
Two brilliant specialists are a doctor of historical sciences, a leading researcher at the St. Petersburg Institute of History of the Russian Academy of Sciences, a member of the St. Petersburg Pen-Club and a member of the St. Petersburg Union of Scientists Irina Levinskaya, and a candidate of philosophical sciences, senior researcher at the Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography named after Peter the Great RAS (Kunstkamera), a member of the St. Petersburg Union, scientists Valentin Uzunov, literally smashed the infamous expert opinion on the actions of the Pussy Riot group, performed by V.Yu. Troitsky, V.V. Abramenkova and I.V. Ponkin.
Here is their text, logically called “Examination in the punitive style”: http://www.spass-sci.ru/news/detail.php?id=300
I highly advise everyone to read this document, a stone on a stone that does not leave these citizens from the conclusions, of which Vsevolod Troitsky seems to be “Orthodox philologist”, Vera Abramenkova as an “Orthodox psychologist”, Igor Pinkin - as an “Orthodox lawyer”.
Since when did “Orthodox philology”, “Orthodox psychology” and “Orthodox jurisprudence” appeared in the country? Or are their norms significantly different (which, in general, directly follows from the “expert opinion” prepared by the indicated citizens) from accepted in the relevant scientific disciplines? In this case, the court had to send this “conclusion” to the garbage tank, and not use in the process ...
For reference - so that readers understand what "experts" we are dealing with.
The “Orthodox philologist” Troitsky in his article on the site, which is difficult not to call the Black Socialist, requires “subordinate the media that are in Russia, national-state interests” and “seek the proportional representation of the nations and the peoples of Russia in all administrative and administrative state structures”.
“Orthodox psychologist” Abramenkov is known for texts with characteristic names such as “about modern blasphemy” and severe condemnation of the appearance of “foreign, alien innovations in our country, like the Day of Valentine and the Day of all saints, Halloween, who have nothing to do with the morality of Christianity, nor with the moral representations and traditions of the peoples Russia ". And another example of the reasoning of Ms. Abramenkova: “Intellectualization, rationality is not characteristic of Russian mentality. It is imposed on us in the West way of thinking, life. ”
Well, the “Orthodox lawyer” Ponkin has a long -standing reputation of a person engaged in serving the interests of the Russian Orthodox Church. It is noteworthy of his close cooperation with one of the lawyers of the victims in the Pussy Riot case - Mikhail Kuznetsov (this alone was to force the court to doubt the objectivity of the examination conducted by him). On the same site on which the mentioned article by Troitsky was placed, Pinkin and Kuznetsov called President Dmitry Medvedev to fix the federal law “On Education” in August 2011. The authors complained of the “atheism of the concept of the bill”, and considered it their duty to generally in general that in the project, published on the website of the ministry, “the interests of the Russian Orthodox Church, Orthodox educational institutions and Orthodox citizens were not sufficiently guaranteed” ...
With such experts, one should not be surprised at the “punitive” conclusion given by them. However, nothing is new under the Moon: the indictments in the cases conducted by the Inquisition (and later-the Cheka-NKVD-KGB) gave the same “objective” and “unbiased” experts.