
Excursion into the history of church collaboration
"Remember the traditional moral values of the Church!" I heard this full dignity in one of the discussions about the fate of Pussy Riot. But how did the historian most interested me in that discussion - what kind of church we were talking about? If about today's Russian Orthodox Church, then there must be some kind of misunderstanding. For there were no moral values from the middle of the XIII century, starting from the middle of the XIII century. She does not have such a tradition. And it is not very difficult to prove this for anyone who knows her story.
The date, of course, is familiar from the school bench: in the middle of the 13th century, Rus' won the Horde. What, however, was not explained to us at school is that since the conquest, the Russian Orthodox Church suddenly turned out to be the favorite of this very horde. And therefore, we do not know, as a rule, for which, in fact, the Mongol king (just like that, for the health of the king of the Russian, the Horde Khan, then prayed in the Orthodox churches) gave the Russian Orthodox Church with such generous privileges and immunities that, perhaps, perhaps, no other church in Europe.
Here is a decree of the king to his army: “They don’t need a tribute from the Church, nor the Popluzhny, nor the pits, nor the carts, nor war, nor the food, in all duties, will not be necessary for them, not which the Tsarieva is the duty.” Translated to modern Russian means that the Russian Orthodox Church was completely exempted from any taxes, duties and in general, the burdens that lined with the rest of the population of the conquered country.
And, no less importantly, the ROC was awarded the Supreme RPC of management and the court in its possessions (and these possessions were huge: under the auspices of the conquerors, the monasteries captured more than a third of all arable land in the country). Another tsarist decree reports: “But he knows the truth and the right judges and controls his own people, what is no longer: in robbery, and in Tatbe, and in any deeds the Metropolitan himself is in charge of, one or to whom he will order.”
Truly, that church stood in the middle of a ruined country as a fabulous temple, as a stronghold of well -being. And success. But…
But the conquerors were by no means philanthropists. They paid the Russian Orthodox Church - for collaboration. For the fact that she put at their feet the spiritual sword of Orthodoxy. For the fact that the preaching of humility to the Mongolian king and his glorious army sounded from the amvons. For the fact that she rejected from the church a people who stole from despair, who drowned in blood, this is a ferocious army.
Of course, the Horde’s power was barely staggered in Rus', completely different sermons sounded from the amvons: they cursed the “filthy” who enslaved the country. Without blinking an eye, the Russian Orthodox Church betrayed her patroness yesterday. The new one had to become the winner - Moscow. It was expected, of course, that she would confirm all the Horde “labels” and will protect the corporate property of the Russian Orthodox Church as jealous as their hordes protected.
In particular, the Russian Orthodox Church then bothered that the peasants flew from the church lands to the boyars (where, as a rule, there were no corvee). What was the land cost without the peasants processing it? It was necessary to prohibit them with transitions, fix them. In the end, the Church was used to the centuries of the yoke that in the foreground are its private -owned interests. And also to the fact that the power (that is, the horde) satisfies them at the first request. But then she suddenly found a braid on a stone.
Josephlans and non -possessors
Ivan III could not be liked by the first builder of the Moscow state, claims of the postmongol ROC. From his point of view, the Church was appropriate to be a pastor of the people, and not a landowner, not a moneylender, not an entrepreneur. And even more so not the state in the state. Even very loyal to the Russian Orthodox Church, historian A.N. Sakharov, who sees her main merit in the “struggle against the Catholic aggression of the West,” and he is forced to admit that “the church with its religious influence, land wealth, numerous benefits began to compete with the princely power.”
And the sovereign decided to bring the Russian Orthodox Church to his senses. First of all, the law on the Juryeval day (two weeks in November) was included in the lawsuit of 1497, when the peasants could freely leave the monastery lands. From now on, their consolidation could not be a question. It is clear that from this minute the Russian Orthodox Church hated the boyars, Yuryev day and ... sovereign.
The power that could not be leaning, which not only did not give it all with new privileges, like the Horde king, did not need the Josephlans (as the Russian Orthodox Church in the XV - XVIVV, named after their main ideologist Joseph Volotsky, the hegumen of the Volokolamsk monastery).
But Juryev was not limited to business. Ivan III pricked to the help of like -minded people, revered by the Volga elders, who broke away from the monastery Josephlatism and who considered church acquisition, not to mention the enslavement of peasants, mortal sin and heresy. Very soon, these non -possessors turned into a powerful church movement, putting forward the outstanding leaders of the Neil Sorsky and Vassian Patrikeev.
