From the editors: Svetlana Reuters is one of the best Russian journalists. This year, she was nominated for the Polit-Osvet Prize and got into the short list. On the eve of the final decision of the jury with Svetlana Reuters, Alexander Morozov talked.
* * *
Alexander Morozov: Long List List Politsosvet-this is a list of journalists of one workshop-these are those who write on social topics. Saying “political journalists” will probably be inaccurate. These people are not united in a section of the Union of Journalists, but this is something like an informal guild. In what condition is this guild, this workshop now?
Svetlana Reuters: Maybe this is too optimistic, but it seems to me that he is in excellent condition. And he is much wider than it seems. I collaborated for a very long time and tightly with two magazines - Esquire and Big City. And I saw around them many talented journalists who go to the same places and write to the same publications. But a year ago, when I began to engage in a “swamp case” and go to the courts, I saw a completely unfamiliar circle of journalists to Lenta.ru and Gazeta.ru. Glory to Kozlov, Seryozha Smirnov work perfectly (the last two, unfortunately, have left the old Gazeta.ru, are already working in other publications). But there, fortunately, the peppy Olya Kuzmenkova remained. Polina Nikolskaya, Andrey Kozenko and Ilya Azar are very well written in the “tape”. And the same Olesya Gerasimenko from the "Kommersant of the Power" is generally a whole event in journalism. For a happy occasion, I met people who do incredible things in business journalism: Lisa Ossetian, Roman Badanin. Therefore, I am in great delight of this workshop. When I, for example, come to the courts, I see how journalists work, who are ten to fifteen years younger than me. They do not sit in one place, they cheerfully dig the texture and at the same time reflect, and are very sharpened. If we talk about news Internet resources, there are already, as it were, “School” - Badaninskaya in Gazeta.ru, Timchenko’s school in “Ribbon”. It would be criminal not to say a word about the “school of Maxim Kovalsky”, from which, let’s say, “Olesya Gerasimenko, and Ksenia Leonova, and Polina Yeremenko“ released ”. And there is also Shura Burtin from the Russian Reporter, Lenka Kostyuchenko from Novaya Gazeta ...
Maxim Trustlyubov, with whom we recently saw at the journalistic conference in Italy, said that recently he was surprised to discover many new journalists, so this is a common pleasant trend. Therefore, everything is fine in this regard. It is only bad that the space in order to write to these journalists is steadily narrowing.
A.M.: This is the second question, by the way.
SR: We talked a lot on this topic on all sorts of journalistic "gangways." Yes, it narrows. Accordingly, there may be two reasons: economic and political. These are very tightly interconnected causes. When it is said that there is not enough money for some publication, you just understand: the country has such an environment and such a climate that they simply will not give you money for this. They can give everything else, but no.
A.M.: What will happen? Obviously, a new state of state media is being built, and all these young journalists will be forced to go there because the sites will be reduced.
SR: I don't know. It’s hard for me to predict, I don’t know how to think in advance. So far, almost all the journalists whom I listed remained where they remained. Olesya Gerasimenko is a special corner of Kommersant. Nikolskaya fields - Special Corps "tapes", Ilya Azar Special Corps "tapes". Openspace was closed, and this is very bad, Colta is still in the same place. So far, everyone is somehow arranged, but here is the key word “so far”. We do not understand how long it will be “for now”.
A.M. What is the problem?
SR: I am not a specialist, but it seems to me that the problem is that for even my generation and, probably, for generation of people who are younger than me, the word “trade union” has some undesirable connotations. This is something from the Soviet past. This is something so rotten, sour, where you need to take membership dues, and not very working. And if you have an energetic trade union, then this is usually some kind of very difficult story. These trade union leaders beat.
A.M.: And the new large journalistic club?
SR: Yes, that would be a brilliant idea. I would love to drink there.
A.M.: There is such an objection: journalists have corporate obligations, and they do not dare to join some kind of association that performs with a consolidated position ...
