The ice has broken. The Tomsk administration held a round table “Green Tomsk. How to save trees." The topic of discussion was the work of “resource workers” in pruning and demolishing plantings during scheduled and emergency work. The discussion was attended by “Landscape Volunteers”, members of the “Active Citizens Club”, representatives of the Center for the Development of the Urban Environment, activists and creators of the “The City Doesn’t Enrage” project, as well as representatives of the resource supply organizations “Gorseti”, “Rosseti Tomsk” and “Tomskvodokanal”.
Author: Pavel Petrenko Winner of the photo competition “Ungreen Tomsk”Over the past few years, townspeople have been worried - trees are being barbarically cut and destroyed in Tomsk. Not always, but often – this is the work of “resource specialists”. Power engineers, in response to reproaches against them, hide behind regulations that allow them to disfigure trees under wires. The mayor's office simply throws up its hands and sends unsubscribes to requests from citizens. The irritation of Tomsk residents reached its peak in the spring of this year, when power engineers actually destroyed the luxurious apple tree alley, the only attraction of Bering Street. After this barbaric tree trimming, Regional Committee for Nature Protection decided to add fuel to the fire and announced a photo competition “Green Tomsk” and received a response project from the townspeople “Ungreen Tomsk”. The Instagram channel “The City Doesn’t Infuriate” launched a photo contest, asking people to send not only evidence of abuse of trees in the city, but also to write a request to the mayor’s office demanding to indicate who carried out the barbaric pruning of trees and on what basis.
We don’t know how many photos of “Green Tomsk” the Regional Committee for Nature Protection received, but hundreds of citizens responded to the call of social activists. In fact, the results of this competition began the discussion of the problem of how to protect trees from the chainsaws of “resource-seekers”.
Dmitry Polyakov said that for several months on the community platform “The City Doesn’t Enrage,” they collected the opinions of residents on assessing the actions of local “landscape resource workers.”
– From time to time in our public we talked about the problems of landscaping in our city. But the key moment was the barbaric pruning of apple trees on Bering. After that, we were bombarded with a flurry of photographs and complaints about similar problems in different parts of the city. There were times when we received five to seven messages a day about various types of felling and pruning of trees. We ourselves did not expect that this would be such a global problem for Tomsk,” said Dmitry Polyakov.
During close communication with citizens and regularly sending requests to the mayor's office, it turned out that in 80% of cases, cutting and pruning of trees in the city is carried out with violations. They either were not agreed upon with the mayor's office or did not comply with the work regulations!
Author: TV2 Pruning apple trees on Belinsky with GorsetsTomsk residents had the most complaints about electricians. Taking into account the fact that the whole of Tomsk is entangled in power lines and wires, citizens are concerned that all the streets of the city will soon be disfigured.
The topic of farewells was picked up by the regional Duma deputy, head of the regional branch of A Just Russia and representative of the Active Citizens Club Galina Nemtseva. “Every year, wires envelop our city more and more. Accordingly, in order to comply with all requirements and standards for the safety of wires, electricians will increasingly disfigure trees. Snowball. We need to stop it, study the experience of other cities, in particular Novokuznetsk and Kazan. There are special municipal programs in which resource specialists participate, and together they remove communications underground.”
Galina Nemtseva noted that budgets for the next three years are being formed right now, and if we admit that a huge number of wires is a problem for the city, then we need to set aside funds to solve it now.
Representatives of resource supplying organizations, in turn, explained that in their work on pruning trees in security zones of power lines, they are guided by the requirements of federal legislation. Thus, the branch of Rosseti FGC UES - MES of Siberia, whose contractors pruned apple trees on Bering, wrote that although the legislation allows for complete clearing of vegetation from the protective zones of overhead lines, power engineers take into account the wishes of the public and perform crown pruning according to the minimum possible requirements.
Author: TV2 Lumberjacks of the branch of Rosseti FGC UES - MES of Siberia on BeringPerhaps in Krasnoyarsk, where the company’s management is located and where the official reply came from, they did not see the hemp of the apple trees after complying with the “minimum possible requirements.” They were unable to send Rosseti FGC UES - MES of Siberia on a business trip to Tomsk. Perhaps they were afraid that the expenses of the business trip would entail an increase in the electricity tariff. Yes, yes - this is not a joke. One of the main arguments of electricians why they cannot professionally and accurately form tree crowns under the wires is that this will inevitably lead to an increase in electricity tariffs. It turns out that it is concern for the wallets of energy consumers that forces electricians to trim trees to stumps once every four years, and not annually, according to tree care requirements.
General Director of Zelenstroy Vladimir Tulasov noted that previously, specialized specialists had always been involved in pruning and shaping trees in the city. In the early 2000s, “resource specialists” decided to save money on trees and began to trim them at random.