Here is what they answered with Joseph: “Test and understand, who from the age of century from those who shone in holiness and built the monasteries took care of acquiring villages? Who prayed to the princes for the benefit for themselves or for resentment for the peasants? Who tormented the human body with a scourge or put them on the shackles? " As you can see, the non -possessors called for the simplicity of the pre -Orordy church customs. For them, the Iosiflyan acquisition was the punishment of God for treason, for the reproach of "our Russian antiquity."
One by one-between the beginning of the 1480s and the mid-1560s-four generations of non-possessors will enter the arena of history. The struggle went with varying success. There were “their” bishops and even “their” metropolitans. But the Josephlans, whose heirs are considered by today's Russian Orthodox Church, were richer, more cunning and, as we will see soon, amorous. Ultimately, they won.
Their main political enemy - the Russian patrimonial aristocracy, the boyars - was defeated, non -possessiveness was declared heresy and destroyed, Yuryev was canceled, and the Russian peasantry was fixed tightly - for three long centuries. But the Josephlans achieved all this only in the end.
Back in the middle of the XVIT, the outcome of this epic struggle, which decided almost the entire future fate of Russia, was unclear. “Great Squeezd” reigned in the monasteries. Greed has eaten discipline, corruption - spiritual goals, profligacy - human decency. And it was clear to everyone. Even the young king Ivan IV.
In the well -known tsarist issues, the church cathedral of 1551 The distrust of the monastery ROC was expressed completely unambiguously. Judge for yourself. This is what the king asked her:
“The monasteries do not enter the sake of saving the soul, but to always be scolding. Archimandrites and abbesses are bought by their places, do not know either the service of God or the fraternity, bite the villages and lands from me. Where are those profits and who makes them sore? Is this all this sin to be recovered over? And how to get the benefits of worldly souls and disgust from all evil? If in monasteries everything is done not according to God, then what kind of good to expect from us, a worldly child? And through whom to ask us mercy from God? "
Agree, the questions were non -resistant.
Pirrova victory of Josephles
For Josephles, it was a terrible, alarming signal. Everything was complicated by the fact that the new Judicial Code of 1550 not only confirmed the law on the Juryeval day, but also in his last (58th) article legally forbidden the tsar to adopt new laws without the “advice and consent” of the boyars. In this situation, nothing but a coup d'etat, canceling all the laws of the Moscow state, could save the situation. And the Josephles mobilized all their resources to organize such a coup. And they had many resources.
First of all, they were lucky: the metropolitan at that time was “their own”. Macarius was also the teacher of the young king and knew his weakness well. Ivan Ivn did not look like his great grandfather, first builder. He was easily suggestible, pathologically cruel and desperately ambitious young men. It was decided to play on this. The coup plan consisted of three points. Firstly, it was inspired to the king that he was the heir in a straight line of “Augustus of Caesar” himself and there was no equal in Europe, except for the “Caesar” of the Holy Roman Empire.
Secondly, since all the crowned European smallness-Polish, Swedish or Danish-refused to recognize Ivan IV by the king, it should be studied, conquering, contrary to her, the land of the decayed Livonian order (Baltic states), against which the government categorically spoke out.
Thirdly, a seductive example of the Turkish Sultan Mehmet was proposed to the king, who not only did not obey his government, but also “ordered them to be alive and rivers like this: they will grow up the body again, ino will give their wine. And their skin ordered the papers to stuff and write on their skin - without such a thunderstorm, the truth in the kingdom is not visible. Like a horse under the king without knots, so a kingdom without a thunderstorm. ”
It is difficult to imagine that the most far -sighted of the Josephlyan hierarchs did not understand the risks of the upcoming coup. It was obvious that it was that they created a monster - the authorities that did not recognize any laws and restrictions capable of “living Odrati” of anyone who has to be reinforced, arbitrary, autocratic power. But the blood of most hierarchy inherited from the time of the yoke thirsty to cling to the chest “its” power, if you like, “Ordinsky syndrome”, which preferred to take a chance, has already entered the flesh and blood.
One way or another, the plan was a success. And barely struck a coup d'etat (known under the name of the oprichnins), as the Turkish “thunderstorm” broke over the Russian land, Ivan IV turned into Ivan the Terrible - and the heads flew, including the Josephla.
