
The State Duma is considering a bill limiting access to the works of "foreign -agents" in libraries. Although in August the parliament went on vacation without accepting the amendments, some libraries decided to “reassure” in advance. The journalists of the “New tab” talked with librarians from different regions of Russia and learned what they think about the intervention of officials in their work, why some even pro -government libraries condemn censorship and why readers sometimes steal books of “foreign agents”.
“If I take the book and will not return it, that is, stole it, what should I do according to the rules?” Similar questions began to be asked the librarian Natalia ** from a small city in the suburbs more and more often. In her opinion, so readers try to save some books or get them to a personal library while there is such an opportunity.
-They ask us: “Have you written something else? And write off in our caring hands, ”says Natalia.
According to her, some libraries have already begun to get rid of the books of “foreign agents”, despite the fact that there are no such requirements in the legislation. The works of Dmitry Glukhovsky, Mikhail Zygar, Dmitry Bykov and other writers included in the register of the Ministry of Justice are written off with dilapidated books and handed over to the waste paper. As Natalia put it, the libraries "fell before the shot."
She heard from her colleagues that they had already received an official letter with a recommendation to remove the books of “foreign -agents” from the reading rooms, “so as not to annoy the public.” The list was attached to him, but she herself did not see him.
- So far, it has not reached “451 degrees on Fahrenheit” , so the books are not burned, but simply write off and handed over to waste paper. Citizens are vigilant, look, they say, they say, they removed Akunin, well done, ”says Natalia about those readers who do not want to“ save ”literature.
The novel-antiotopia is science fiction writer Ray Bradbury. The work of the main character of the novel is to burn books prohibited in the future of the future.
In the library where it works, the books of “foreign Agents” were not sent to waste paper, but hidden to the closed fund. First, the librarian printed on the printer the dicks “This message (material) was created ...”, but colleagues dissuaded her to label books, because “this will disgrace their honest name of the librarians”. So far, we have decided to limit himself to stickers with an age limit of 18+, as required by the legislation.
A separate room where books are rarely asked by readers and additional copies of books presented on a subscription.

Natalya said that sometimes the books “Ino -Agents” passed by readers are put in an inattention in the reading room. But for works where there are descriptions of the life of LGBT people, you have to follow more closely. For example, a book marked 18+ “Summer in a pioneer tie” of Malisova and Silvanova (recognized by “foreign agents”), despite the demand among readers, librarians are easier to write off than to hide in the fund.
Since she allegedly promotes LGBT (LGBT’s movement is recognized as an “extremist organization” in Russia), then, according to Natalia, if this book is accidentally found on shelves, library staff can be involved in gay propaganda. There is no responsibility for the books of the auto-agents.
Recently, Natalia made repairs in the library, and the youth began to come here to work and look at exhibitions, and the attitude to the books seemed to have changed - they began to be more interested in them. Natalia believes that now reading is a new luxury, he says that they even wrote about the fashion for books in Vogue magazine.
The enhanced control of the library sphere, Natalya explains this: “Because we have, in my opinion, all living and good is settled that suddenly sprouts on our plains. Of course, both the authorities and caring citizens have now become intently to look at the libraries. ”
A bill on restriction of access to the books of “foreign agents”: who initiated it and what is its essenceIn the spring of 2024, State Duma deputies proposed amending the Federal Law “On Library Affairs”. The bill No. 584955-8 dated March 26, 2024 limits in libraries access to the books of authors recognized by foreign agents.
The draft law was introduced by five deputies - Elena Yampolskaya, Alexander Sholokhov, Olga Germanova (all three from United Russia), Elena Drapeko (“Fair Russia - for Truth”), Dmitry Pevtsov (“New People”). Four of them are associated with the Ministry of Culture, the project “Dumabingo”, specializing in the identification of lobbyism in the State Duma, drew attention. The bill was adopted in the first reading, the second reading was postponed. How the law will act in practice is still unclear.
In fact, now the Ministry of Culture will decide what to do with the books of “foreign agents”, says Ivan Brilulsky lawyer in the field of constitutional justice. According to him, this is another framework law: the restriction is formulated, as it were indirectly, to complicate the judicial verification of violation of constitutional rights.
Now all the restrictions related to the status of a foreign agent are regulated by the provisions of the Federal Law of July 14, 2022 255-ФЗ “On Monitoring the activities of persons under foreign influence”. For libraries, one item is important in it: "A foreign agent is not entitled to produce information products for minors." Otherwise, this law does not limit access to the documents created by “foreign agents”: the main thing is that the book has a marking 18+ and that the publication does not fall into the hands of children.
In one of the university libraries of the North-West Federal District, they have already heard about the preparing law. In the meantime, the leadership of the libraries did not give clear instructions what to do with the books of "foreign -agents", the employees themselves monitor the list of the Ministry of Justice. According to the librarians, they, just in case, constantly monitor the department’s website and check on the electronic catalog whether they have books of new “foreign agents” to make an appropriate mark. Monthly report this to the authorities and warn colleagues, which books are best removed from open access. But some librarians are in no hurry to show such an initiative.
- I informed the subscription employee that it was necessary to remove the textbook on the economy of the lips . And the colleague replied that it would work with these publications only after her official paper will have on the table, ”says Ksenia's library worker **.
Igor LipsitsRussian scientist-economist, professor of the Higher School of Economics in 2001–2023. He created the first in Russia a full cycle of school textbooks on economics from grades 7 to 11. In March 2024, the Ministry of Justice recognized the Lipsite in the agent.
If the reader wants to take home the book “Inoage”, it will be given from the fund, warning about the status of the author (if the visitor was 18 years old).
- In closed funds, we made bookmarks marked 18+ and the signature that the author of the book was included in the register [foreign agents]. But this is more for us. We cannot make an official marking, because there is no such order, ”said Ksenia.
But in the municipal libraries of the North -West, according to her information, they have already begun on books on books on their own initiative.