Our opinion is that pruning and shaping of trees should be carried out by specially trained people. Resource supply organizations should announce competitions and hire companies that do this professionally to work with trees.
Vladimir Tulasov noted that Zelenstroy is not the only organization that professionally cares for green spaces in Tomsk. When asked how a representative of Zelenstroy assessed the pruning of apple trees on Bering, Vladimir Tulasov noted that the electricians had gone too far and that a specialist, of course, would not have acted so radically.
The opinion of a colleague from Zelenstroy was supported by the director of the Siberian Botanical Garden of National Research TSU, Mikhail Yamburov. He noted that it is often impossible to understand in our city whether tree pruning is carried out in a coordinated manner or not. “We often see that trees have been pruned and it is not clear why it was done. So, on Kievskaya Street, for example, hawthorn bushes were pruned. These were some of the oldest bushes in the city. They had a topping made. The entire crown was cut off. They didn’t bother anyone and there weren’t even any wires nearby. Pruning has led to the fact that most of the trees are dying or have already died. We were never able to find out who did it,” said Mikhail Yamburov.
This example led the head of the Botanical Garden to the fact that all work in the city should be thoughtful and planned. To do this, there must be a long-term concept for greening the city for 10-20 years in the future. If such a thing exists, then no one knows anything about it. And in order to coordinate all the work with green spaces in the city, according to Mikhail Yamburov, there should be a position of chief landscape designer in the mayor’s office.
Author: TV2 Apple alley on Beringa after pruning We understand that the service, which is currently involved in green spaces in the city and has only three people, cannot physically control what happens to the trees and competently plan the replacement and planting of new trees. This service should be expanded, says the director of the Siberian Botanical Garden. 
The executive director of Gorseti, Maxim Reznikov, recalled at a round table at the mayor’s office that it was during his time as deputy mayor in the Tomsk administration that the environmental committee was liquidated. “As a result, our urban forests have become ownerless, and green spaces are equated to benches and are considered not the most important element of improvement,” Reznikov stated.
Another revelation that came from the lips of the chief electrician of Tomsk, Maxim Reznikov, is that pruning trees is of a notification nature and no felling tickets are needed for this! Those. "Gorseti" can do whatever they want with the trees under the wires, without coordinating it with either the Landscape Commission or anyone else.
Author: TV2 City networks cut apple trees on Belinsky We are notifying the mayor's office what and where we plan to do this season. And the fact that the administration does not have a greening policy is not our fault. First we need to agree on what should grow and where. And then ask why you defaced such a beautiful tree. And when they ask us why you touched the birch tree, in theory they shouldn’t have planted birch trees under the wires,” insists Maxim Reznikov. 
Sergei Dorofeev, a social activist and head of the IT company Rubius, could not restrain himself here.
- We have wires. There is a legacy - trees that grow uncontrollably under them. There are trees that actually fall and create emergency situations. Nobody denies this. But the conflict lies in the fact that it is much easier for network companies to come, cut down the stump and hide behind this economic feasibility. Like everything is for the benefit of electricity consumers, to curb the growth of tariffs. But no one asked the consumers themselves.
If you give free rein to the networkers, they will completely tear down all the trees. Look how many wires we have on the streets. If they completely destroy everything that is under the wires, then the city will go bald by 70 percent. Therefore, the mayor's office must develop the rules of the game. If power engineers say that birch trees should not grow under wires, then we say, okay, and plant shrubs there. The city should belong to the citizens, not the electricians.
Author: provided by Dmitry Polyakov Pruning apple trees on Nakhimov PJSC "TRK" ("Rosseti Tomsk")The outcome of the discussion between resource workers and public activists was summed up by the acting mayor of Tomsk, Mikhail Ratner.
– We have two ways in relations with resource supply organizations. The first is to build a dialogue. The second is to strengthen the legislative framework and penalties. For now we are working in dialogue mode. I see the response. In addition to resource specialists, there are other interested parties. They need to be identified and worked with. The approach should be the same. We should not ruin the green fund that we have. What have we already done as a first step? We are including new specialists in the work of the landscape commission. We want to never have a black box again. Many people believe that the decisions made are incomprehensible. This needs to be changed. It is necessary to seek compromises between the rules that resource managers have (it is clear that they have a serious responsibility in the event of excesses, God forbid, any (knocks on the table)) and the rules that are generated by the defenders of green Tomsk. It would be nice to have some kind of public control. We have a landscaping program. Standard product. It requires updating. Let's have this as our next topic. We will present the program and listen to criticism. Regarding the performers. Once upon a time there was a municipal service - Gorzelenkhoz. But now the legislation is pushing us to optimize the process and act through contracts and competitions. We will try to look for Tomsk contractors.