Since then, the Russian Orthodox Church love to represent yourself as a victim. And Metropolitan Philip was strangled by the oprichnik Malyuta Skuratov. Both Leninist repressions will recall, and Khrushchev. But not the half -word about the fact that they themselves created the “king of the rabder, who was bathed in the blood of the subjects for 24 years,” the words of Mikhail Lunin, one of the brightest minds of Decembrism. And they won’t tell you how they contributed to the Bolsheviks, not hitting a finger with a finger to help the temporary government - despite the fact that it was the patriarchy that returned them to the patriarchy.
Be that as it may, the treacherous attempt of Josephles to save their privileges with the help of a coup d'etat ended for them in the 16th century and really badly. Three times they forced them to pay an unprecedented fear and humiliation. For the first time, he forced them to the whole cathedral to participate in the disgusting comedy of the court over their own metropolitan. Secondary when the Pskov and Novgorod monasteries robbed them to the thread. And for the third time, when Tatar Simeon, who was set by him for the time of himself at the time of himself, took away all the preferential letters given to them by the Horde, and demanded a ruined bribe for their return. That was a terrible royal joke.
The peasantry paid for their "Horde syndrome" for their "Ordynsky syndrome". Of course, as we recall from the time of the yoke, the fate of their own people was the last that was interested in the Russian Orthodox Church. Especially if its earthly wealth stood at the stake. But the fact that protecting these wealth, they for the second time caused incredible suffering to their people (Nikolai Karamzin was the first to equate the reign of the Terrible to the Mongol invasion) should not be forgotten.
There is no sadder than a completely stationary description of the disasters of the people in official acts of the times of the oprichnina, which continued mechanically, like empty millstones, spin and spin, describing that which is no longer in the world. “In the village in Kyublech, - we read in one of these acts, - Ignatka Lukyanov’s bow was desolate from the oprichnina - the guardsmen robbed the abdomen, and the cattle were spotted, and he died, the children ran unknownly. Afanasov’s Eremakek Luke was desolate from the oprichnina - the guardsmen robbed his stomach, but he was killed, but he had no children. Luke Melentyika desooped from the oprichnina - the guardsmen robbed his stomach, scotch the cattle, he ran unknownly ... "
And endless, like Russian spaces, paper versts of this chronicle of human misfortune, stretch and stretch. Again, the bow (site) was desolate, again the stomach (property) was robbed, again he disappeared unknownly. And not the boyars, after all, are all these Ignatka, Yeremayki and the Melentyaks, not the enemies of the sovereign, just men who had a “stomach” who could be robbed, were wives and daughters who could be raped, “onions” could be taken away ...
Unknown
Here my competence ends as a historian of the Russian Orthodox Church. From now on, my only advantage over the reader is a historical retrospective. Alas, it testifies to undeniably - for three and a half centuries, the Hierarchy of the Russian Orthodox Church took care of exclusively about its earthly wealth. For their sake, she was ready not only to loyally cooperate with the foreign conqueror, but also to inspire, according to Karamzin, "the second Mongol invasion." What kind of moral values are there! When the non -possessors reminded her of them, she declared them heretics, Judging - and destroyed. So where did she get in this case the “tradition of moral values”?
Theoretically, she could, of course, find her in the next centuries. I could, if I sincerely repented in the heavy terrible sins that we talked about. But have you heard from the mouth of the Hierarchs of the Russian Orthodox Church at least the word of repentance? On the contrary, they hired a whole army of writing servants, designed to justify all its sins. And most importantly, she continued to sin - in the same spirit in which she began in the XIII century. The same "Horde syndrome" in 1943, when she clung to Stalin’s chest, as once to the chest of the Mongolian king, and devotedly collaborated with his special services. And in 2012, when she tries to reinforce the ideological void of Chekist power with her medieval canons.
* * *
I know that today's Josephles failed to kill the tradition of pre -Orordy Orthodoxy and non -possession. It is carefully stored in the hearts of thousands of priests and laity. Yes, their parishes are poor. Yes, their voices are barely audible for the noise of official propaganda. But they are, these parishes. And the very presence of this alternative is the guarantee that the moral values of Orthodoxy have a future. For these values begin with overcoming the "Horde syndrome", from independence.