In the library where Ksenia works, there are more than a hundred books of “foreign agents”. Most of all - the works of Boris Akunin, Lyudmila Ulitskaya, Dmitry Bykov. They were taken before, but recently, according to Ksenia, these books began to be asked even more often. “They are probably afraid that they will not read later,” she believes.
-And someone, maybe in principle, will not read, because the author is a foreign agent. This is a personal matter for everyone. The main thing, of course, is not to overdo it in all these laws. Many books have been written long before all events, and it is unlikely that the author inserted something illegal in them, ”the librarian argues.
In the book sphere, they laugh at the foreign agency while they can. “I myself read the books of“ foreign Agents ”, of course. Many managed to read even before the authors received such a status. I consider the law on foreign agents very stupid, to be honest. They joke that declaring someone in the agent is the best recommendation. And this is really partly so. I was at the book festival in July, took the book by Arkhipova , went to another stand, and the seller girl saw and said: “We have books of applicants for the title of foreign agents. Let's show,” Ksenia smiles.
Alexandra ArkhipovFolklorist, social anthropologist. The Ministry of Justice recognized her as an ino -agent.
But on the works of authors included by Rosfinmonitoring in the list of terrorists and extremists, some Russians have already developed self -censorship. “ The authors who were included in the list of extremists have never asked, although before that the books were in use and someone took them regularly,” the librarian recalls.
Boris Akunin, Svetlana Petriychuk, Evgeny Berkovich were included in this list, for example,.

Russian legislation prohibits the spread of extremist materials, as well as their production and storage for distribution. And if with extremist literature it is more or less clear, then how the new law will legally limit access to the books of “foreign agents” (and they can not only be authors, but also editors, publishers, illustrators or simply write an introductory article) is not yet very clear.
114-ФЗ "On Combating Extremist Activities"
The statement of the Russian Library Association says that in their work the libraries are guided, among other things, the Constitution about the right of citizens to freely receive information.
Recently, at all -Russian library conferences, special sections have been conducting special sections, where employees are discussing work with the books of “foreign agents”. For example, at the conference “Corporate Library Systems: Technologies and Innovation” in June 2024, a whole round table was devoted to this issue - “Inoagents, inventory or verification: issues requiring solution”.
True, the participants of the discussion in St. Petersburg themselves did not understand how preparing amendments to the law can be put into practice. Tatyana Petrusenko, the executive secretary of the sections on the formation of library funds, noted that of all the laws that limit access to information, the law on foreign agents - “the most weakly modified, slightly fulfilled to library activity”.
She mentioned that in Russia the prosecutors have already checked libraries - apparently, for compliance with not yet accepted norms: “In Russian libraries [in Yaroslavl, Vladimir, Murmansk, Arkhangelsk and other cities - approx. Ed.] Checks are going on now. <...> Prosecutors or their assistants go with a list. ” As Petrusenko explained, this is a "list of writers with whom they [prosecutors] in libraries are looking for foreign agents."

