
The unification of two people close in culture, the composition of the population, the historical past of the Slavic states - Russia and Belarus - one of the favorite election topics of the most diverse politicians, both in Russia and in Belarus.
Not a single large federal election campaign in Russia has been complete without it for the past 10 years. However, some elections are held for others, an agreement is signed by the agreement "On an even greater deepening integration", but nothing changes. It does not change in the eyes of people who were promised in words, but gave the usual interstate cooperation.
In fact, the Russian -Belarusian Union is only a tool for manipulating mass consciousness , just as the notorious "Year of Ukraine", etc. I.T.p.
Since the mass consciousness that believes in myths is about to constantly wait for “integration, it seems to be tired, it finally appears a chance to translate the problem of Russian-Belarusian integration from propaganda into the sphere of political reality-it is honest in the population that there can be no talk of any uniting one state of the Russian Federation and Belarus. It can only be about the close (absolutely necessary and natural) cooperation of two close states on the most wide range of issues.
The term "union state" itself is essentially an attempt to deceive mass consciousness - both the Russian Federation and Belarus remain sovereign states, and the state cannot enter the state. There are no states that do not have sovereignty. Forming the so -called The “Union State” is actually not even a confederation (there should be at least a single currency in the Confederation - which the “Union State” seems to not have), the authorities of the Russian Federation and Belarus were initially manipulated by mass nostalgia for “Soviet times”, and this absolutely certainly reflected the mood of mass consciousness. Another thing is that these sentiments have no longer had anything to do with political reality. It is enough to recall that the signing of supposedly “historical documents” occurred at the height of the presidential election campaign of B. Yeltsin in 1996.
The collapse of the Soviet identity, which happened overnight due to the August U -turn of 1991, left society in a rather difficult situation. As in the rest of the post -Soviet space, in Belarus, as a result, there was no “frame” ideology that allows society to act as a whole. The myth of the "restoration of the USSR" in the conditions of the vacuum of state ideology was out of competition.
According to the famous specialist in Belarus K. Koktysh, this myth gave rise to the power to improve its position - being extremely simple in its structure of causes and consequences, he assumed a chain of completely “obvious” actions and, as it were, made the culprit of the crisis and a vast deterioration in the country not Belarusian power, but some objective circumstances. In an understandable way, in this request, reality and myth changed places, and not the first began to cultivate the latter as a “balancer”, and the myth received legitimate right to inspire reality in accordance with his canons. The prerequisites arose for the “fundamentalist” coup and for the coming to the power of the corresponding charismatic, the “true” leader, which A. Lukashenko became.
The project, however, remained nothing more than an illusion. Both the Customs Union, concluded in January 1995, and subsequent agreements on the Union State were nothing more than the development of the original formula "resources in exchange for loyalty."
Over the entire period of the Union, the issues of real integration have never gone beyond the PR project. The fundamental absence of the achievements of the Yeltsin regime, which society would be ready to recognize as such, gave at that time the role of the union that used mass support for the idea of the Union almost key to Russia's internal stability. Actually, this explains the role of the “sacred cow”, which the Union myth in Russia more than quickly found in Russia - it simply could not present anything else to society.
Thus, the problem of the Russian-Belarusian Union lies in two areas: mass consciousness led by the myths of the Renaissance of the USSR (and for many in the Russian Federation-and the myth of "Great Russia"), and political and economic reality, where the policy of loyalty in exchange for money (gas, etc.) was actually pursued.
Since the political situation in the Russian Federation has changed and a really popular president turned out to be in power, and society is used to the fact that in relations with Belarus, nothing is “changing”, there was the possibility of a more productive resolution of the situation.
Search for a union format
Indeed, what is the Union of the Russian Federation and Belarus today? Well, of course, not the federation - both the Russian Federation, and Belarusian sovereign states with its own citizenship, armed forces, monetary systems, etc. Maybe a confederation? There is no definite understanding of the confederation, since there are no stable confederations. The main thing is that the Confederation is still a state education. Although the subjects of the Confederation have the right to free from it and no decisions of the union authority have the strength without the consent of the confederation, but the confederation acts as a subject of international agreements, the subjects of the confederation include issues of war and peace, the formation of a single army, a general communication system, and resolution of disputes between confederation. Thus, from the Confederation of the Union State of Russia and Belarus, only governing bodies are parliament, which delegated representatives of the parliaments of the Russian Federation and Belarus, as well as the Higher State Council.
