
“Russian Journal”: in such works as “Organs Without Bodies ”, you showed that modern leftists actually were left without political economic theory that could support their political actions and programs. So, "schizoanalysis", in your opinion, only develops the logic of capitalism, the logic of streaming. The left, united by "anti -imperialism" or "anti -atlantism", can actually strive for completely arbitrary goals, proclaiming the values of local communities, culture, "social state", ecology, etc. And even more blurring any certainty of the left discourse. So is there any prospect of a truly fundamental left theory? Or is there only a revolution - even without a ghost of Marx?
Glory to Zizhek: I agree that there is such a trend. At least in the West I see three main forums of the left, relatively organized. One is just left: Tony Blair and others. They accept the capitalist game and are partisans of Margaret Thatcher. As for the economy, they talk about socialism with a human face. But in fact, it is global capitalism with a human face. More human rights, but still this is a capitalist game.
A reflection of another trend is Tony Negri. I think he represents a hopeless position. It can be traced everywhere, even in modern capitalism: decentralization and proximity to communism. As Tony Negri recently said, we no longer need to fight capitalism, because capitalism has already become postmodernist. That is, this is a hopeless strategy of an abnormal person.
Another position is represented by Georgio Agamben. This is a completely catastrophic position of radical pessimists. They draw a gloomy picture and say that an increasing number of communities are going to the concept of concentration camps. They have no positive projects: everyone will live in a concentration camp, but we just have to wait for violence to intensify even more.
Why, despite this, I still adhere to my left glances? Because the logic of capitalism itself has too many destructive principles: from ecology to the manifestations of the new apartheid. In other words, global capitalism today creates so many dangerous antagonisms that an explosion should once occur.
I am a moderate optimist, but globally - a pessimist. There are things that explode, the capitalist game cannot continue endlessly. And this is what will push us to the invention of something new.
Some people note the new Latin American populism, Hugo Chavez and others. I don't trust them. It is not surprising that they pay special attention to anti -Americanism. It is easier for anti -Americanism to question the fundamental foundations of capitalism, so it is not surprising that it is so popular today. But do we need alternative capitalism with a more human face? I think that all these populist Latin American experiments will lead to disaster, as in the Soviet Union.
I always wondered: what consequences follow from the fact that each structure of power has a pronounced set of rules? After all, it is not always possible to observe the rights directly. The rules indicate how seriously the rights need to be perceived. Much is officially prohibited, many know that under the socialist regime, the black market, smuggling and bribery were very important and the economy would not have been possible without them, people would not survive. And even those things that are prohibited should actually be fulfilled.
The current system will be destroyed, and you need to know which things are allowed to the extent that they do not use them freely. For example, in the former Yugoslavia and in the former Soviet Union there were unwritten rules and you knew what to do when it was necessary to give a bribe. In the days of Yeltsin, unwritten rules were incomprehensible, which made misunderstanding and confusion. I am not a friend of Putin, but I think that a certain kind of stabilization came with him. It became clear what the unwritten rules are.
The largest catastrophe for society is when you do not know what rules of the game exist. For example, you want to create a new company, but you don’t know whether someone needs to give a bribe in order to get one or another permit. There must be rules that allow you to understand what really needs to be done.
And again, I turn to the experience of the former Yugoslav system, which was much more open than the Soviet system, for example, from the point of view of self -government. In fact, many things were allowed there, and self -government in Yugoslavia was more effective than in the former Soviet system. I recall the filmmaker of Tarkovsky with nostalgia. He shot the film, and then had to negotiate with representatives of the authorities to allow them. In the former Yugoslavia, no one dictated to anyone when the work on some problematic topic ended, it was not necessary to negotiate with anyone, everything was open. People in the party were afraid to take such responsibility and indicate what could be done and what could not. That is, there was real self -government characteristic of a liberal society. Self -government in Yugoslavia has already paved the way for today's self -government. I am a pessimist, but for the same reason paradoxically optimist. We now have a good social theory describing what is happening.
