Real estate tax reform looks set to stall for a long time. This is the result of yesterday's round table, at which it was discussed by representatives of Veliky Novgorod and Tver, the cities that experimented with this reform.
Four years ago, officials set themselves the goal of replacing the three taxes that are currently levied on real estate with one on real estate. However, during the experiment in Veliky Novgorod and Tver, such a tangle of problems was discovered that it is at least naive to count on quick success. Nevertheless, the heads of local administrations intend to ask the government to extend the law on conducting an experiment in real estate taxation for another two years, until 2005. After all, the new tax will in the future be one of the permanent sources of income for local budgets. The federal budget does not plan to allocate funds for this reform.
Today, according to the Tax Code, real estate is subject to three taxes (on the property of organizations, on the property of individuals and land), of which each business entity pays two: the land tax is combined with either the first or the second. According to the law of 1997, it was decided to switch to a single tax, which is expected to help form the property in the form of an integral property complex (building plus land).
According to the director of the autonomous non-profit organization “Institute for Problems of Registration, Valuation and Taxation of Real Estate” Natalia Kalinina (one of the authors of the reform project), with the transition to one tax “there will be a stable source of income for local budgets and clarity in property rights, which will have a positive impact on investment climate." Deputy Minister of Finance Mikhail Motorin estimated the volume of the planned unified real estate tax at more than 100 billion rubles.
However, in the experimenting regions the reform is proceeding with difficulty. Yesterday's meeting turned into a list of reasons that hinder its implementation. According to Novgorod Mayor Alexander Korsunov, the undeveloped infrastructure of this market comes first: there is no system of “mass valuation” and a unified real estate register has not been created. In Russia, almost nowhere is an inventory of existing real estate maintained, and built ones are not taken into account.
Deputy Head of the Ministry of Economic Development Arkady Dvorkovich said that there is no interaction between the Ministry of Economic Development, Gosstroy, Roszemkadastr, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Taxes and the Ministry of Justice - all federal departments required to do cadastral and technical records, register property rights, as well as taxpayers and enterprises. According to Ms. Kalinina, departmental inconsistency is aggravated by the delimitation of land ownership rights and - what is much more important - powers between the federal center and the regions.