About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
04/06/2006
Author
Hidden
Source
Novaya Gazeta Saint Petersburg
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Hour of the bear

A year and a half before the elections of the St. Petersburg city parliament, experts are already beginning to predict their possible results


One of these forecasts was presented by Valentin Bianchi and Alexander Seravin from the Department of Political Psychology of St. Petersburg State University. Taking the results of the 2002 elections as a basis, they “recalculated” them based on the results of voting on party lists. The breakdown, according to their calculations, is as follows: United Russia will receive 20 mandates, Rodina and the Party of Life will receive 9 mandates, SPS will receive 7, and Yabloko will receive 5. If so, the opposition can strengthen its influence in the Legislative Assembly, which today is very small.
Among the features of proportional elections, political scientists highlight not only the increasing role of parties, but also the intensification of intra-party competition, especially in United Russia. In their opinion, during the elections United Russia candidates will strive to lower the ratings of their colleagues running as part of other territorial groups.
The essence of the matter is that everyone who did not make it into the top three then lines up for the mandates assigned to the party, depending on the percentage that the party gained in the corresponding territory. This means that we must strive to both “raise” ourselves and “lower” others in order to find ourselves at the beginning and not at the end of the queue...
Well, Bianchi and Seravin consider the election results themselves to depend mostly on the personalities of the candidates rather than on party labels. Whose candidates are more popular will gain more percentages.
Not everyone agrees with the above conclusions and forecasts. Deputy Alexey Kovalev, for example, believes that the results of the 2002 elections, which were held in single-mandate constituencies, cannot, in principle, be taken as a basis for analyzing the 2007 elections. He predicts the future composition of the Legislative Assembly to consist of 4-5 parties: United Russia, the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, United Democrats, the Party of Life and, possibly, the Liberal Democratic Party. As for Rodina, in his opinion, this party (judging by the fact that it has now been removed from the electoral lists in the overwhelming majority of regional elections) will not even be on the ballot.
Another deputy, Vyacheslav Makarov from United Russia, believes that all factions currently represented in the Assembly, including Rodina, have a chance to get into the next Legislative Assembly by overcoming the 7 percent barrier. United Russia member Makarov considers the prospects of his own party to be very encouraging, and if Valentina Matvienko also agrees to head the EdRa list, then everything will be just wonderful: “such an outstanding politician will undoubtedly help us raise our rating.”
However, according to some political scientists, the voters themselves should not be discounted. It is possible that, as the housing and communal services reform and other “fateful” government initiatives unfold, the level of citizen dissatisfaction may increase so much that it will overturn all the ratings of the “party in power.”
But still, no matter what logic we follow, making forecasts, as we know, is a thankless task. And not only because it is impossible to predict what the mood of citizens will be in 2007. But because the 2007 elections are likely to be unfree and unequal - even more so than the 2002-2003 elections. And their results will be determined not so much by the popularity of candidates in certain party lists, but by the level of “administrative resources” and the degree of monopolization of the main channels of information that reaches voters.

Boris VISHNEVSKY