But now I am afraid that soon we will see the emergence of a new type of society, when capitalist freedoms, the economy will exist, but in close connection with the state. For example, some Western critics of Putin accuse that the model he created is an old Soviet model with a strong role of the state. But this is the wrong statement of the question.
Take the United States for example, where today the state is stronger than ever. In a multicentric global society, the state acquires a new force, a new role. And under Bush, the state became stronger than it has ever, and has more opportunities to control and regulate human life.
On this occasion, I conduct a polemic with a black man who speaks of self -organization. But in the United States, a system of state centralization is an unprecedented system for this country. The American state is now stronger than it was during the time of Roosevelt. I do not see some revolutionary power that can save us from this type of society, and remain a pessimist in a long run.
RSA: You often emphasized your proximity to the concept of Badya, especially in the issue of revolution and events. However, Badya with great difficulty solves the problem of distinguishing between a genuine, authentic event from the untreated, from simulation. In the same way, now the term "revolution" itself acquires a "technical" character, in an exhaustive way described through the listing of predicates. And the revolution as an “event” turns out to be something that never opens a “new era” and does not require a true subject. Do you think that the concept of the revolution itself has changed radically or even erased - so that the responsible use of its progressive forces is simply impossible?
S.Zh.: Of course, each era requires a rethinking of the concept of revolution. For Badya, the Chinese revolution, the collapse of the socialist regime means the end of the paradigm, which began with the Jacobins, Robespierre and their followers.
We can call or not call this new phenomenon a "revolution." It all depends on how accurate our definitions are. Of course, this concept should be comprehended in full. Today, capitalism constantly follows the path of self -revolutionization . And this is the lesson of the 20th century: the capitalist at the economic level is a more revolutionary to a much greater extent than the socialist. It seems obvious that the destruction of socialist regimes did not occur as a result of the struggle for democracy, but in connection with new changes in information technology. The socialist regime simply could not integrate the results of the last industrial or, as it can still be called, the economic revolution.
Let us return to the first point that caused criticism. Although we are continuously leading a friendly controversy, I would like to protect Badya. I do not think that he cannot distinguish between a true event and untreated. Badya gives very clear criteria for a political event. It should occur at the moment that he calls the "symptomatic moment" of "social antagonisms, etc. In other words, you can demonstrate why, for example, Nazism was not real, but, on the contrary, an artificial event. I don’t think that here the Badya has a vulnerable position, because he knows very well what a political event is. Also, by the way, the revolution is characterized by not inherent in internal properties, but a place in the structure. Therefore, the same phenomenon may or not be an event. If you do something not at the moment where the phenomenon has a different structural function, it is no longer an event.
I remember what could mean the same statement under the Soviet regime. The above at the right moment became a heroic act, and what was said too late - opportunism. I think that Badya should be fully justified. It is not a new radical proto -fascist who sees the need for a large spectacular event. He understands the situation well. Badya is one of the few who really realizes the disaster associated with the end of the traditionally left movement. He is aware that today the left is experiencing a systemic crisis.
RG: As you may know, one of the last books by Badya was a small collection of political notes. The controversy around this collection was reflected in the Zionist journal "Leto Moderna ", which recently made an attack on the Badya as a possible anti -Semite. I don't think this is true. Badya, even in a minimum degree, has nothing to do with extremism. For example, in the United States, where he regularly arrives in Los Angeles, the main place of his meetings with friends is the Center for Jewish Studies .
S.Zh.: This is absurd. I think that in this case something else happened. And this is a very interesting thing. The idea of communism, we will call her the idea of "universal liberation" in any form, found support in France by the 1968 generation. Many of the 1968 revolution figures were Jews. Now, after the “left” suffered Fiasco, perhaps the Jews abandoned the project of universal liberation and, like Beni Levy, turned to the protection of the Jewish heritage. They are of considerable interest in this rejection of the previous position, and the “collapse” of the left movement, associated with the role of Jews, who moved away from the radical left -wing positions and moved to the protection of the Jewish heritage. I think that this is one of the many manifestations of a large collapse of the “left”. When they say: "We cannot save the world, let's abandon the potentially totalitarian or global liberation project. Let's just move on to the protection of our Jewish heritage." The only thing the Jews dispute is just the last moment.
