
What are the miscalculations of local authorities and investors who decided to save on transport infrastructure during the construction of a TBO training ground in the mining of the district, and is it legal to protest against the incomprehensible decisions of the district leadership, as well as how great the chances of local residents are to defend their constitutional right to a favorable environmental environment - in an interview of “ 7x7 ” says a lawyer and head of a public legal legal legal entity Reception, a project for the preparation of a report on environmental crimes and violations of environmental rights of citizens in the Russian Federation of the “Ecological Human Rights Center” “Bellona” Nina Vyprovko. At the end of October, she directly connected to the representation of the interests of the inhabitants of the Red Volga rural settlement in the courts in the territory of Mari El.

- First, tell us, please, about the human rights organization "Bellon": what is the focus of your activity, have you exist for a long time, are there any regional branches?
- The central office of Bellons is located in the capital of Norway - in the city of Oslo. The non-profit organization of Bellona was formed in 1986. Bellona-Murmansk was formed in Russia, which began its activities in the early 90s and St. Petersburg Public Organization of the Ecological Human Rights Center, established in 1998. The organization’s activities are based on the conviction that human rights to live in a favorable environment and have reliable environmental information are the fundamental rights of each of us, since these rights relate to the most valuable - health and life of people. EPC "Bellona" provides legal and information assistance to victims as a result of violations of environmental norms and environmental rights of citizens; Organizes activities to enlighten, inform and consult Russian citizens on environmental and legal issues, contributes to the participation of citizens and NGOs in decision -making on environmental protection issues. To solve these problems, the Bellona EPC carries out its activities in three main areas: legal, information and expert.
Our organization is actively cooperating with the legislative and executive authorities. In 2012, Bellona prepared comments on the draft resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation “On the application by the courts of legislation on liability for violations in the field of environmental protection”.
This year we presented comments and proposals for the state report of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Ecology "On the condition and on environmental protection in 2012." Now he is ensuring that environmental non -profit organizations can apply to the courts in defense of an indefinite circle of persons, if there are violations of citizens' rights to a favorable environment.
Bellona pays great attention to the legal education of citizens. Together and environmental activists from all federal districts, we are preparing public reports on violations of environmental rights of citizens in the regions. We bring the information to the executive authorities authorized to human rights in the constituent entities of the Federation. “Bellona” prepared several thematic brochures to protect the environmental rights of citizens, which provide samples of procedural documents, and recommendations are given. The main task in this direction to teach environmental activists to independently defend and protect their right to a favorable environment, since there are many environmental problems, and there are not enough lawyers for all.
Bellon has a public reception for legal assistance to citizens on the protection of their environmental rights and to reliable information about the state of the environment. Given the territoriality for the consultation, activists of St. Petersburg and the Leningrad Region come, but we are addressed by e-mail and from other regions. In this case, we advise in absentia: we give written recommendations, prepare legal documents in the protection of the environmental rights of citizens. Sometimes we go to the regions, provide support for activists in the courts.
- It is no secret that the existence of Bellona in Mari El became known after the events related to the preparation for the construction of the solid waste training ground in the Horma region. And how typical is our situation based on your practice?
- I must say that Bellon is well known in regions related to nuclear energy objects: our experts take part in conferences, seminars, and public hearings on nuclear facilities. Bellona experts work in the field of alternative energy, climate change and pollution of the Arctic.
And for the general public of the Republic of Mari El, indeed, Bellon became known after the start of the trial. But environmental activists independently turned to us with a request to provide legal and information support related to the construction of the solid waste training ground.
The situation that is happening in connection with the construction of the solid waste landfill is typical for many regions of our country. Over the past few years, environmental and urban planning legislation has been substantially changed, unfortunately, not the best side for citizens. Of the laws, the norms that most fully protected our environmental rights have been withdrawn. In 2007, changes were made to the Town Planning Code of the Russian Federation, the Institute of State Ecological Expertise was actually canceled (carried out only in relation to certain types of activities), new forest and water code were adopted.
Another problem is the lack of an effective management system in the field of environmental protection, the need to increase the effectiveness of state environmental control (supervision) at both the federal and regional levels. At the same time, there is no clear distinction between powers for state environmental control (supervision) between federal state authorities and state authorities of subjects.
For example, only federal executive bodies (Federal State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography) have the authority to carry out state land supervision. The right of environmental supervision is also endowed with Rosrybolovy, Rosselkhoznadzor, Rosleskhoz, etc.
The trend is characterized by the transfer of powers from the federal level to the level of constituent entities of the Federation in order to reduce their expenses for the content of the territorial environmental authorities of the executive branch of federal significance. However, not all subjects, especially subsidized ones, are able to fulfill these powers, the transfer of authority to the regional level occurs without transferring financial resources for their implementation.
- Is the miscalculations of the Gornomariysk district and a private investor obvious to organize the legitimate, seemingly procedures related to a public hearing or preparing documents of a state environmental examination? In other words, does the practice of such cases tell you that eco -activists will win in court - this is a hopeless case or opposite?
