
The question is whether intellectual television in Russia is possible today is rather a smile. Is television possible today at all? What do we mean by TV - a entertainment box, a narcotic drug, a nauseating sleeping pill, indifferent to everything, the screen created for mechanical broadcasting, or a mirror of public life? It would be easier to think that it was the mirror: what to blame him in difficult times? Whether it is a west ...
But to consider Western experience is an ambiguous lesson. Most of my acquaintances of Europeans and even Americans practically do not watch TV, and some do not have a TV. We are talking about in their own way of happy people: they do not need television as a means of communication, since they are united by newspapers and magazines, not to mention books.
Those who touch the remote control live in fundamentally different television than Russians. The publicly accessible state channels in Europe are spared, as a rule, from advertising, especially after eight in the evening. But both commercial and regional channels in Germany do not look complete idiots. Among the most interesting so -called third channels belonging to the federal lands are the TV of Bavaria and Hesse. From Munich, all day they can convey sweet-mailing songs that singers in folk dresses perform in the middle of huge beer halls (an analogue of our pseudo-folklore programs of stagnant pores). And in the prime time there are films about nature or art. There are a lot of cognitive programs on German TV - about ancient Egypt and baroque architecture, writers of the twentieth century and science. They are captivating not only the quality of performance, but also the independence of the look. This is about the Russian Museum, the Hermitage or the Bolshoi Theater is told by their directors, and an interview with the actor or director takes a high -ranking official from culture. In Europe, this is unstable. There, the image of society is not created by him, society, top managers. They have other tasks.
There are two phenomena in the German -speaking world that our television agents are talking through teeth. These are channels "Arte" and "3SAT". The latter is made with the Austrians and the Swiss. Here, even current information is submitted through the analytics. Every evening the program "Kulturzeit" ("Culture time") is published-40-minute news built around 3-4 cultural reports. Their language is not like the texts of the program of Vladislav Flyarkovsky. The latter is rather a retelling, preferring to state the point of view (close to the autopoir) of creators, but not experts. "3SAT" strives for an analytical dossier, in every cultural event, finding a public lining, public significance. The journalists themselves keep in the shade, the faces of correspondents are practically not shown. But the language of both the host and correspondents are not alien to modern philosophical vocabulary, which is natural for the channel that has opened its own “television academy”, broadcasting full lectures from the largest German universities. Politics pierces all the news: the death of the Nazi criminal of the Pope is next to the discussion about whether Li Luther himself wrote his theses, and the report of our film "Stalin.live" in the light of the approaching elections.
So in one television "3SAT" there are a lecture by a professor of Frankfurt University Axel Honnet "Justice and Freedom of Communication - Reflections in connection with Hegel", a film about Gidona Kremere and his "Kremrata Baltic", a recording of the Schubertov "Winter Travel" performed by Peter Schrayer and Christopheis Eschenbach, a film -ballet to the music of Steve Raich, "Literary The club "For 45 minutes, the program about the Zurich zoo, documentary tapes about the Brazilian city of Salvador de Bahia and the Museum of Natural History in Karlsruhe.
"Arte", led by the famous "public philosopher" Bernar-Henri Levy, is made by the Germans and French. Most evenings are thematic here-about African life, animation, drugs or stealing works of art ... Within four to six hours, they will show a current show on the topic, a couple of documentary reports, one or two feature film ... "Arte" can afford to put a half-hour transmission of Edward Munku in the prime-time (after three weeks in the basket, his retrospective is opened), And the main movie consumption to make the American comedy of 1953 directed by John Negudo.
And so - every evening.
They say that the phenomenon of "smart television" (with the abundance of channels of vulgar and meaningless) is generated by the quality of German universities. Say, in Germany there are many graduates who are accustomed to life for life, and therefore those in need of appropriate food for the mind.
But the appearance of such high -quality TV looks like a normal reaction to intellectual minorities, which determine the country's life. Even if the Arte rating is incomparable with mass channels, no one will close it. (Although at first the French parliament, belonging to the right, made an attempt if not to directly change the policy of the channel, then at least deal with its personnel; what our State Duma would have taken twenty minutes in France did not happen.)
Yes, the "smart" channels are watching a minority. In cheap television highlands that go out once a month (the usual format in Germany for such publications - once every two weeks), the Arte program can be printed in abbreviated form. But newspapers of the mental front, such as Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung or Sueeddeutsche Zeitung, serve 3SAT and Arte as first -order phenomena. Though mental work, although a small niche is given, but the degree of respectful attitude to it overcomes its size. The intellectual in the West is small in quantity, but great weight; This is not an outcast, but an honorary relative who came from afar: what to talk about with him is not very clear, but it is always happy to see him.
