
This is a personal blog. The text could be written in the interests of the author or third parties. The 7x7 editors are not involved in its creation and may not share the author’s opinion. The registration of blogs on 7x7 is open for authors of various views.

The prosecution authorities in the Russian Federation are, one might say, the last instance of hope for citizens trying to resolve the violations of rights in the legal field. People write numerous complaints and statements, but is there any sense in this?
And as follows from the information below, the prosecutor's office is now engaged in formalism, and not a real protection of rights.
In December 2019, residents of the city of Sursk, Penza Region, with an active civil position, applied to the district prosecutor’s office with a written statement on the illegal actions of the officials of the administration of the city of Sursk during the implementation of housing policy in the territory of the municipality.
In their appeal, citizens specifically pointed out the facts of offenses, describing the situation in sufficient detail and attaching the confirming documents.
The prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district, headed by Alexei Dyakonov since April 2018, sent this appeal for consideration on the merits in the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs for the Gorodischensky District of the Penza Region and the Gorodishchensky MSO of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for the Penza Region.
The officials of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia in the Gorodishchensky district conducted an audit, according to the results of which on 01.01.2020 a resolution was issued to refuse to institute criminal proceedings.


The applicants did not agree with this procedural decision and appealed it to the prosecutor of the Gorodishchensky district on 01/30/2020, however, on 10.02.2020, the district prosecutor’s office was issued to refuse to satisfy the complaints of applicants, which reported that “the decision adopted by the body of the inquiry on the refusal to institute criminal proceedings, the grounds for the cancellation of the issued procedural decision not There is ".




In this regard, on 17.02.2020, the applicants filed a complaint with the Gorodishchensky District Court of the Penza Region in accordance with Art. 125 Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation. However, the court, having received a complaint of the applicants, refused to accept it on 02/19/2020, motivating this by the fact that the appealed procedural decision was canceled by the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district on 02/18/2020 (really a coincidence?) With the direction of materials for additional verification, that is, due to the lack of the subject of appeal, although it follows from the meaning of the law with the decision of the prosecutor or the head the investigating authority, as well as with the partial satisfaction of the requirements contained in the complaint, the complaint filed to the court is subject to consideration in accordance with Article 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation. The applicants took advantage of this unconditional right.



02/27/2020 by the applicants to the prosecutor of the region of Natalia Kanserova sent a complaint in which they asked for an official audit against officials of the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district in connection with the improper implementation of the procedural activity of the inquiry bodies, in connection with which the most important obligation of the prosecutor's office is not realized - timely protection of the rights and legitimate interests of the participants in the criminal legal proceedings.





But instead of conducting an official audit, the department of Natalia Canzerova lowered the complaint ... to the one whom the applicants complained about, i.e. prosecutor Alexei Dyakonov.
During this time, the inquiry body on this verification material issued the next decision to refuse to initiate a criminal case of 01.03.2020.


03.03.2020 by the applicants filed an appeal against the decision of the Gorodishchensky District Court of the Penza Region of 02/19/2020 on the refusal to accept the complaint. The applicants indicated in the complaint, in particular, that since the court made the decision at his disposal, there was a decision of the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district of 10.02.2020, according to which, in a similar complaint with the same arguments of the applicants, the prosecutor of the district carried out in accordance with Art. 124 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation and made a decision on a complete refusal to satisfy it, the court had no reason to refuse to accept the complaint. But on 05.27.2020, the Judicial Collegium for Criminal Cases of the Penza Regional Court left the decision of the court of first instance.
Meanwhile, on 20.03.2020, the prosecutor Alexei Dyakonov, in his next decision to refuse to satisfy the complaint, put a personal signature, that is, made it clear to the applicants that he personally checked the legality and validity of the appealed procedural decision, in connection with which there are no grounds for making measures of prosecutorial response.


05/29/2020 the applicants again sent a complaint to the Gorodishchensky District Court to the resolution of the inquiry body in accordance with Art. 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation, and, Oh Miracle! - Decree of the Gorodishchensky District Court of 02.06.2020 was refused to accept the applicants' complaints to the proceedings, because, as established by the court, on 05/29/2020 (the next “coincidence”?!) The disputed decree of the inquiry body on the refusal to initiate criminal proceedings of 01.03.2020 was canceled by the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district with the direction of materials for additional verification, that is, the prosecutor's office of the prosecutor's office. The district again backdered.


According to the order of the Prosecutor General’s Office of the Russian Federation dated January 26, 2017 No. 33 “On the Organization of Prosecutorial Supervision of the Procedural Activities of Inquiry Bodies”, in order to ensure a single approach to the prosecutor's supervision of the procedural activity of the bodies of inquiry, immediate response to the identified violations of the laws committed during the consideration of crime and investigation of crimes, The prosecutor ensures timely verification of the legality and validity of the procedural decisions of the inquiry bodies, investigators for each message about the crime, urgently responds to violation of the law. The resolution of the investigator, the interrogator to refuse to initiate criminal proceedings, in turn, should become the object of close attention of the prosecutor, both from the formal and the substantive side.
But apparently, for the prosecutor Alexei Dyakonov, this order is not mandatory for execution.
Why is the prosecutor afraid of this and what is afraid of quickly canceling the procedural decisions that he had previously recognized as absolutely legal?!
Based on this situation, it can be assumed that the prosecutor of the Gorodishchensky district Alexei Dyakonov on the eve of filing complaints to the court in accordance with Art. 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation, a prophetic dream was dreamed that if these complaints have entered the court and will be accepted for proceedings, the court will undoubtedly establish violations committed in making the contested procedural decisions, but then the facts of improper performance by employees of the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district of duties on the procedural activity of the bodies of inquiry will be revealed, which will be negatively affected by the negative activities of the body Image of the prosecutor's office.
In the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district of the Penza region, a vicious practice of canceling the decisions of the inquiry bodies on the refusal to initiate criminal proceedings, which are objects of judicial appeal in accordance with Art. 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation (often even before the issue of accepting such a complaint to the court’s proceedings), there is a difficult access to citizens to justice, despite the fact that citizens in a pre -trial order turned to the prosecutor of the Gorodishchensky district with the corresponding complaint in accordance with Art. 124 of the Code of Criminal Procedure of the Russian Federation, and the prosecutor made a decision to refuse to satisfy it.
There is no doubt that the district prosecutor is done intentionally in order to exclude the subject of appeal in court in order to avoid the formation of judicial practice on recognizing the procedural decisions of the inquiry bodies, after the prosecutor's office was recognized as legal and reasonable, as well as in order to avoid negative criticism of the district prosecutor's office by the higher management.
But still, why does such red tape take place: the security of officials of the prosecutor's office of the Gorodishchensky district or a conspiracy between the supervisory authority and the executive branch? What does the reader think?
I ask the chief prosecutor of the region Natalya Evgenievna Kancerov to pay close attention to this situation and take appropriate response measures.