
The " island " of Pavel Lungin is not a masterpiece in the film understanding of the word. Sinefils will not be delighted with an excessively straightforward plot, long, admiring the beauty of the Russian North (which were supposed to emphasize the special spirituality of everything that is happening), from the very expected game of the main actors. The claim of the "island", replicated by critics and the media, was obviously incorrectly expressed. Instead of talking about achieving cinema, "Cinema for directors", we should talk about an attempt to "new folk cinema." Hence frequent comparisons with films busy searching for a national hero, for example with Forrest Gamp (it’s good that not with Citizen Kane.)
In the "Island" it is embarrassed and, as it were, the director’s desire, there is a rejection of the standard separation, which prevails in domestic film products, where the "author's cinema" can arise, which becomes festival or movie as an object of consumption, which does not exclude artistic qualities, but also not putting them at the forefront. The “consumer” cinema is quite clearly associated with a certain set of topics, plots, installation methods, etc., and all of them are not original in Russia (if you view all variations of this type - from TV shows and reality shows to blockbusters like “patrols”). In other words, only a movie that directly or indirectly supported the created structure of consumption, in which the cinema is either embedded during the pastime on the evening couch, could rely on consumption in Russia, or is a background of visiting a shop-cinema. "Island" is a desire to destroy this structure, make a movie that they will consume (since it should be important for everyone), but consume differently.
This desire does not arise for the first time, and Lungin is not his only carrier. After the “brother”, the gesture of the modern Russian director is a certain “nationalization” of the movie, its transformation into something at the same time highly artistic, interesting to the overwhelming majority and, most importantly, telling a certain hidden truth about the spectators themselves. They must see themselves, but so that in what they saw is new, so that they are surprised that they were shown in this form. In short, the new cinema is simply obliged to show the Russian people a national idea in a full-screen version.
Attempts to solve such a problem are interesting and inter -perplified. However, the solution found by Lungin makes not such a good impression. Taking a highly spiritual topic for the film does not mean making a good film. But it is such a thought that is inspired by the viewer. Spirituality as a traditional Russian idea of recent years is distributed by steps, as in catapathic theology. The more “holy” the topic, the better the tape should turn out. The cinema should gradually move away from the "worldly reality" (where Bannian and corrupt officials live) in order to more adequately display the life of saints, or even heavenly forces. What are these saints from the island, on which, apparently, the mass viewer should be equal to who is demonstrated as a sermon?
The decision of the "island" is simple - Russia and the Soviet Union do not differ from each other, because both in the first and the second there is "island". Russia - in accordance with still popular journalistic theories - is this small island, lost in the cold seas. On the periphery there is "official Russia", that is, Russia, replacing each other rulers, ranks, social experiments, wars, etc. It does not exist on its own, but as an application to the island, which is self -sufficient. The "island", or a pop -up kitezh, turns out to be a timeless component of historical Russia, as well as the lives of all people who can turn to the island - for advice or comfort.
It looks quite dogmatic. But such dogma does not contain intrigue. In the "island" the minimum intrigue is created due to the fact that the main character - Father Anatoly - is not just an "old man". De fact is a small war criminal who is hidden in a monastery from Soviet justice. (Unfortunately, the topic of evasion of justice is not even scheduled for general strokes.) The tie determines the further development of the "national" cinema offered by Lungin, and the nature of the film. As was said, such a movie should be not only "ideological", but also "spectacular." However, the director did not succeed in synthesis. The general frame of the idea is too trivial. The entertainment is ensured by simple gags performed by Mamonov and his duet with Sukhorukov. And actually artistic achievements were lost between attempts to revive realism and symbolic reminiscences.
This, however, does not cancel the need for careful reading of the "Film Carry", which replaced the film truth. The replacement itself suggests that in modern cinema there is no such truth that it would be interesting to watch and which would stun the viewer, problematized his situation not due to horrors. True, it is delayed to better times, since the present is the time of repentance. Father Anatoly (Mamonov) has been repenting for several decades, gradually acquiring the quality of the saint. But just in this paragraph "instructive" tasks of the "island" look unresolved and unsolved.
