If you strive for a more subtle and detailed consideration of the Vatican’s decision to cancel the excommunication of the four bishops of the Brotherhood of St. Pius X than what, say, the New York Times , I recommend an overview and analysis of Amy Welborne. This material exposes what, in my opinion, is the basis of Benedict's decision.
The Pope is not stupid. He knows all the corners and nooks of the Brotherhood of St. Pius x Better than any of us, and is perfectly aware of various currents of faith, customs and relationships that exist in these currents. In the brotherhood of St. Pius X, there are malicious anti -Semites. There are almost sedevakantists. Many in the fraternity believe that the second Vatican Cathedral was illegitimate, invalid. There are those who believe that the mass on which most readers this blog goes every Sunday, if not every day, is invalid, and involved wine and bread are not consecrated.
But he also knows that, especially in Europe, many adherents of the Brotherhood of St. Pius X do not share these views and simply want to confess a richer Catholic faith than the one that is available to them in the local parish. I think that in order to really realize how the situation is, it is necessary to understand the European situation, which in many aspects is very different from the one that can be observed here.
I think the Pope knows that in the next few years we will have a wave of independent selection; To some extent, self -destructive models of behavior are inevitable. In short, those who really want to be in alliance with Rome will do so, and something secret will exist for some time until a certain fantasy moment comes when a new order and the second Vatican Cathedral will be rejected.
Of course, the problem is that, opening up opportunities for supporters of the brotherhood of St. Pius X, who needs to be in complete unity with the Catholic Church, the Vatican temporarily strengthens the bishop of Richard Williamson, who denies the Holocaust and pleasant in all respects, which constantly gives reason to make sure that he is not going to - and probably does not want to return to the bosom of the church, but which instantly became a walking advertising of Papa’s decision. Roman, a symbol of the traditionalist community, if the question is wider. This is the price, which, I hope, it is worth paying for the cessation of unnecessary schisms, but the price would not be so high if the Vatican had a more clear replacement of how to build public relations in such a controversial and ambiguous case, like this one.
The average reporter or commentator will not delve into the nuances of canonical church law, the history and height of the Brotherhood of St. Pius X, the context of excommunication, the status of bishops after excommunication, and so on. What the average journalist really understands is how to write a title: "The Pope rehabilitates the bishop that denies the Holocaust." And although the prospect of obtaining public condemnation should not prevent the Vatican from showing mercy to excreted, when it is appropriate, it would still be nice if it forced to present any manifestation of such mercy in the style of a detailed and affordable course “Catholicism and canonical church law for“ teapots ”” with an explanation of what this act does not mean. In our case, with the explanation that it does not mean approval of fierce anti -Semitism and conspiracy theories.
And this is precisely this nothing portended. The papal representative said that Williamson’s words about the denial of the Holocaust were “absolutely unprovable”, and the Catholic “Roman observer” printed an advanced (of course, she has not yet been transferred to English), claiming that the decision “ should not be tarnished with unacceptable revisioned opinions and positions in relation to the Jews ”. But this is not enough in the modern media environment. If the Pope removes the excommunication from the Holocaust, the Vatican press center must work around the clock, stamping press releases to ensure the context and control the possible damage. Moreover, if the Roman dad removes the excommunication from the Holocaust negative, the Roman dad himself must say something about this, and not just put his head to the decision during his last sermon. Yes, the main work of the Church is the salvation of souls, not PR, but these days and in this era, public relations are part of the mission to save souls. And, it seems, no one in Rome, starting with Benedict and below the hierarchy, understood this truth.