistent the dream of new orthodoxs of a variety of confessional affiliation. Distingulations between science and religion are burned in the furnace of the post -consumer world (it turns out that the conflict that seems inevitable, in fact is illusory), lose the significance of the discussion about the non -identity of religious reality of the actual - there is a kind of fact that instantly acquires flesh in the new history, characteristic of the representation of the post -texular world.
New History: Reloading
From the position of adherents of a post -texular approach to understanding modernity, the story carried out a full circle, bit itself by the tail (atheism and irreligiosity of the 20th century), was poisoned and died. The end of history came, but he, in turn, came to the end: thus, there was a reboot of the worldviews of mankind - and humanity has returned to the centuries of the proven opposition of the Holy World - and its worldly distorted reflection. The case of new (in this context) intellectuals is tirelessly polish the Amalgam of the mirror of the world (political system, ethical norm, aesthetic criterion, and so on), hoping - but reasonably, in the all -consuming fullness of Albedo, reflect the sacred hierarchy of religious tradition.
On the other hand, a few simple questions immediately arise to the concept of the post -consumer world: first of all, the lack of reliable and reproducible evidence of the arrival of the postsyular era is somewhat surprised. Whereas, for European religiosity, it is possible to talk about the collapse of secularism to a certain extent, one must not forget, firstly , that the map of the post -Christian worldview and forms of practice in modern Europe is increasingly being a bit of an Islamic map - either in the format of the Euro -osm, nevertheless aimed at partial integration with a European culture, or in the format of a Eurochalifate that perceives the concept of about The "Christian nature" of European consciousness as historical injustice. Here it is possible to appeal to the fact that Islam became a reality for Europe already in the middle of the VIII century - after the battle of the Guadel of 711, the defeat of the Visigoths and the start of the Arabs of the Pyrenee Peninsula, i.e. The perception of Europe as a historically Christian space is at best mythologem, and at worst - just ignorance.
Secondly , another claim to the post -consumer approach indicating the illegality of the transfer of the European situation to the whole world is possible; For example, what can be said about societies in which the post -Curular world can hardly occur, because, first of all, secularization itself has not passed? This, of course, is, first of all, about Islamic countries, but in the case of Buddhist oriented countries of the Far East, many difficult questions arise.
Ultimately, the concept of the post -consumer world, undoubtedly demonstrating its correctness, correctness and prospects in details, is incorrect as a whole - it is not confirmed by a significant part of sociological studies of religiosity, is closed on the European situation, erroneously understood as the situation of Christian harasses; Finally, he claims to be predictive - but is not confirmed by anything other than a set of intuitive premises - however, they should pay tribute to them, very convincing.
In the store of the necessary things
An alternative post -texular dream position equates religion to any other social institution, rubbing it from the first rows of the struggle for human attention to the side of the functional rituals (assignment, change and confirmation of the status), one of the traditional legitimators of social action and space for the painless implementation of the need for subordination and (or) unity.
From a perspective, rather traditional than modern, religion does not exist outside the ghetto , in the role of which the system of religious institutions acts. To talk about the “religion” of Moveton, religion was “not and not” (as they write in textbooks), which is more correctly presented to the arguments about “religious traditions”, “religious systems” and “religious phenomena”, as if the transformation of “religion” into an adjective relieves the need to determine it.
The instructive religion, from the standpoint of such a corrective -limiting approach, turns out to be one of the extremely necessary and, perhaps, useful things in the economy . Religious identity cements ethnic and, through it, strengthens civil self -awareness; The structuring of the population on a confessional basis is added by one of the levers of society management. Finally, in a situation of religious choice, religions have to, in search of optimal strategies for, if not distribution, then at least survival, find new, modern forms of expression of their alleged eternal content.
However, the reduction of religion to the systems of rituals and institutions made by it expresses a thirst for a secular consciousness to split the world, as a result of which, as it is “spaced” by the world, man, secular consciousness itself paradoxically turns out to be enchanted by its own intuitions. A simple way to criticize secularism lies in opening its subonos, as which we are perplexed by the semantic emptiness of an economic or psychoanalytic warehouse.
