
Drinking into the stream of political science comments about the events in Ukraine and comparing the conceptual constructions of experts with the testimonies of "inexperienced in science", you later begin to feel some intellectual dissonance. One gets the impression that in geopolitical, political economic and similar studies (often deep and accurate), something very important for understanding the Ukrainian situation is missed. I recall Kant, who believed that different areas of their application should also meet various human abilities. Reason is a bad assistant where the aesthetic ability of judgment should be applied. The concepts of modernity, which are still saturated with a political science (and any other) science, prevent us from understanding that the so -called "velvet revolutions" are the essence of the project is primarily aesthetic . Understand that people for the masses choose not certain politicians or their "program", but a way of life . And the choice of the image is the choice of aesthetic.
Even the question of the Russian language that has acquired such an acute political sound in Ukraine is a significant issue of aesthetic. It is difficult not to notice how the poetics of the Ukrainian language differs from the poetics of the modern Russian language. Yanukovych would never have said, like Yushchenko, that his supporters are in a hurry in Kiev " on oxen ." This almost Freudian reservation shows the patriarchal-Selian, folklore "unconscious" of the Ukrainian language. I don’t know how it is now, but in historically not so ancient times in Kharkov, for example, Ukrainian speech was considered a “village”. And the question here is not in knowledge along with the Russians of another language. People can perfectly own the Ukrainian literary language (since they taught him well at school in Soviet times), but they are annoyed , for example, that their children instead of “twice two” say “Two -Two”. The poetics of the Ukrainian language are alien to them, since the aesthetics of lifestyle are alien to him (including, among other things, and an expressive-present attitude to the "Moskalya"); They are quite tolerant of this aesthetics, but the total "Ukrainianization" of their life (and even in the spirit of Galician nationalism) is regarded as violence.
The aesthetic choice, of course, is not a rational choice - this is not a choice between two more or less real outcomes, but between the fact that a person wants to wish. Exactly so: wants to wish . Do you want to wish your mine or plant to work and your family has enough means for life, or do you want to wish for Ukraine to become a real white European power? What a question for a puppy Ukrainian! ..
And now - state -political institutions are fading into the background, become decorations in which a grandiose orange carnival unfolds. The attempt of the Verkhovna Rada to arrange his benefit, with an accounting for voting and an orange communion, looks pale and boring in comparison with it. Either it was a matter of lights filled with a mass of people and a huge screen, with laser rays sticking into the sky, with a scene, on which the hot speeches of political idols are replaced by no less incendiary performances of pop idols! An abundance of orange color (there is no hot!), Still widely used only by road services or clowns in the circus; Hundreds of tents standing in the center of the European capital; Pomeranzium human rivers and whirlpools; Hundreds of thousands of votes chanting one name ... No, not a name, but a name! .. When you see a group of men on TV, in some trance of drumming, like Papuasam or Brazilian mulatto, according to empty barrels of fuel and lubricants, you understand that the carnival metaphor here is key.
The phenomenon of the carnival has repeatedly attracted the attention of researchers, and what we know about the Carnival can explain not everything, but much of what is happening after the second round of the presidential election in Ukraine. Mikhail Bakhtin excellently analyzed the paradoxical logic of the carnival, during which the current laws are canceled, the existing social hierarchy is turning over and the “order of things” itself. Carnival is the time of the holiday, the time of abolition of everyday life. One can only be surprised that the actions of the so -called “opposition” are built in this logic, starting already with the adoption of the name of the opposition, that is, those who are against the existing political regime or course. The preparation of the carnival - turning the order of things - began already when the supporters of Yushchenko (and not only in Ukraine) took the thesis for the axiom that only the elections in which their candidate would win are honest. The non-recognition of the voting results and their own exit from the legislative and legal field, in fact, is an attempt by the anti-constitutional coup, they give out as a "coup", carried out by the "Kuchma-Yanukovych gang" as a "state coup". The internal issue of popular will turns into a question of external recognition of the election results, into a kind of universal vote for who is the president of Ukraine. The legitimate power is not yet overtaken or seized - it is blocked , thereby provoking the use of force or forcing to make concessions (this technology of “blocking” in the Variant of the city of Suma has become painfully similar to the terrorist capture of hostages). The creation of unbearable conditions for the work of state bodies is depicted as a struggle for democracy (more precisely, as Yulia Tymoshenko says, " for our democracy "). Here you have a farce with a presidential oath, and horror stories about the disguised Russian military, who had either arrived on an airplane, or crossed the border in order to "shoot the Ukrainian people." It is already a matter of ultimatum to President Kuchme, declared in the same voice of the same “frantic” Yulia Tymoshenko, this, as she called her “The Guardian”, a millionaire-revolutionary . All, literally all the elements and moments of the carnival found their place in Kyiv events. Until imitating the battle of light with darkness, in all options possible for the Ukrainian scene.
