
Chairman of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation Vyacheslav Lebedev at a reception in the Kremlin. Photo: Kremlin press service
Lebedev went through all the steps of the service staircase, starting with an ordinary judge, to which he was elected back in 1970 after the end of the evening department of the law faculty of Moscow State University. In fact, this was an appointment - the elections of people's judges in the USSR were fully controlled by party bodies. The future head of the judicial system of the Russian Federation began a labor biography at the plant, he did not have “paws”, and the judge’s work was “responsible”, but unenviable.
Lebedev managed to climb into high positions even before perestroika, heading the Moscow Road District People's Court of Moscow in 1977, and in 1986-after two years in the rank of deputy, he was appointed chairman of the Moscow City Court. Here he participated in sentences, including in cases of “anti -Soviet activity” - well, who could have evaded it?
He was appointed (with subsequent approval at the session) to the post of chairman of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (at that time) by decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Council of the RSFSR on July 26, 1989. This was a period of fierce struggle for “sovereignty” between the leadership of the USSR represented by Mikhail Gorbachev and the future leadership of the RSFSR represented by Boris Yeltsin.
The appointment of Lebedev took place a month before the adoption of the law on the status of judges in the USSR prepared by the Gorbachev team, which sunk into oblivion along with the USSR in December 1991.
Since then, the Chairman of the Supreme Court was appointed and reassigned to the Federation Council, that is, after 2000, according to the unsuitable representation of the President of the Russian Federation.

Until 2000, Lebedev was quite published, participated in the work of the Moscow Club of Lawyers, where he met with colleagues of democratic views, and came to meetings of the guild of judicial reporters, which was created in 1997 by a number of journalists engaged in the coverage of judicial problems. At such meetings, he spoke in support of the jury and for the broad openness of the judicial community.
The style of his communication with representatives of civil society and the press after 2000 has changed noticeably. When Mikhail Fedotov was the chairman of the Presidential Council for Human Rights, he sat at the same table of the Presidium with Lebedev at meetings of the Council of Judges, but he rejected all proposals about meetings with the relevant commission of the Council.
Regularly speaking to the Council of Judges of the Russian Federation and the chairmen of the courts, Lebedev from the rostrum poured the data of judicial statistics, to no extent helping to understand the principles of the internal structure of the system - they remained behind the scenes. Unlike his colleague, Chairman of the Constitutional Court, Valery Zorkin, Lebedev did not particularly go into theorizing the Doctor of Law.
He spoke out loud in support of the humanization of criminal punishment, repeatedly talked about the inadmissibility of detention before the verdict in economic crimes, but all this remained only at the level of good wishes.
But to draw from this the conclusion that the chairman of the Supreme Court did not affect the work of the judicial system would be a big mistake. On the contrary, for more than 30 years, Lebedev built a cruel judicial vertical, but working - in any case, when considering sign cases - not only and not so much according to the law, but according to the rules that are understandable (“conceptual”) only for the participants themselves. The basis of this vertical was the mechanism for the appointment of judges and chairmen of the courts by the president, and the actually completely opaque personnel commission of the presidential administration, where the “security forces” play a decisive role.
The judicial community formed over the years will undoubtedly preserve the good memory of Vyacheslav Mikhailovich: he achieved the creation of a generously funded judicial department in the Supreme Court in 1998, and in most regional centers new courts of courts are perfectly equipped palaces. Lebedev provided not only high official salaries and allowances for the experience for judges, but also “lifelong content” for retired judges, the size of which may approach their last earnings.

But the irremovability of the judges, which Lebedev-Democrat defended when the relevant legislation was adopted in the 90s, turned out to be a trap for them: there is too much judge with experience (where the work secretary of the court session and assistant judge is counted) in case of “incomprehensibility”. The hierarchy of the qualifications of judges as a mechanism for their prosecution is also formally controlled by the Council of Judges, and in fact the supreme court, but there is a lot of things to complain about the judge.
Lebedev was undoubtedly a “pillar”. But his death itself does not shake the prevailing and even cemented vertical. However, it is important who will stand at the head of it. Judges are rather a “backup” of the regime, the support of which are the FSB authorities, the Investigative Committee and other “security forces”.
But according to the law, almost all of their actions related to coercion (search, detention and even listening to phones) can be carried out only on the basis of court decisions.
Now such “sanctions” are issued almost automatically (for detention in 9 out of 10 cases), but the situation may change if the overall regime is weakened by internal competition.
Inside the judicial corps, as in any bureaucracy, intrigues and violence are widespread, there are, apparently, there is a compromising evidence, including corruption in this system, on many judges and leaders of the courts. From the outside, these threads are usually not visible, but Vyacheslav Mikhailovich undoubtedly knew how to hold them in his hands. In a long hardware struggle, he was able to defeat the chairman of the Moscow City Court Olga Egorova, to hush up the scandals related to corruption and the participation of judges in the Krasnodar Territory, to get rid of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation together with his chairman Anton Ivanov, and then from the chairman of the Economic Collegium of the Supreme Court Oleg Sviridenko.
Specific knowledge that allowed V.M. Lebedev to keep the entire judicial vertical in the UP, they are not such that he can completely convey them to someone outside the system he created. It is not a fact that with this kind of information a classmate of the President Irina Podnsova, who, in the absence of experience in arbitration courts, was appointed to the deputy chairman - chairman of the Economic College of the Supreme Court after the resignation of Sviridenko in the summer of 2020 in the summer of 2020.
The judicial power can be claimed to be claimed only if competition is aggravated at the highest political level. We will monitor the development of the situation in the judicial system, but only as much as possible by indirect signs.