
Another literary competition is held on " network literature ". As the initiator of this competition and one of the jury members, I would like to talk about literary competitions in general. Why are they needed? What do we find out in such competitions? Without understanding this, one can neither understand the meaning of the jury, nor properly read the works of the winners.
We will inevitably have to touch on a more general question: in what sense in general one literary work can be better or worse than another. Therefore, I want to start with a long retreat and briefly retell the way the most influential school in domestic literary criticism understands the development of literature - the school of formalists, which included scientists such as Tynyanov, Shklovsky, Eichenbaum.
I propose to compare the literary evolution described by formalists with biological evolution in Darwin. This comparison is useful for understanding literature not because Darwin theory seems true to me (on the contrary, it seems to me paradoxical), but because Darwin's theory is well known and is a good model of literary evolution, which will help us understand some dark places in the theory of formalists.
The very idea of comparing these two evolutions (or any two evolution) is not new, but it is difficult to correctly choose the scale of comparison. The biological species and literary text are united by the following important property: the choice of their characteristics and their original niche among existing types and texts occurs at the time of their creation, and then their characteristics remain unchanged throughout the entire time of their existence. Thus, the atom of biological inheritance is the species, and the atom of literary inheritance makes sense to consider a separate text. You can compare Darwin's attitude to the views with the attitude of formalists to the works (in a joke, we can say that, for example, “Eugene Onegin” is a birch, “war and peace” is a hippo, etc.).
One literary text can neither be better nor worse than the other; Talking about such a comparison is as pointless as comparing which type is biologically more perfect: a giraffe or a camel, a cactus or cranberries. Here you can say: how can it be, because it is obvious that Hamlet or Odyssey is important texts. In fact, sometimes (not always) you can compare texts by which of them is more important. This is how it is done. In biology, in some cases, it makes sense to say that a particular species was especially important for biological evolution - if a large number of existing species came from this species. In the same way, it can be argued that some literary text was important for literary evolution if a large number of new literary texts inherit this text. Of course, this assessment can not be given not immediately, but only a few centuries after the occurrence of the text (on the scale of literary evolution) or several tens of millions of years after the appearance of the species (on the scale of biological evolution). The assertion that any new text will be important for literary evolution does not make sense. In general, when formalists say that we cannot predict the development of literature and manage the development of literature, this is as true as the fact that we (although we are already able to create individual new species) cannot lead the creation of species and the evolution of species on a global scale.
As I said, one literary text can be neither better nor worse than the other - this is true insofar as we consider their literary dignity. In the same way, one biological species can neither be better nor worse than the other. However, when we consider the biological world in its relations with humanity, the species form a complex multidimensional hierarchy in its utility - uselessness - harmfulness - dangers, and we have not at all the same attitude to beaver and cobrales, pines and elephants, pigs and guinea pigs, cucumbers and sea cucumbers, etc. In the same way, different literary texts can be useful - useless - harmful - dangerous in one way or another.
Now back to the conversation about competitions. The jury members are asked to evaluate which work presented to the competition is better than another; Inside the literature, such a comparison does not make sense; Consequently, each jury member will apply extraovitative evaluation criteria. Thus, the jury members are representatives of the company who decide which literature is more valuable to society at the moment. We give two simple examples. Suppose that a jury member makes such a choice (consciously or unconsciously): to evaluate all the texts with mentioning religion as good, and all the texts with mentioning sex and drugs are as bad. In this example, it is obvious that the assessment criteria, selected A, lie outside of literature, and that but evaluates the texts in accordance with their understanding of the role of literature in society. Now suppose that the jury member decides to evaluate only the literary virtues of the texts in accordance with its (conscious or unconscious) literary taste. At first glance, it may seem that more correctly, “more literary” approaches the assessment of works than A. However, this is an illusion. In fact, the assessment criteria made a non -power selection twice: the first time when he decides to evaluate only the literary virtues of the texts, and the second time decides what literary features of the work he will consider “good” and which are “bad”. Both that, and another gives his view of the role of literature in society.
So, we understood how the jury works: the jury members act as representatives of modern society, collectively deciding what literature our society needs. Now let's discuss how to read the "best" works selected by the jury. If this is really a contest, and not a between the man, then different authors send different texts to the competition. The main thing here is that these texts are different, that is, they represent different trends in modern literature. The jury members choose several texts by the winners of the competition, thus arguing that such and such is especially important for a modern society from existing trends in modern literature. The jury does not claim that the winning texts are better than the rest from a literary point of view, since there is no word “better” inside the literature. In addition, the jury does not claim that the victorious texts will turn out to be more durable or have a greater impact on the further development of literature than other texts presented for the competition. The only result of the competition is a clear and undoubted indication of which texts are more important and more interesting to modern society.
From here, by the way, it follows that the jury is always right. In each era, it is guided by other criteria for evaluating works, in addition, assessments of different members of one jury diverge somewhat, but the jury as a whole always expresses the view of society on art at the moment. Of course, you can tell me that the “look of society” is an abstraction and that in fact different parts of society are different about the works that modern authors offer society. The case is also confused by the fact that the literary tastes of a person are not determined by its class, floor, nationality, but exist independently of these "objective" questionnaires. Is it follows from this that literary contests are meaningless? No, this follows completely different: that a literary competition is not a way by which society can learn something new about art, but a way by which society can learn something new about itself.
With some reservations, it can be argued that art has always existed, from the very beginning of the existence of human society. Competitions in art are also an ancient invention. The ancient Greeks already understood that competitions exist for what was described above - to identify the perception of art by modern society, and to expect something else to be stupid from them (so stupid Apollo, offended by the king of Midas in the legend in which Midas judged the competition of musicians). Since literary contests are an ancient and unchanged satellite of literature, it can be assumed that humanity needs no less than literature itself. Nowadays, a market competition, on the one hand, is a postmodern theory of art, on the other hand, try to cancel any other types of competitions. However, in culture, more new often turns out to be superficial, optional and, therefore, less durable. I am sure that literary contests will be held in that distant future, when there will be neither a market economy nor modern literary theories.