-Let's specifically dwell on the training ground, where waste of hazard class II-V will be placed. I will briefly describe the procedure that is provided by law:
Economic activity related to the placement of the landfill of the IV CLACS of the hazard class by virtue of Art. 11 of the Federal Law of November 23, 1995 N 174-ФЗ “On Environmental Expertise” is subject to environmental examination of the federal level. To prepare documentation on the state environmental examination of the landfill, it is necessary to assess its impact on the environment (EIA). The EIA is carried out in accordance with the Order of the State Ecology of the Russian Federation of May 16, 2000 N 372 "On approval of the Regulation on the assessment of the impact of the intended economic and other environmental activities in the Russian Federation."
Thus, the customer (in our case, LLC "Polygon") makes an initiative to conduct EIA. One of the most important procedures in the framework of this activity is to inform the public and identify the opinions of citizens on the issue of placing a landfill. The customer independently elects the form of informing - it is possible to place in the media, the Internet, special booklets, letters, various documentation can be prepared to most fully and widely convey information to the interested public. The next stage is the hearing at which there is a full discussion of the project, its environmental impact and decision making.
How public hearings are held, I mean how openly and accessible to the interested public the publication has been carried out and preferences for the placement of solid waste have depended primarily on local authorities and the customer. The customer should also provide an alternative option for the implementation of the planned activities. The summary of the comments and suggestions of the public indicating which of them were taken into account by the customer and in what form, which were not taken into account, are reflected in the conclusion on the results of public hearings, which is published in the media again with the aim of informing citizens.
The next stage is the conduct of state environmental examination.
In the case of the construction of the MSW landfill in the Republic of Mari El, we see that they are going to build a training ground in the Red Volga rural settlement, but for some reason there was no information on citizens in this region-neither on information stands, nor on local radio, nor in the local newspaper Zhera, published in the Mining Mary. In addition, the comments that were expressed by some activists present at the hearings were not taken into account when drawing up the protocol and were not subsequently presented along with the materials of the public hearings on the GEE. Those. The hearings were held formally without the intention to identify the opinion of the inhabitants. In addition, in the materials of the EIA, represented on the GEE, there is no alternative option for placing the landfill. Those. An unprofitable document entered the GEE. Of course, socially responsible companies are trying to prepare for the hearings and the hearings themselves, as openly and without violations as possible.
-Obviously, “having contacted the courts”, the eco-activists of the mining of the district got involved in a rather troublesome lesson-at first the district court makes one decision, then it is protested in Yoshkar-Ola. How long can such mobilization last, your forecast?
- Defending their rights in court is always a rather long process. The appeal can be filed within a month from the date of the court decision in final form. There is also a cassation appeal procedure and supervisory instance of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. It is difficult to say how much time will pass before the court made the court. It all depends on what court decisions will be made following the results of the statements.
- The fact that Bellona drew attention to the situation in the Republic of Mari El, how could it affect the final of this story? Many of your similar affairs ended successfully?
- If you look at the statistics of court cases in which the Bellona EPC provided legal support to activists, then the majority of claims and statements on the issues of violations of environmental rights of citizens, the rights to access environmental information, the category of cases related to the protection of environmental activists themselves were satisfied with the courts and the rights of citizens were restored.
The category of cases that were initially not resolved in court on the same reason were subsequently resolved positively on other grounds (for example, the case related to the construction of the Okhta Center in the historical part of St. Petersburg). Despite the refusal of the two courts to satisfy the complaint, as a result, a decision was made to build the Gazprom’s main office on the outskirts of the city. Here, much also depends on what position on this issue is occupied by the interested public. It is necessary to defend your rights in all ways not prohibited by law.
As a rule, if lawyers, professional lawyers, representatives of the NPOs take part in the courts, the courts are trying to prevent at least serious procedural violations, more objectively consider issues related to the satisfaction of activists' motions, and the introduction of a number of documents to the materials of the court case.
-Literally the day after the meeting of the Minormarian District Court, which deviated the complaint of ecoactivists about the results of the state sequences, some construction work began at the alleged location of the landfill. How does the builders have the right to carry out such actions if the trial is not yet completed?
- Unfortunately, local authorities are so obviously on the side of the business entity (LLC Polygon) that they independently apply to the Federal Service for Supervision of Nature Management with a request for the GEE; Well, now, when the court’s decision to appeal the results of the GEE did not even enter into legal force, they hastened to issue permission to build a solid waste training ground. At the same time, in the main urban planning documentation of the Moscow Region, the General Plan and the Rules for Development and Land Use, the corresponding changes that provide for the placement of the training ground were not made. Although it is necessary to conduct public hearings to make such changes, and their organizer is the local government.
-Of course, we themselves are surprising how difficult the load took over several residents of the district who were not afraid to openly oppose the authorities-say, it is not accepted for us if you do not want to be known as a radical-margin, etc. And what do you think would have developed a situation if not rallies and not courts?
- As statistics shows, up to 15 percent of court cases are permitted in favor of environmental activists. Therefore, to solve environmental problems, public activity is very important, and as it seemed to me, local residents are very concerned about the possible construction of the landfill.
The issue in the trials has not yet been finally resolved. We hope, in appeal, it will be possible to recognize the results of the GEE of the design documentation of the solid waste landfill invalid. Processively, appeal to the court and the very permit for the construction of the training ground, but this is as a spare option.
The position of local authorities, which actually create the next intensity of social tension, is surprising. After all, none of the local residents disputes the need to build the MSW landfill itself, but why place it in one of the most densely populated territories of the district? It seems that everything rests on financing again, local authorities want to save on infrastructure, road construction, and all this to the detriment of the health of residents.