| Officials have launched pre-sale preparations for Yukos The scandal surrounding the future sale of Yuganskneftegaz is growing more and more. On Tuesday, a representative of the Russian Ministry of Justice announced that the bank hired by the department, Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein (DrKW), has completed an assessment of Yuganskneftegaz, and the lower limit for the company’s value is $10.4 billion. Moreover, the Ministry of Justice reported, in the event of a sale of a minority stake, the seller may apply discount of 60%. Yesterday DrKW, confused by the interpretation of his report, decided to publish it. It turned out that the Ministry of Justice actually announced only the most conservative scenario, keeping silent about the rest.
The scandals did not end there. Yesterday evening, the Interfax agency, without citing a source, reported: “The state will put up for auction 76.8% of the authorized capital of OJSC Yuganskneftegaz, the starting price of the package will be calculated based on the valuation of all shares of the company at $10.4 billion with a discount of 60% as for a minority stake. Thus, the starting price of this block of shares will be just over $4 billion.” It is necessary to clarify that the capital of Yuganskneftegaz consists of 56 shares - 43 ordinary and 13 preferred. Thus, according to Interfax, all ordinary, that is, voting shares will be put up for sale. The agency does not explain why this stake is a minority stake and on what basis a discount will be applied to its value. However, citing a high-ranking source in the government, he adds: “most likely, one of the companies affiliated with Gazprom will take part in the auction for Yuganskneftegaz.”
Officials and entrepreneurs interviewed by the Vremya Novostey newspaper were discouraged by the agency's message. The state's desire to lower the value of Yuganskneftegaz is not in doubt. But the arithmetic presented by Interfax sources is equally similar to the truth (if we believe that the authorities dared to conduct a dishonest auction) and to a “provocation” in the sense of an attempt to prevent a dubious auction. However, a Vremya Novostey source close to the Kremlin says: “Why is it necessary to draw a line between truth and provocation? I think this is the case when the truth is a provocation and vice versa.”
Press Secretary of Gazprom Chairman of the Board Alexei Miller Sergei Kupriyanov, who is on a business trip in Beijing along with the head of the gas company, denied information that the holding intends to participate in the auction for the sale of Yuganskneftegaz.
It seems that the only one in this story who cares about its reputation is the Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein bank, which yesterday published a report on the assessment of Yuganskneftegaz. “I don’t think that their income from cooperation with the government or Gazprom will compensate for the damage to the reputation that this cooperation could cause,” says a source at another international investment bank. DrKW said in a statement that "in the interests of transparency, and strictly for informational purposes, with the permission of the Ministry of Justice, the decision has been made to publish a summary of the report to the press." The bank published a letter that was sent to the Ministry of Justice on October 6, marked “strictly confidential.” The bank's report confirmed that the figure of $10.4 billion cited by officials is the most conservative estimate of the enterprise. Although the appraiser is confident that the range of the enterprise’s value is still within the range of 18.6 - 21.1 billion dollars. And taking into account liabilities and tax claims, it is 14.7 - 17.3 billion dollars.
“In addition to the main task - assessing the value of the entire Yuganskneftegaz as a separate enterprise - Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein provided the Ministry of Justice with advice on the potential value of a minority stake in the company. When analyzing the minority stake, it can be expected that control over Yuganskneftegaz will remain on the part of the majority shareholder, and that the minority stake will be illiquid, the report says. -- We believe that specific factors such as minority shareholder rights, corporate governance, company structure, and restrictions on value realization are likely to cause a discount to the proportionate value of a controlling interest relative to a minority interest. However, such a discount can be significant, depending on the above factors.” The bank's letter does not mention a specific discount of 60%.
The bank notes that Yuganskneftegaz can be assessed based on the amount of income that the company will receive in the future from its activities according to three scenarios. The first is the most conservative (the Ministry of Justice used it). It provides that the enterprise's reserves will remain at the level of the end of 2003 (2.7 billion tons), and production will not grow. In this case, Yuganskneftegaz, according to the bank, can be valued at $14.3 billion. If we take into account YUKOS’s message about increasing its reserves this year and assume that the holding’s production will increase annually by 10%, then the price of the enterprise will be $24.8 billion. With 5 percent growth, the company will be worth $19.8 billion.
However, the company is burdened with obligations. These are loans received by YUKOS from Societe Generale in the amount of $2.6 billion, for which Yuganskneftegaz acts as a guarantor, as well as the debts of the enterprise itself to YUKOS Capital, which amount to about $300 million. At the same time, the bank reminds of the claims tax authorities to Yuganskneftegaz for 2002 in the amount of 27.8 billion rubles. ($951.3 million). If this tax claim comes into force, the value of share capital will decrease further.
As noted by Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein, the valuation of Yuganskneftegaz at $14.3 billion, which assumes that the holding’s reserves will not change and production will stop growing, is too conservative. But if we consider this option, then after deducting $2.9 billion of liabilities and the amount of tax claims, the amount for which the asset can be sold will be $10.4 billion. The Bank notes that subsequent events related, for example, to licenses companies or new tax claims may change the value of the asset. Andrey DENISOV, Denis REBROV |
|