The oversight agency insists on eliminating legal loopholes that allow “agreeing” on the extent of permissible transformations of historical buildings, and demands that their demolition be banned altogether.
The prosecutor's office demands to change the law on security zones, eliminating corruption factors
City Law No. 820, adopted in 2009, “On the boundaries of zones for the protection of cultural heritage sites...” in many ways became a document of compromise. VOOPIiK experts managed to achieve the inclusion of a number of fundamental amendments: for example, a ban on the demolition of all, and not just historical buildings under protection, built before 1917 (this is for the central regions, in the rest - before 1957). But the counter-efforts of the executive branch also ensured the consolidation of a clause guaranteeing officials a feeding trough: the permissibility of dismantling emergency buildings with their subsequent reconstruction if this emergency cannot be eliminated.
At the same time, the very concept of accidents de jure is absent, as well as the criteria for making decisions about the impossibility of its elimination. Over the past time, more than one ancient building has collapsed into the resulting legislative gap - the most resonant was the demolition of the Literary House on Nevsky. The examination, carried out with the investor's money, led to the fatal conclusion required by the customer, although the data indicated in the examination showed that the tested samples of brick and mortar had a safety margin that exceeded those of new buildings.
It is also generally accepted in the professional community that modern technologies make it possible to preserve a building in any, even the most deplorable, condition - it is just a matter of will, time and money. The head of the regional Stroynadzor service, Alexander Ort, also admitted this: “The concept of “impossibility of eliminating accidents” is meaningless from a technical point of view at the current level of development of construction technologies. In this case, “impossibility” can be understood as expressed economic or other inexpediency,” said the head of the department, which is not at all called upon to take care of business benefits for taxpayers’ money.
The prosecutor's office, having undertaken an anti-corruption examination of Law 820 and turning to several episodes of its application, discovered: in similar cases, officials issue opposite verdicts. Thus, KGIOP, citing the lack of evidence of irreversible accidents, refuses to approve the demolition of one investor (Mayakovskogo St., 5) and gives the go-ahead to the other to dismantle the building (Voronezhskaya St., 26–28).
We also identified another potential source of income in the text of the law: the established ban on changing the architectural design of the front facades is accompanied by the phrase: “With the exception of local changes in accordance with the conclusion of the state body for the protection of cultural heritage objects.” At the same time, the concept of “local change” is not defined in any way, “and therefore decisions are actually made at the discretion of officials,” the St. Petersburg prosecutor concludes.
In support of this thesis, the letter from the supervisory agency also provides several examples. Thus, KGIOP does not object to the installation of a separate entrance on the front facade of house 21 in Saperny Lane or in house 32/1 on Fontanka, but refuses to satisfy a similar request for house 63/13 on Kamennoostrovsky Prospekt.
The content of the law allowing decisions to be made by agreement with officials may entail a violation of the rights of citizens and organizations to use land and transform the historical, urban and natural environment. Based on this reasonable conclusion, the prosecutor demanded that adjustments be made: to establish the concept of “local changes”, and to exclude the passage about the admissibility of dismantling irreversibly damaged houses altogether. Thus, the demolition of historical buildings is prohibited altogether.
The requirement to make appropriate changes to Law 820 was ordered to be fulfilled immediately, having considered the issue at the next meeting of the city parliament. The newly appointed speaker Vyacheslav Makarov is clearly not going to rush yet. The protocol sector of the Legislative Assembly, dated December 27, formalized the letter from Sergei Litvinenko only on January 18, at the end of the parliamentary vacation, which has now stretched for almost a month.
Perhaps, having rested after the grueling division of portfolios, parliamentarians will consider the message from the prosecutor's office at the next meeting.
Tatiana LIKHANOVA
Recorded by Victoria RABOTNOVA, caricature by Victor Bogorad, cartoonbank.ru