The theme of foolishness is one of the most difficult for Orthodoxy since Byzantium. If you touch it briefly, the holy fool always returns to the thesis of Paul about "madness and scandal" - for the Hellenes and Jews, that is, for two centers of culture. But the holy fool can hardly find himself in the functions of the preacher - he can be too easily confused by an ordinary person. The film, of course, must tell the viewer: "Repent!" But the figure of repentance itself is depicted so that the "great" sin of Anatoly is interpreted as the pledge of his holiness. In the end, it is surrounded by normal people: Father Job is an ordinary manager, although with education, Father Filaret is a weak -chased boss with his small weaknesses, although not without a sense of humor. But the number of gifts of Anatoly is not amenable to calculus - he heals, predicts the future, expels demons. The film clearly shows that Anatoly, in principle, is not able to play the role of a preacher, because he seeks to hide from people, constantly impersoning another. If we assume that the film itself must perform such a function, it turns out that only the one who has something to repent can truly repent.
We need repentance in especially large sizes. Repentance as a personality transformation is embodied in Anatolia, but its case seems too single and unique so that the model of such repentance is widespread. It is not clear why to repent to everyone else.
This is not to say that such problems could be attributed to the director. To attract the viewer to such plots is almost the same as dragging into the church service with the help of rock concerts. The old rocker Mamonov, of course, copes with the role, but remains too exceptional, unusual, exalted, as well as his case, so that the idea found in Orthodoxy has become really national. The holy fool is the last instance in the Soviet (and, obviously, modern Russian) world, which is addressed after all. After the district committees, regional committees, courts and cancer corps have been passed, it remains to go to the island to an anatoly, like a chicken, like a chicken. It turns out that both Orthodoxy and God are simply the most important bosses. This is well shown on the example of a woman who brought a boy with a sore foot to Anatoly - after prayer she seeks to go to the "work" as soon as possible. And rightly - it is better to face the authorities less often. The double exclusivity of the holy fool - as a person with an absolutely unique fate and as the highest authorities (he does not even submit to his abbess) - makes him a figure that can consolidate the attitude to Orthodoxy, which already exists. That is, the attitude is pragmatic, and even pagan.
The island as the "region" of the Russian land becomes a place of magical resolution of all problems. In this sense, he is similar to the place that the heroes of the Stalker strive for. He is outside of society, he cannot but save this society - as a kind of balancer, balancing any shocks, external and internal. In the same sense, the solution of all problems and the figure of Anatoly itself closes in an absolutely flat denouement - the person who he killed is alive, risen. The victim and the killer forgive each other, after which Anatoly dies, and his coffin floats in a boat into the fog. Lungin is not Dostoevsky, the severity of the deed here is miraculously canceled. Anatoly acquires icon -painting simplicity, completely loses some unlawfulness and bends, even more moving away from ridiculous Soviet citizens who come to him with their problems. Anatoly is “chosen”, and few are lucky as he is.
Despite all the claims for the preaching, the “height” of the topic taken in the “island” - as if to lead all the ideological reasons - inevitably leads to the same “spirituality” that is obviously not for everyone. Spirituality is existential elitism. There is no significant difference between Kitezh-Ostrov and Shambhala: both of them are not for a worldly person who does not understand what it is until he is tapping something heavy. They are opposed to "soullessness", which penetrates everywhere - even into the monastery - and which only the Escapades of the holy fool, who does not obey any of the people and not recognizing any order can resist. The main thing, the desired national idea of Russia is always extraterritorial for it, like the death of Kashchei for Kashchei. The "metaphysical" territory of Russia is arranged on the principle of nesting dolls - inside the island there is another island that will always remain, but which you can not know about - for the time being. That is, until the moment when something or someone does not move you - most likely, through gross violence - to another, "internal", island. The only question is what to do if everyone wants to move to this "real" island prematurely, to the tests sent by fate. And, even more interesting, what to do to those who remained on the mainland if they know what should be on the island?