In fact, if we argue that the causes of religion were socio -economic conditions or psychological attitudes, then it is completely incomprehensible why, when changing these conditions and attitudes, religion does not disappear now. If the religion does not have its own reason, if it is the reflected form of another, then it should either disappear when the conditions change (and it does not disappear), or it should be recognized that the conditions cannot be dramatically changed - but such an idea turns any attempt to comprehend religion as a form of expression of another into a kind of farce, since another ceases to be perceived by a transformed and distorted form of something genuine (otherwise it would be Fixed during the historical process).
So, when understanding religion as external, functional in relation to the society of the system of rituals and the self -uniform - indicated norms expressed in a particular institution, we are faced with the contradiction: if religion is like that, it is akin to the trade union or guild - and then it makes no sense to talk about religion, then religion in the modern world is dead, and this is still too sharp conclusion. If the religion of INAKOV, the entire conceptual system for the distribution of religion into the context of public institutions and universally used nonspecific functions, collapses.
Perhaps in the future - it is difficult to say whether this picture is a pessimistic position - the presented position will be able to confirm: the religion will either turn into something radically different, or it will simply disappear, but as long as this does not happen, the idea of religion as a product, product and service in the market of social functions should be revised to a certain extent.
Uzurping the Pontiff's chair
The description of the situation, which today seems to us the most accurate, does not correlate very well with the views on the existence of religion in modern society classic for its time. First of all, because both the first and second paintings are intuitive, convincing, applying for a certain ontology and is already unlikely to be correct. The below proposed by the view is contributive; The possibility of his falsification is great (and this is one of the criteria of scientificity), finally, he reveals the whole picture from a rather unexpected position.
So, we will make the following assumption. We will separate, in order to ultimate accuracy of understanding, religion from the place that she once (and partly now) occupied in society. Our proposal is to waste the content of religious from its functions in society (which may change).
Within the framework of the proposed worldview, religion is a pontiff, combining, as follows from etymology, the world of earthly with the world of the sacred. One can argue with this fundamental division (for example, whether it is applicable to oriental cultures), but religion, in any case, is a certain historically established structure of connections between various cultural, worldview and behavioral prerequisites.
In the initial sense, religious is not the one who believes in God or the gods, but the one whose attitude towards them is contextally religiously (belongs to the context of religious tradition) and is expressed in practices that are considered to be religious in the society in which we strive to understand a person or a group of people (religious person or religious group - a religious community as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity as a unity believers).
The function of religion in society is a kind of pontiff chair . In a situation of primacy of historical religions over any other forms of religiosity, pontiff and pontiff chair, religion is substantial and the functions of religion are united and thought by one. In a situation characteristic of modernity, the pontiff left the building (and in this sense a picture of the market of religions, converted to complexes with hierarchized membership, consistent of the presented). This is our hypothesis.
But the Pontiff's chair was busy with something completely different.
Tango with strangers
At the place of religion in the Pontiff's chair, it turned out to be a completely different, in our opinion, still no accurate name, no intelligible definition, essence (or essence). In fact, we should talk about the werewolf, Verlioka, which takes place of religion, performing its function, but inaccessible to it in content.
Among the examples are an ideology that has long crossed the framework of one of the forms of worldview, becoming a universal legitimator of any worldview that could be as motivated. Once upon a long time, even in our galaxy with you, the term “engaging” was, sorry for the expression, abusive. Now the commitment of ideology, a new party science, is a warning to ontology, its basic condition.
The essence that Tillich and Smart tried to bring to clean water under the terms “quasi -religion” and “worldview”, it has firmly occupied the above chair, combining with the position of religion and, naturally, taking its functions in society. The best example of such a “stranger” from the field of the evolution of religion in the modern world is the so -called “New Age” ( New Age ), which are first completely fragmented, and then completely defragmented and re -established religious consciousness (however, without a cult, tradition, and not requiring systematization of ideas).
***
In this situation, we must stop talking about religion in the modern world with an effort and tension of reason. Nowadays, religion, or rather, what was called religion all the path of human history, has become an institutional appendage of society, and not an independent force. May historians talk about her.
Today, a new force entered the arena, which took the place of religion and so far did not receive a name - no worthy definition. This force usurped the functions of religion; In part, it is reflected in the phenomenon of the dominance of ideology, quasi -religious forms, movements of New Age . It is hoped that it is precisely its study that modern researchers of culture, religion and, in general, are paying attention to its attention.