Novaya's columnist Boris Vishnevsky talks about why the dictatorship doesn't know how to deal with crises
medical workers have died in St. Petersburg and the Leningrad region since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic (*according to the “Memory List”)
The entire metro network will be divided into three rings - three zones (central, industrial and sleeping, the most remote), and you will have to pay depending on how many zones the passenger passes through. Representatives of the State Unitary Enterprise “Petersburg Metro” assure that this is being done solely for the convenience of citizens: they say, the new system will make it possible to more accurately calculate passenger flows and make passenger trips more comfortable. It seems that they are lying: with the system they propose, we will either have to pay more for travel on the usual routes, or limit the number of trips.
In 2012, the metro plans to introduce a new payment system based on the so-called zoning
The underground octopus will grow great. But will this make life easier for its “parasites” - passengers?
Kilometer rubles The discussion of the metro proposals took place at a meeting of the specialized commission of the Legislative Assembly on the transport complex, which was chaired by its chairman Igor Rimmer.
“They always treat authorities with suspicion,” he noted, “because they are used to expecting bad things.” Let's try to explain to us that in fact everything will be fine. Or, on the contrary, we will be convinced that everything will be bad.
The deputy head of the metro for economics and finance, Irina Vorobyova, began to convince that “everything will be fine,” with a statement that the demand for metro services exceeds supply. It became clear that the situation was leading to an increase in prices for services that were in such short supply. But no, “this is not about raising tariffs, but about managing passenger flows, which we want to regulate using economic methods,” Vorobyova said. After which she began to argue that the metro, knowing which station the passenger entered at (if he uses an electronic card), does not have information about where he got off, what is in the “limited elements” (transfer hubs, lobbies and etc.) more accurate information is needed and that “transport work is measured not in passengers, but in time and kilometers.”
The metro proposes to measure its work in “space” and not in time (it would be possible to limit the stay in the subway of a passenger who has paid a certain amount, for example, to forty minutes), so that, as Vorobyova says, “not to strain a person in the subway, forcing him to run " And he proposes to introduce a system of “concentric rings”, dividing his network into three zones.
Think about where you work! On the edge of the central ring (for now this is an indicative diagram) the stations “Gorkovskaya”, “Lenin Square”, “Alexander Nevsky Square”, “Obvodny Kanal”, “Technological Institute” and the planned “Teatralnaya” station will be located - they will limit the first zone. The second zone will be limited by the stations “Primorskaya”, “Komendantsky Prospekt”, “Udelnaya”, “Akademicheskaya”, the planned “Ruchi” and “Ul. Communes", "St. Dybenko", "Lomonosovskaya", "Prospect. Glory" (also planned), "Victory Park" and "Avtovo". Next is the third zone, which will start from the stations “Ozerki”, “Grazhdanskaya”, “Narodnaya”, “Proletarskaya”, “Dunaysky Prospekt”, “Moskovskaya” and “Leninsky Prospekt”.
The principle of “transport work,” according to Irina Vorobyova, is simple: “Those who travel more must pay more.” The travel distance (number of zones crossed) will be kept track of and the toll will be charged based on this. At the same time, the metro offers a new approach based on an electronic wallet system. Put money in this “wallet” and drive until it runs out: Irina Vorobyova considers the fact that a person “decides for himself how much money to put in” to be an extremely great achievement.
She also notes that an extensive and flexible system of discounts will be developed: “weekend”, “off-peak time” (to encourage passengers to travel during non-busy hours), and so on. However, these discounts will not apply to the first zone (which will be the most expensive based on the cost of one kilometer of travel). All discounts will be summed up (how exactly this will happen is still completely unclear), and passengers will choose for themselves how to travel and at what time. Moreover, according to Ms. Vorobyova, the system they proposed will encourage people to “think about where to get a job” - so that it would be cheaper to travel by metro. (Otherwise today they don’t think about it, you understand: they live in Kupchino, but they dare to work on Grazhdanka - and they travel across the whole city, paying the same as those who commute to work from “Primorskaya” to “Gostiny Dvor”!) She also promises to maintain social discounts for students, schoolchildren, pensioners, and so on. Finally, unified travel tickets will remain - you can travel with them in all zones.