In this sense, the groans of Russian televisionballs about dependence on television are more likely to be Freudian in nature. It seems that they are based on the traditional dislike of the masses to the intelligentsia, which is increasingly voiced by the TV-officials themselves in the format "The people speaks of our lips." Not the most stupid people are engaged in voicing these views, and therefore they sometimes look quite cynical (some examples are given here ).
Freedom of statement on Russian television has acquired in recent years bizarre forms resembling the kingdom of the Snow Queen: you will not have time to open your mouth, as it has already frozen. Therefore, Western intellectual talk shows differ dramatically from ours. Firstly, they go live, and not on the record. Secondly, there are no shameful situations when there are lists of Person Non-Gart on European television. Unless the Nazis are unlikely to be invited to the general discussion table - and then rather on their own initiative than by a secret indication from above (right radicals are usually bad speakers). There are few unspoken in the work of the European media in general, their transparency is ensured by an endless analysis of the situation in the printed press (our best commentators, such as Sergey Varshavchik, change the battlefield, others, like Irina Petrovskaya, begin to engage in weekly announcements).
European talk shows look different than Russian, and thanks to the atmosphere. Her relaxation is so fascinating that it does not even matter how much she is or natural. Nobody keeps his own tongue, thinking painfully, will call you next time or not. All the details are important here, even who sits like. For comparison, the two programs of the Channel "Culture" - "Apocrypha" and "Meanwhile". Both are built according to the "teacher and student" scheme. The permanent presenters occupy a central, royal place in them. Erofeev’s right hand is sitting two especially invited, who talk with the “class”. Arkhangelsky’s everything is at the same table, but the camera initially distinguishes the host, and his manner not to turn to the interlocutors, but to a telephoto object (i.e. to the people) in Europe would be perceived as disrespect to those with whom he formally conducts a dialogue. It is noteworthy to divide into elect and especially elected: in the hall near Arkhangelsky there is always “piano in the bushes” from among the characters, in principle no less interesting than those who are sitting at the table. But they give little time for the performance, the deployment of statements is minimal (meanwhile, on “their” TV usually they talk with each guest for ten minutes). As a result, it looks like a seminar where the professor conducts the choir of novice students. This is especially pronounced on the show of Mikhail Shvydky, sometimes reminiscent of a session of collective speed -firing psychotherapy. At a crazy pace, those present blurt out 2-3 phrases (rarely anyone can move away from a set of banalities during this time), which create a rather information and shum backword than an intellectual field. And the advanced desire of the presenter to summarize the incident (or occurring, but never happened) discussion of important things and completely resembles meetings of the party committee. There, the secretary, especially the visiting man, was obliged to evaluate what happened in the light of the last attitudes of the Central Committee.
In the West, a talk show is a conversation of equal, devoid of hard modulation, natural and free, resembling friendly gatherings (and not between the parties), the phase of the feast, when everyone has already managed to drink, but has not yet been drunk. Here, they joke a lot (everything is either deliberately aggressive or catastrophically serious, as if they were in front of the broadcast), they give them in detail to another, the leading is assigned the role of a moderator-interviewer, offering new turns of the theme, and not an all-knowing mentor.
The participants of our talk shows belong to the sphere of not analytical, but mass media, vulgarized-hubby, a space that is closer to the current "Izvestia" and "MK" than with "Kommersant" and "Vedomosti". As a result, our talk show is similar to a domestic auto industry: there is a lot of efforts, the conditionality of the product tends to zero.
To summarize what has not yet happened, to comment on the event whose mechanism remained a mystery to the viewer, this is the peculiarity of the current Russian television poetics. It is built around an assessment that arises outside the real discussion, the myth suppresses and crushes everything for itself, the opinions of experts are drowning in the choir of banalities.
Is such a life as a product of intellectual censorship or only reproduces the stamps of the telechic consciousness? How much this censorship is perceived by those whom, in fact, it is censored? The discussion on this subject in Russian society is practically not conducted.
A civilized state can and should take the protection of the rights of intellectual minorities. But in the eyes of the State Machine, all minorities - both national, and religious, and intellectual - are equally unprofitable and irrelevant. It remains only to convince the minority themselves of the correctness of this gaze.