Another high-profile scandal is brewing in the long-suffering 41st electoral district of St. Petersburg, where by-elections to the city Legislative Assembly took place on September 21. According to the voting results, Colonel Vyacheslav Makarov, a teacher at the Mozhaisky Military Space Academy, won in the district. However, now his competitors in the election fight are announcing that they intend to seek a review of the voting results through the court, since during the preparation period and on election day, numerous violations were allegedly committed at those polling stations where the “Makarov” Mozhaisk cadets voted. The piquancy of the situation lies in the fact that not so long ago Makarov himself demanded the same thing and under the same pretext, accusing the winner of the December 2002 elections, Yuri Rydnik, of violations, who as a result was deprived of his deputy mandate. It is possible that now a similar fate may befall the current winner of the election race...

Will the “hand of Moscow” help Vyacheslav Makarov?
The 41st district in the Petrograd region has long earned a reputation as unreliable. The story of his misadventures began almost two years ago, when the district was represented in the Legislative Assembly by the owner of the Hollywood Nights club, Sergei Shevchenko. In November 2001, the Kuibyshevsky District Court sentenced deputy Shevchenko to seven and a half years probation, finding him guilty of extortion. In February 2002, the city court upheld the decision of the district court, and Sergei Shevchenko was forced to resign as deputy. Thus, for the first time, the district was left without its own deputy.
An equally dramatic fate befell the next deputy from the 41st district - President of BaltONEXIMBANK Yuri Rydnik, elected on December 8, 2002. The election results in the district were disputed by rivals who lost to Rydnik - the chairman of the St. Petersburg Chamber of Control and Accounts, Dmitry Burenin and Colonel Vyacheslav Makarov. At the end of February of this year, the City Court recognized that violations of election legislation by Rydnik during the election campaign did indeed occur, and the election results in the district were canceled. The Supreme Court upheld the City Court's decision. And at the end of March, now Yuri Rydnik was forced to resign as a deputy. So the 41st district was again an orphan.
Now this scenario seems to be playing out again.
They started talking about violations even before the elections. One of the candidates in the 41st district, also an officer Igor Portalenko, even filed a lawsuit to cancel the registration of Vyacheslav Makarov, because, in his opinion, he, using his official position, attracted cadets to participate in the election campaign, while they were supposed to be studying. However, the court did not make any decision and the process was suspended. According to the plaintiff, this happened due to opposition from the leadership of the Mozhaisky Academy, headed by Lieutenant General Alexei Kovalev. “The Academy simply ignores the court’s requests,” explained Igor Portalenko. Nadezhda Egorova, another candidate in the 41st district, agreed with this assessment. “In addition to using administrative resources and attracting cadets to his campaign,” she said, “Makarov also uses the resources of senior officials, universally declaring that Valentina Matvienko and Vladimir Putin strongly support his endeavors.”
It must be said that this statement did not arise out of nowhere. This is not the first time municipal deputy Vyacheslav Makarov has taken part in campaigns for elections to the Legislative Assembly, or rather, the third time. He had previously tried to enlist the support of certain influential political forces. On the eve of the elections in December last year, many walls and fences on Petrogradskaya were decorated with exotic leaflets, from which it followed that Vyacheslav Makarov was supported by almost all political parties at once: United Russia, the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, SPS and Yabloko, and for the representatives of some of the said parties themselves, this, as it turned out, turned out to be a surprise. This time, Vyacheslav Makarov, it seems, decided to make a win-win bet - and was one of the first to join Valentina Matvienko’s support group. Which in itself, of course, is not reprehensible. If only it didn’t look like a desire to make some political capital out of this...
The situation worsened after the elections. At first, the district election commission, due to violations on election day, even invalidated the voting results in two of the four “cadet” polling stations in the 41st district, which caused a delay in registering Vyacheslav Makarov as the winner. Note that Vyacheslav Makarov was ahead of his closest rival Natalya Garkavenko with a difference of only about 200 votes, which makes the situation especially acute.
But not only Natalya Garkavenko, but also Vyacheslav Makarov’s other closest rivals, who took third and fourth place according to the voting results, respectively, spoke about violations in the “cadet” areas: Dmitry Razumov and Alexander Pirozhenko. Moreover, all the listed gentlemen adhere to completely different political views and are not noticed in mutual sympathies, however, the results of the cadet voting are assessed almost identically. Natalya Garkavenko and Alexander Pirozhenko told Novaya Gazeta that those cadets who should not vote at all in the 41st district were brought to the polling stations; that the lists of voting cadets were not certified by stamps, as required by law, and the general who rushed in urgently stamped the lists right at the station; they said that the cadets, whom the officers led in formation to the ballot boxes, blocked the work of the observers... In a word, in their opinion, the impression was that the cadets were mobilized by the leadership of Mozhaika in order to ensure the victory of their “candidate No. 1” by any means...
As a result, Natalya Garkavenko filed a lawsuit with the City Court to invalidate the voting results in the “cadet” precincts, while simultaneously appealing to the City Prosecutor’s Office with a complaint about the unlawful actions of the leadership of the Mozhaisky Academy. Alexander Pirozhenko may also take some part in this in terms of providing evidence of violations at the 53rd and 55th precincts of the 41st district. Dmitry Razumov is also very determined, and will probably demand that the voting results be invalidated. Plus the already existing claim of Igor Portalenko, whose claims are supported by Nadezhda Egorova...
In short, if these claims are supported by evidence,
The 41st district again risks being left without a deputy.
Nikolay DONSKOV
photo INTERPRESS