However, Badya very accurately notes that there is no struggle between Jews and anti -Semites. This is a kind of European liberation universalism, what has grown from Jewish traditions in Europe. Firstly, of people like Spinoza, Marx, etc., pursuing the goal of universal liberation, up to 80% were (now I say as an anti-Semite) Jews. I think we can say that Zionists are inclined to the project of universal liberation.
On the other hand, it should be noted that strange things sometimes happened with theory. I was always surprised at what happened to Jacques Derrida. Do you know what happened to him in the USA? It is quite obvious that Derrida was wrong there. But the irony lies in the fact that then Derrida himself fell under the influence of the incorrect interpretation of his own views.
History knows many examples when significant events occurred due to a misunderstanding or incorrect reading. You can turn to the history of Christianity: St. Pavel is one of the brightest examples of major falsification, the wrong interpretation of the image of Jesus Christ. But it happened. And therefore I prefer Pavel Jesus Christ. Without Pavel, Jesus would be anyone. Pavel created it.
RG: You wrote a lot about Lenin, and this is understandable. But now in Russia the figure of Brezhnev, not Lenin and not even Stalin, is more popular. How to be left if they cannot convey their Leninist ideals to the people who prefer to live nostalgia for stagnation? By the way, how do you feel about Leonid Ilyich?
S.Zh.: This confirms my theory. In one of my books, we are talking about a situation where people are truly happy, but not when they have everything. Something "inert" happiness is needed for those cases when there is not all. I formulated the three conditions that are necessary in order to be happy. Life should be peaceful, comfortable and not too rich. If it is too rich, a person will become too demanding. Then, you need someone who can be blamed for everything. Therefore, with democracy, you do not feel happy. Again, not everything in life should be too good. For example, you do not need to eat meat or milk every day. The deficit opens your eyes to the fact that in addition to meat there is something else. And you can imagine why each person experiences happiness with stagnation.
I heard from one of the Russians that the last years of Brezhnev’s reign were the only period in the entire history of the Soviet Union, when society was not in a state of mobilization. And that was what people wanted. On the other hand, you should also be known that memory works in a strange way. Those things that were perceived terribly at a time when you came across them, later recalled with nostalgia. For example, how do I remember the service in the army now? I meet with friends, we tell stories, chat. But if you imagine how it was in all details, then this is a nightmare. No need to underestimate how much people liked stagnation. Even for the poor then there was inert stability, because nothing had to be worried about anything. And I can well understand this nostalgia. People like stupid inertia. There is nothing surprising here.
RG: Many people believe that you can be a philosopher anywhere and in any conditions. And where is it better to philosophize now, where is it good "going"? In London or in Engadin? Where would you suggest going to young philosophers (how did Wittgenstein go to Russell to Britain at one time)? Can there be philosophical tourism (according to the model of medical tourism - when patients specially go to other countries to treat their teeth cheaper)?
S.Zh.: Despite my critical attitude to the United States, I can give a paradoxical answer to your question. I think the best place is some small college in the USA. In Europe, in fact, there is nothing. In France - only two or three places. In Germany - Sterberg. Nothing happens in Europe.
It is best to start in the USA, in a small campus. Because large universities, such as Harvard, consider themselves the centers of the world. For example, the Berkeley University. This is generally the worst place. They consider themselves the center of the universe. No, you need something like a small university in Chicago or Buffalo, where there is a small department of philosophy and where they teach what is called "European or continental philosophy." This is the best place. The tragedy is that there are only individual people here and there. If someone asks me which department I would like to be, I would answer that not the department is important for me, but interesting people are important. I think, thirty or seconds of years ago, if you were an analyst philosopher, the best option was to spend several years at the Department of Philosophy at the Berkeley University. Everyone visited there - Sun Kripka, Donald Davidson and others. Now there is nothing there.
Distant Dmitry Kralechkin