SR: It’s hard for me to answer your question, because I have been a freelancer for many years. But I admit that, probably, people from magazine N, we will not call, maybe they do not want to unite with the magazine X. Maybe so. I remember, in fact, that three or four years ago, the Media Indian, in my opinion, was an attempt to create a trade union, and, in my opinion, it did not end, unfortunately.
A.M.: You write a lot about violence. And this is the question: what do you think, the level of violence in society is growing, or was it always like that?
SR: I agree with the second point of view. It seems to me that the level of violence has always been the same. Just, firstly, they wrote less about it. They wrote much less. And to write about it is very difficult. I, Napomir, admire Lena Kostyuchenko, who writes about Kushchevka. She is very selfless, she retracts herself into this hell over again by her hair. I don’t understand how she lives, because it is an incredible severity of the topic ...
A.M.: Do you think that the ability of the media to write about violence can affect a decrease in the level of violence in society?
SR: Take, for example, the case in the Dalniye department. Still, after this incident in the Dalniye Department, a completely many people who applied for torture in the police came to the Kazan human rights center. I am sure that Elena Kostyuchenko writes about Kushchevka, of course, reduces the level of violence. I really hope all over the country. I am an idealist in this regard.
A.M.: You go a lot, you are such a journalist who sees Russia. Now still few are driving.
SP: Well, why, Gerasimenko drives much more than me.
A.M.: Here you are traveling, and everyone who drives - and I also go - we all look closely. Russia in its current state over the zero years has become more prosperous. And if you ask, through what words do you call the main change that has occurred in Russia in a decade?
SR: Credit pyramids, this I see. People want to correspond to some level in consumption. And I see what sociologists call "atomization." This is not my observation, but it is very accurate. When you go home from Europe through the border by car, you get from the well -groomed landscape in this way: there is a small rickety house in the middle of the landscape, on which a huge satellite plate, the road to the store from the house, is overgrown with grass.
A.M.: What are you reading now?
SR: I have a favorite writer, Oliver Sax, he is a neuropsychologist, I recently finished reading his last book Hallucinations. Now I am reading the writer Sherwood Andersen, this is a person who is considered even in his kind teacher of Faulkner.
A.M.: Watch the TV?
SR: children are watching a TV. And I watch the Daily Show on the Web, which is leading James Stewart. Although, honestly, I don’t love him anymore, and his former “partner”, Stephen Kolbert, who makes the program “Colbert Report”. I am his big fan. This is from what I look. Of course, when something comes out on the Rain TV channel, which is worth watching, I also look at the links.
A.M.: All of us who are printed are now faced with the fact that we see a tremendous number of comments under the texts, which are clearly not specially organized, but at the same time they are filled with monstrous aggression.
SR: Yes, this is true. This is also amazing me.
A.M.: Natasha Gevorkyan wrote about this once recently. That is, we see that it is impossible to write about violence, about minorities, about the fate of people, about some media characters, so as not to get a stream of comments, where people sincerely demand to shoot, execute, strengthen punishment, curse people. What is it, how do you interpret it for yourself? This is a new real state of society, or what is it?
SR: It does not seem to me that this is a real state of society. I can explain why I think so. Anonymity plays a role here. You will find one of these comments and ask whether they are fierce in life or not. I am sure not. As practice shows, people who promise each other to break the head in the networks are surprisingly cute later with each other at a meeting. Social networks, in my opinion, with all their obvious benefits, distort reality. A person begins to be a little in social networks not to those who he really is. He can be quite sweet in life, but for some reason he can be in social networks, and I often face this, plays some kind of incomprehensible role. So he chose it, and so he behaves. I think that trolls, in principle, may even be kind of kind people, but they just have the task of getting a person. Why? - God knows. Here is such a kind of sports. You wrote an article about the fact that you need to save the puppies, and they write to you, put your puppies for yourself where. They just want to get you out of themselves. There is such a term in psychiatry - "to be divided."
Photo: "Political Svetvet"