Formally called the confederation of Switzerland, in fact, is a federal state (although this is a very free federation), since Switzerland as a whole has sovereignty and citizenship, and not constituting cantons. The Confederation as a form of the Union of States, preserving sovereignty almost in full, was relatively rare in history. The confederations were Austria-Hungary until 1918, Sweden and Norway until 1905, the United States of America from 1781 to 1789, Switzerland from 1815 to 1848.
The most close to the Confederation of the present Bosnia and Herzegovin. Let us dwell on Bosnia and Herzegovin in more detail, since it was the Bosnian "Deyton scenario" that turned out to be the most viable form of the union of very different territories with ambitious elites.
The state structure of modern Bosnia and Herzegovina is the result of an international compromise based on the results of the events of 1992-1995, enshrined as a result of the Deyton agreements. Bosnia and Herzegovina actually consists of two states - the Bosnia and Herzegovina Federation and the Republic of Serbian, each of which has its own state authorities, constitutions, political parties and actually even pursues various foreign policy. According to the scheme of public administration of Bosnia and Herzegovin, it is impossible to classify either as the presidential or as a parliamentary form of management, which has no analogues of a specific experimental organism, which is somewhat close to the “assembly and independent” form of the reign of Shugart and Carey.
The collective head of state is the Presidium of Bosnia and Herzegovina, consisting of three members, one of the three peoples (Serb, Bosnik-Muslim, Croat). The Presidium is elected by the country's population for 4 years (members of each community vote for a candidate for their "quota"). The rotation of the prescriptions in the Presidium occurs after 8 months based on the priority established by the lot (Serb-Khorvat-Bosyak). A member of the Presidium cannot be elected for the second four -year period in a row. All decisions of the Presidium are made by consensus, in a situation where consent is reached only between two members of the Presidium upon disagreement of the third, the issue is transmitted to the parliament of state education who has chosen it, which has the right to cancel the decision. It determines that all bills should be approved by both chambers of the bought -out (parliament).
However, for a quorum in one of the chambers - even peoples - not only the presence of at least 9 out of 15 deputies is required, but also the presence of 3 Bosni Muslims, 3 Croats and 3 Serbs. Thus, the disagreement of the Serbian member of the Presidium or Parliament of the Republic of Serbian is able to paralyze the presidium, and the boycott of meetings of the Veh of Peoples with Serbian deputies not only breaks the quorum, but also deprives all acts of bought -up.
The internal structure of the Bosniysko -Crowned subject of Bosnia and Herzegovina - the Bosnia and Herzegovina Federation is somewhat simpler. The head of the Federation is the president elected by the House of Representatives of the Federation. Here again the principle of rotation is valid.
According to the Deuton agreements, the president and vice president of the Federation represent different ethnic communities. The president and vice presidents are elected for four years, every next year since the election the president and vice president are changing places.
The entire system of power in the federation is based on the numerical superiority of two "main" groups of the population: Bosnians (Muslims) and Croats compared to the Serbs, which are called "other nationalities" and who are given a secondary political status.
This structure is also reproduced by ten cantons, into which the territory of the Federation is divided: the proportionality of representation in the authorities is determined in accordance with what group of the population before the war was the majority in this territory. In five cantons, the majority make up Muslims, in three - Croats, in two - a mixed Muslim -Khorvat population; In these two cantons, a special control regime is introduced.
The federation is built according to the parliamentary model. The House of Representatives includes 140 people who are selected by direct voting regardless of their nationality. The upper house consists of 30 Muslims and 30 Croats, which are prescribed by the Assembly of Cantons, as well as a certain number of "other nationalities", mainly Serbs. However, only Muslim deputies and Croats have the right to apply a veto on any legislation that they will consider infringing on the "vital interests" of the peoples they represent.
The Republic of Serbskaya is already a typical presidential parliamentary republic. The president in the Republic of Serbian has quite significant powers, the government is formed on the basis of the parliamentary majority, but is subordinate to the president. The sample for the organization of governing bodies was chosen by the state system of neighboring Serbia. Initially, it was assumed that this is a temporary education, which should be part of the Unified Serbia, which is why a “copy of Serbia” was created to the maximum extent on all basic issues of state construction, the authorities of the Republic of Serbian on this subject did not have any special discussions.
"Bosnian version" for Russia and Belarus?