In the public domain on the libraries sites you can find a list of 38 "foreigners". The employees made it themselves, relying on the data of the Ministry of Justice. Some institutions, for example, the Moscow Provincial Universal Library, even release something like “ leadership ” on working with books of “foreign agents”. For example, there are advised colleagues to go to court if “the librarian or visitors of the library has suspicions of the presence of signs of extremist literature regarding the author’s work recognized by the foreigner.”
When libraries ask for explanations from higher departments, they often ignore questions. “If we have some of our library events, we often invite representatives of the Ministry of Justice or the prosecutor’s office, but they never come to us precisely because they avoid giving any recommendations, especially in this, I don’t know how to say, slippery and incomprehensible business,” Petrusenko complains.
Lilia ** lives in the same city near Moscow as Natalya, but works in another library. She does not hide that some authors-“foreign agents” belongs negatively, but she condemns book censorship: “We have already passed it. We are Gumilyov, and Pasternak, and Brodsky already “burned”. Therefore, do not do this. The content of these books is worthy. The fact that people behave like that - well, yes, they lead badly. Well, what are the books to blame? " - the librarian argues.
She cited the example of the work of two writers:
- Take the same Akunin - very good, light reading. I want to relax? To unload the brain? High -quality, good reading. Who loves historical detectives - please. I recommended him to everyone. Take Ulitskaya. Yes, says nonsense now, but the texts are magnificent, Russian, syllable. Try to find such an author who writes like that.

In recent years, the work of librarians has changed significantly. According to Lilia, now they should be able to: keep social networks, photograph, organize events. The hour that was previously given to familiarize themselves with new books so that the librarians could give readers to readers, and canceled.
In the library room where Lilia works, they made repairs - there are new ceiling, floor, windows and blinds. True, funding was not enough for the walls and updating furniture, and the repair itself stretched for five years. The library goes into a digital format of work: all books are entered into an electronic database, and now you need to form a reader ticket through public services.
- The state should know everything that you eat, where you go. He is interested in the state, what is your spiritual life and what you live, ”Lilia is ironic with sadness.
It is against digitalization, because books are something “too personal”, and the right to read in the library “should be unconditional”, and not only for those who have issued a reader’s ticket for public services. But Lilia does not argue with the authorities on this subject.
- We have it like now: do not like it - a suitcase, station, go look for work elsewhere. Now they do not keep anyone anywhere. Or you adapt in some way, you enter this system, try to adapt it to yourself somehow, with minimal losses for colleagues and readers, or you are not working here, ”says Lilia.

There are few people go to the library in the small city of the Tver region, but there are regular readers. These are mainly pensioners and students. The former are often interested in love novels and detectives, the latter with classics and scientific literature. Oksana ** settled here as a librarian three years ago. According to her, the work is hard, they pay a little (the vacancy of the second librarian has long remained unoccupied), but Oksana likes this work, she likes to communicate with people.
Once a year, she, together with her colleagues, conducts an audit and write off “morally obsolete” and dilapidated books. Some of them fall on the table for bookcrossing, but behind most of them a car arrives and takes to waste paper. The books of "foreign Agents" have so far been put into the book depository .
Literature storage department closed to readers. Books from it are issued by prior order.
Olga ** works in one of the libraries of the millionaire city. Due to the internal order, here they have already got rid of the books of the authors-“foreign agents”. Just in case, even bookcrossing was closed: suddenly someone will bring a “forbidden” book, and the librarians will not notice in time.
- We were sent a list of books that need to be removed, and [we] wrote these books by defectiveness. What did they do with them then? They were taken away. Most likely, passed to waste paper. However, some employees take them home, and it also happens that readers steal the books of “foreign agents”: they take them on cards, and then do not return them. In return, others are bought or the cost is reimbursed by money, ”says Olga.

An employee of one of the libraries of the Vologda region said that she also took home several books of “foreign aggress” to save them, because she was afraid that someday they can simply remove them. The leadership of the libraries is trying to play it safe, it is not ready to take risks for the sake of books, but the librarians, according to Olga, are very difficult to get rid of the works of “foreign agents”. She sees the reason for this hidden conflict in the fact that the libraries are not guided by librarians, but managers.
“For him [manager], the main thing is to avoid problems and stay in its place, and the value of books for him is quite arbitrary,” Olga spreads his hands.
According to her, the books of "foreign Agents" were seized, including from children's libraries. Например, книгу Андрея Макаревича «Я змея».
— Страдают не только авторы, но и иллюстраторы, и вся команда, работавшая над книгой. Особенно жалко сборники, в которых есть один из авторов-«иноагентов». Мы вынуждены изымать и их. Адекватные библиотекари понимают, что это большая проблема. Нет никакого официального поручения или регламента, и ценность, которой владеет библиотека, уничтожается своими руками, — с грустью говорит Ольга.
**Имена героинь материала изменены по их просьбе.
