

Valery Mironov: "With this state I am not on the way!"
According to the chairman of the Komi human rights commission "Memorial", yesterday’s decision of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan in the case of disabled person Valery Vasilyevich Mironov plunged human rights defenders into shock.
The story began six years ago, when Valery Vasilyevich, a resident of the Ezhvinsky district of Syktyvkar, was unreasonably removed from the line for housing. Valery Vasilievich is sick of the throat of the third degree - according to federal standards with this disease, he is laid for a separate apartment.
Then the Memorial helped the disabled. As a result, the Ezhvinsky District Court ruled: to return Mironov and give him housing. But the court decision was not carried out a year after year.
Thus, almost four years have passed. In the end, in response to the cassation appeal filed by the Ezhva administration, the Supreme Court of the Republic of Kazakhstan issued a completely unexpected decision: the city administration, to which the lawsuit was addressed, cannot be the defendant, since the Ezhvinsky department of the city should be such. In this regard, the case should be sent for a review. Given the duration of the procedures and summer holidays among the judges, all this can now drag on for another three to four months.
According to Igor Sazhin, “the person appeals to the court for help, and the court does everything to refuse him. Of course, formally, there is a reason to cancel the decision of the Ezhvinsky court. But there is a living person who has undergone the most difficult operations in winter, ready to start a hunger strike now, although this simply means death for him. But it seems that this death would have arranged many. In any case, Mr. Epstein, then acting The head of the Ezhvinsky administration, who directly stated that no court would force him to give Mironov an apartment. Now we intend to launch the procedure for emergency appeal to the European Court of Human Rights. This is done in just three to five days. At the same time, the case is considered there if it does not tolerate delay and there are circumstances that threaten a person’s life. In this case, in our opinion, it is precisely the following case: they just want to be a person, on the principle: there is no applicant - there are no problems. But the right as such cannot change or disappear depending on the arbitrariness of the judges. ”