Obviously, the Kyiv carnival is by no means spontaneous, and by no means purely Ukrainian. Such events, as you know, never do without a thorough organization, invited specialists and considerable cash costs. But who thinks money, "if such a booze went"? ..
The festive destruction of order, perceived not only as getting rid of painful duties, but also as eliminating the borders existing between people (in ancient times, it often assumes the nature of mass orgies), gives rise to ecstatic effects. The feeling of ourselves by a particle, we, depersonalization, is combined with a sense of extraordinary freedom and joy. Actually, the value of the carnival is that it is a special, festive-free form of life, absolutely necessary from time to time for humans. In other words, the carnival is the body of the action , that is, roughly speaking, such an action, the motive of which is its own implementation ("nonsense" from the point of view of the logic of the meaning of the case). Therefore, all goals and meanings have an external character in relation to it, and can be very different for various people and groups participating in this action. Often, the general meaning here is suggestive in nature. It is natural that the unstable psyche of young people lends itself to the greatest extent. Young people, on the one hand, perceive what is happening in Kyiv as a non-stop show, a carnival, a cheerful holiday of disobedience, and on the other hand, they experience a conceited pleasure from the fact that she participates in “historical events” and adults finally accept it seriously. The calls sounding from all sides do not shed a drop of blood ” - the essence of a kind of ritual spells aimed at maintaining, for the time being, until the time that occurs within the framework of the game (but not the game ), to prevent the brutal reality to destroy this pink -orange illusion of the holiday or the impression that" nothing special happens. " At the same time, such a strategy on the part of the headquarters of Viktor Yushchenko (filled with the same oligarchs and was out of work by the highest nomenclature) is nothing more than a cynical deach of the masses in a situation where there is no way back and the question is raised as "freedom or death."
Among the "external meanings" of the carnival action there are several archetypal (and therefore especially powerful), dating back to those lost in the darkness of millennia, when the primitive world has celebrated the New Year holiday. Rene Girard wrote about one of them in detail, one can read, for example, from Mirche Eliade.
According to the concept of Girar, all rituals are based on a special situation, during which the crisis of the community, the mutual alienation and bitterness accumulated in it, frustration, “war of all against all” is allowed due to unanimous violence in relation to a special “object”, victims. Unanimous violence, uniting people, becomes the constituent violence - an action that cleanses the community of "sins" and re -establishes order in it. The Georgian “Rose Revolution” is the most highly example of such a ritual of “cleansing of sins”, where Eduard Shevardnadze was used in the role of “victim of scape”. Obviously, however, that in Ukraine, not only Viktor Yanukovych (and the Donetsk clan) can be a victim, but almost half of the population. The alternative follows: either the whole southeastern Ukraine will be “exiled”, or someone else should be as a victim, not Yanukovych (for example, Leonid Kuchma, CEC or Supreme Court; at worst-Moscow). All other options lie beyond the framework of the constituent violence mechanism and are unlikely to lead Ukraine to unity.
The meaning of the New Year holiday, according to Eliad and other researchers, is an attempt to start time again . That is, to abolish the real history, which is perceived as a chain of distortions and dilapidation of the original, established by God or the cultural hero of the true order, and re-reproduce the moment of creation of the world from chaos (this is why the holiday usually begins by playing the “chaos”: with the abolition of all social rules and a random combination of anything with anything). In this regard, the Ukrainian national-ethnic consciousness is not much different from mythopoietic. It also longs to destroy this endless story of the “suppression of Ukraine” (which, as a state never existed), in order to “start everything from the beginning”. Therefore, of course, those students are right, “speaking through the lips of babies” that the reason for their arrival in Kiev and speeches on the side of Yushchenko was the desire to participate in a historical event . And it is no coincidence that in the script and directing of the Ukrainian carnival, artistic and historical reminiscences and allusions on the great revolutions of the past are so clearly expressed. The Ukrainian humanitarian intelligentsia for more than a dozen years played the role of a collective Kobzar, who plunged dreamy crests in the dreams of great Ukraine with her songs, and now it continues in the same spirit (apparently, apparently, that she has nowhere to retreat).
Indeed, the current events in Ukraine have every chance of becoming a "beginning of history" - but what is the story? That's the question. Return to the start point makes it possible, generally speaking, not one, but many projects. Including such exotic projects as the formation of a new Commonwealth (or at least, a protector of Poland over Ukraine). If Western Ukrainians want to cross out all the Russian and Soviet past and start the history of their Ukraine from the European scratch, then the eastern Ukrainians and Crimeans have no less desire (and foundations!) To abolish the post -Soviet history and create their own Ukraine on other principles, which imposes them on the West. Behind all this, the ghost of the Civil War is loomed, which will be little like a prolonged musical on the Small of Nemism.
... the holiday cannot last forever. The cheerful cargo of permissiveness earlier or later will be replaced by a heavy hangover. Are participants in the orange carnival ready for gray, dank everyday life of unfulfilled hopes and bitter disappointments?