Money in advance But how will the metro ensure that a person entering the subway does not travel more than he paid for? Maybe they will introduce a system like in trains, where it is impossible to get off at the station if you do not have a ticket, or if you have traveled further than you paid for?
Vorobyova reassures us: the metro does not plan to introduce such a closed system, with turnstiles at the entrance and exit. But, as it turns out, not out of the goodness of my heart, but only because some stations are located in buildings that are historical and cultural monuments, and it is difficult to install turnstiles in their exit lobbies. Therefore, a “semi-closed system” is proposed, where turnstiles will be located at the entrance, and only where possible - at the exit. At the same time, upon entering the metro, we will immediately pay for a trip of the maximum length - through all three zones. At the exit there will be a validator, which, after checking the smart card, if the passenger has traveled less, will return the extra money to his electronic wallet.
The system of tokens, which will allow you to travel throughout the metro without restrictions, will also be preserved, says Vorobyova. But don’t rush to rejoice, citizens, the metro has already taken care of you. The token will cost exactly as much as a trip through all three zones, that is, the maximum. And at the same time, unlike a smart card, if a passenger travels only one or two zones, no money will be returned to him...
They will count later As it turns out, the metro has been developing the new system for about two years and discussing it with specialists from the Committee on Transport and CERPiT. “This is not the periodic table, you won’t dream about it at night,” said Igor Vybornov, deputy head of the metro. All this will cost about 250 million rubles - which, as the metro believes, will pay off in 6-7 years “due to the fact that people will use the cash registers less” and due to “cheaper cards.” When asked by trade union representative Lyudmila Ryabkina whether it would be better to use this money for other purposes - for example, to improve passenger service - there was no answer, nor were there any specific economic calculations or clear figures.
It was in vain that Igor Rimmer called on the metro to “play open cards with the citizens” and stated that he needed to know “how this will affect the wallets of voters”: the cards were never opened. And Irina Vorobyova never answered the most interesting question - how much will we end up paying for metro travel? They say that tariffs will be considered only at the end of 2011, when the city budget for 2012 will be approved and “taking into account specific factors.” And in general, tariffs are set by the city government, not the metro, and besides, they are very lenient. “The Metro is the cheapest type of public transport,” assures Vorobyova. “On average, a passenger travels 13 kilometers in the metro, and at a fare of 22 rubles, that’s less than two rubles per kilometer.”
In addition, she noted that “their system did not have the goal of increasing tariffs”: since the city compensates them for all lost income, they could transport passengers for free - from an economic point of view, this makes no difference to them. But passengers will begin to storm the stations, trying to get free services...
Let's fade away A representative of the Transport Committee, Maxim Glazkov, said that two tasks are being set: “to bring the volume of services and payment into line” and “to regulate passenger flows using economic levers, which was not the case before.” Well, yes: the more expensive the fare, the lower the passenger flow, we know this even without Glazkov. He also noted that “theoretically, it is possible to introduce a zone system in ground transport” if it becomes clear that this “will be beneficial in the metro.” There is no doubt that the new system will be useful for the metro, so the prospects for similar innovations in buses, trolleybuses and trams are becoming obvious.
Something else raises doubts: why should the fare depend so much on the distance? Why is it not offered, following the European model, a ticket that is valid for all types of public transport? Why does the metro create more and more inconvenience for passengers - from limiting the number of trips on single travel tickets and installing turnstiles that resemble anti-tank hedgehogs to the permanent repair of old escalators and the purchase of clearly defective new escalators, which soon fail (as at the " Sadovaya - Spasskaya - Sennaya)?
Alas: there are no answers. Instead, we are offered a completely free choice: either pay more or travel less. Better yet, look for a job closer to home so as not to overload the metro. After all, all his problems are because there are too many of us. There should be fewer of us...
Boris VISHNEVSKY