
The dangers of the so -called left turn in the Russian political system were spoke on September 18 at a meeting of the Political Action Club "November 4" members of the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation, leading political and public figures, and leaders of political parties.
The club’s meeting was devoted to discussing changes in the party system of Russia in connection with the leaders of the “Russian Party of Life”, the Rodina and the “Russian Party of Pensioners” of their association into the new left -centric party “Rodina. Pensioners. Life Union of trust”.
The organizers of the event stated that the relevance of the topic is also determined by the fact that the coming “political year” is actually election, and the changes that take place can significantly affect the alignment of political forces both during the 2007 election campaign and in the future parliament.
The main dispute turned on the topic whether today there is an electoral group of the left political parties, what are its interests, values and needs.
The chairman of the Committee of the State Duma of the Russian Federation on constitutional law and party construction began discussion Vladimir Pligin. According to him, the ideas of the “left” are controversial ideas: “They (the left - ed. ) Through the implementation of social subsidies and compensations, demonstrate an open transition to the“ request technologies ” - this, in turn, gives rise to the inhabitability and stiffness of Russian society, society and the state should not do what a person is able to do for himself.” According to Pligin, the political technologies of the Central and liberal-conservative-prompting parties, on the contrary, make it possible to realize human potential.
“Sometimes a desire to create a kind of technology of“ requests ”is demonstrated, however, its development is adversely for the country, since it gives rise to internal stiffness, uninitiation, leads to the abandonment of responsibility and its transfer to the state,” Pligin said.
"This technology is primarily beneficial for unscrupulous politicians who build its election campaign on inexpensive promises to help financially, and state bureaucracy," he concluded.
The picture of the real Russian society and the cut of its needs was presented to the public by the head of the research department of the Institute of Public Design Mikhail Tarusin, demonstrating the results of the sociological study "Real Russia".
It turned out that the “left group”, according to the results of the study, has about six percent of the population in the country. However, the value preferences of this group intersect both with the "centrists" and with the "right", so it is quite difficult to highlight a group with obvious "left" preferences, according to Tarusin. The situation is also complicated by the fact that in Russian society there are a large number of people with blurry political worldview.
Confirmed the main provisions of the study of the Inopa, the head of the analytical department of VTsIOM Leonty Byzov:
The “value hierarchy of the“ new left ”today is different than it was five or six years ago when the“ left shift ”occurred. This is due to the fact that another group of people - the Putin middle class turned to the proclaimed social values of the left.
According to him, the “left request” that exists today is strong enough and interesting, first of all, from an electoral point of view. "The new party has good chances to overcome the seven percent barrier, but there is no chance to get along with the same United Russia - this is a political issue."
The state of the party system in Russia member of the Social Chamber of the Russian Federation Alexei Chadaev called the state of the party system. In his opinion, modern parties do not cover the required number of citizens, the parties are outside the agenda and lead a political discussion at a low level.
“Party brands are moving into franchising regions,” Chadaev began, “and the partization in Russia is formal.”
So, according to him, today membership in United Russia has become in the regions a virtually synonym for nemarginal political functioning. For the “second party”, according to Chadaev, there is a certain structural niche: “The Second Party” - a place for the “Luzers of the party struggle, the public opponulation of the Party of power”.
However, according to Chadaev, there is the possibility of the emergence of the “second batch” of the left -wing one from the United Russia itself, this assumption already arose when they talked about the presence of “wings” in the party in power.
Further, the discussion smoothly flowed into the discussion of the ideologies of the left, right and centrist parties. The participants in the discussion, representing a particular party, tried to seem to rehabilitate, quoting excerpts from party ideology.
The prospects for the functioning of the "EP" as the Party Party of Putin were spoke by another member of the OP, president of the Legislative Initiatives Support Fund Grigory Tomchin.
The presence on the political front of the monoparty system, according to Tomchi, is fraught with the death of parliamentarism. “Elected legislation is the only step that moves us to parliamentarism,” Tomchin said.
Other participants in the round table tried to assign responsibility for conducting a political discussion on the shoulders of United Russia. So, Boris Nadezhdin, secretary of the Federal Political Council for the legislative activity of the ATP, asked United Russia as soon as possible to nominate his presidential candidate: “We must make the parties put forward their candidates for presidents,” Nadezhdin said, “and in this regard I am highly hoped for“ United Russia ”. According to the Nadezhdin, you can deal with the danger of left -handed too much non -sectical way.
The far -reaching plans of United Russia were told by the deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Budget and Taxes, a member of United Russia Igor Igoshin. According to him, "the upcoming elections will be the election of loyal left centrism, with the involvement of" right slogans ", so he proposed to fight these trends with the help of" United Russia ", which, according to him, did not engage in, unlike other parties, with its revolutionary."
Gleb Pavlovsky, President of the Effective Policy Fund for Effective Policy, spoke about the threat of a society, "accustomed to remembrance.
“Today there is a group focused on“ remembrance ”, and it is now in the competence of Putin, but Putin in 2008 is leaving, forming a new field that has a new framework,” Pavlovsky remarked, “there is no topic of a political system in the agenda, changes can only be internal - there is a topic of strengthening the economy and progressive renewal of society.”
The danger, according to Pavlovsky, is that the "left" can interpret the Putin system. “Now, - according to Pavlovsky, Putin has a shift in rhetoric and positions, and Putin will continue to defend new positions, but this can take advantage of the parties in the populist, however, while Putin is in power, he himself serves as a“ barrier ”for populism.
Irina Rukina, a member of the Presidium of the National Council, chairman of the Council of the Moscow City Branch of the Russian Party of Life, spoke about the abandonment of populism in the program of the new left -centric party and forecasts for future elections. "Those parties that are closer to the people, which include representatives of public organizations, will win in the election."
The chairman of the Rodina party, Alexander Babakov, abandoned the sharp formulation regarding the existence of the danger of the “left -wing sense”. According to him, there is no threat in this and this process is natural.
Deputy Chairman of the State Duma Committee on Economic Policy, Entrepreneurship and Tourism Vladimir Medinsky and General Director of the APEC agency Dmitry Orlov did not agree with Alexander Babakov. They offered their vision of the resolution of the “left problem”. According to Medinsky, today in Russian society there is a “split personality”: when the majority of the country's population identifies itself ideologically with the right, and in the elections votes for “left” slogans - this is irrational and incorrect. The weakness of all existing parties, according to Medinsky, is that all of them are created according to the “vertical principle” and are well controlled depending on the requirements of the political situation, and the future is behind parties organized according to the “network principle”.
According to Dmitry Orlov, political parties in Russia should not at all concentrate on the "right" or "left" positions, but should "turn to the values of society depending on the political situation."
The leading round table, the editor -in -chief of the Expert magazine, summarized the performances of the discussion, director of the Institute of Public Design Valery Fadeev, wishing it to the participants to build a political system adequate to their own country.