Are the Russian Federation and Belarus ready to go to a similar "Bosnian scenario"? It is unlikely, if only because it is strange and impossible to find the representative in fact at the head of Russia, many times in all respects inferior to it (population, territory, GDP, etc.) of Belarus.
There is a scenario of a gradually united European Union, but it has many members and there is no country that would be more than 2/3 of the union in all positions (also a population, territory, etc.). This is an interstate union, not a state. He can someday become a state, but this is a discussion issue.
There are a lot of integration schemes in the modern world. There are options for independent, but small states, which, without any confederations, delegate the “large” neighbors - foreign policy, defense, often take their monetary unit - so many Oceania states delegate Australia or Oceania, San Marino - Italy, Monaco - France, France and Spain, etc.
There are countries of the Caribbean basin, completely independent, but with a single currency - the East Caribbean dollar and many other integration structures. There is a "special relationship" of the USA and Canada.
After the collapse of the colonial system (with which has certain analogies of the collapse of the USSR), many small territories that remained associated with the former colonial states were transformed into self -governing states through asymmetric federal measures.
They take two forms: firstly, the federation in which the constitutional agreement between the federal government and the federal state can be changed only in accordance with the mutual agreement, as in the case of the United States, Puerto Rico and the Northern Mariana Islands. In the second case, associative state orders, the constitutional agreement in which can be changed by one or the other by one -way under the indicated conditions, for example, the USA and the Republic of Palau, the Marshalls of the island and the federal states of micronzia.
Today, more than 70% of the world population, one way or another, lives in certain confederal or federal structures. A third lives in formally federal systems and approximately 40% in systems that do not call themselves federal, but are forced to use confederal and federal measures to resolve internal contradictions.
And at the same time, no (!) Calls this to "allied states." It is important not the name, but the content. We have everything, unfortunately, the opposite. It would be better if there was no "union state", but there would be a real mutually beneficial integration.
And where, in the end, it follows that Russia and Belarus are doomed to merge in state unity ? No one will argue that the Russian and Belarusian people are very close (however, by no means identical). But there are many peoples who even speak the same language, but live in different states. The Germans and Austrians, for example. You can also recall the Norwegians, Swedes and Danes who understand each other without a translator. And there is no need to talk about the countries of Latin America.
In addition, the plans of the Russian-Belarusian state association threaten the very existence of Russian statehood. The idea made that the territories of areas forming Belarus forms in the Russian Federation means that Belarus ceases to be a specific unified state education, its common interest declines into the local interests of regions and regional elites.
Obviously, the Belarusian state elite will never go to such a scenario - no matter how pro -Russian it may be. The entry into the Russian Federation of Belarus as a subject calls into question the existence of regions within Belarus itself - such a "hypermatic" subject of the Federation will even complicate the state structure of the Russian Federation, which by all means strives to get rid of "diligent" subjects.
If you give special rights to the Belarusian subject, so other subjects of the Russian Federation will want the same. Creating a federation within the federation is a too bulky non -working mechanism. This could only be allowed in the Soviet Union, where formal statuses were fiction - decorations, and it was worth only these scenery to gain flesh, as the system collapsed. Thus, it is obvious that the model of the "traditional federation" for Russia and Belarus cannot be realized.
In general, any normal construction of relations between the Russian Federation with new potential participants in the state community is impossible without rethinking the essence of real federalism within the country itself. “Twisting of the nuts” and “alignment” of the regions will scare away any potential participant in the too dense state union - no one has a desire to get into the bondage.
You need to start with yourself. If we cannot take into account the interests of minorities within the country (and thereby shaking it in the long run), we ignore the interests of our own compatriots, for example, in Moldova and Georgia (this is where Bosnian schemes could be useful! - only who is the expansion of integration, what kind of "geopolitical promotion" can we talk about?
Since the "Union State" has been created, let this name remain. The phantom of the "Union State" will live, as it requires a massive consciousness that is not ready to completely part with the myth of the state association with Belarus, but it has no objective reason to become a reality.
In practice, the only option is to build reasonable interstate allied relations, whether it is an American-Canadian, pan-European, French-Canadian or other option. We will never become a single state, since Belarus is not ready to lose its identity, and the form of the state structure of the Russian Federation does not give it a chance to preserve it, but we can become closely connected by allied states, which will not interfere with the movement of neither people nor capital. The main thing is not in the name, but in what exists in reality.