Dmitry Medvedev contributed grain to the G8 summit
Dmitry Medvedev proposes that world leaders create a new mechanism for regulating international relations in the energy sector to replace the dysfunctional Energy Charter, organize a regime of constant consultations between the ministers of agriculture of the G8 countries and hold a “grain summit” to find solutions to stabilize the grain market. These, apparently, are the main initiatives that the Russian president put forward at the G8 summit in Toyako .
Yesterday was, in fact, the summit when the heads of state discussed the planned agenda. Yesterday evening, the final statement of the heads of the G8 was published, dedicated to the state of the global economy, climate change and assistance to Africa. Today, club members will hold their last meeting in an expanded format (with the participation of the heads of the largest developing economies), some will give press conferences (including Dmitry Medvedev) and begin to leave the island of Hokkaido.
Discussions between the G8 leaders are held behind closed doors, so details can only be learned from the heads of state themselves or their closest aides. Dmitry Medvedev, who did not speak to the press on Monday, met with reporters yesterday during a break between meetings and spoke about the discussion of the G8 leaders and his participation in it. He said the discussions focused on the financial crisis, the food crisis and energy security issues.
Regarding food, the leaders, according to Medvedev, discussed methods for solving problems: “We agreed that special funds would be created, and targeted assistance would be provided to the most affected states. But at the same time, we need to think about how to rationalize this system.” Russia has practical considerations in this regard. Mr. Medvedev said that he made proposals to hold regular meetings of the ministers of agriculture of the G8 states, as well as to hold a special “grain summit” where “the reasons for rising grain prices and possible ways to stabilize the situation in this area would be discussed.” . These proposals of the Russian President received full support.
There are new ideas in the area of ensuring global energy security, although one can hardly count on unconditional approval here. “The task is to link the interests of producing countries, consuming countries and transit states,” Dmitry Medvedev explained the very meaning of the discussion. And he specified: “There is probably a need to think about preparing some new international decisions on this topic, some new international agreements. In any case, today it is obvious to us that a number of international conventions, such as the Energy Charter, do not work or work unproductively. There is reason to talk about consolidating these efforts in a new way.”
As you know, it’s not only Moscow that doesn’t like the Energy Charter . For example, Norway, like Russia, has signed but not ratified the legally binding Charter Treaty (ECT ). And the United States and a number of other countries signed the charter, but did not sign the ECT. Each specific case has its own reasons, but in the end, as Mr. Medvedev emphasized, the document does not work. At the same time, the idea of replacing the charter with a new, more effective instrument is still too extravagant for world leaders. In any case, this idea was not reflected in the final communiqué of the summit. It only talks about the relevance of all the G8 decisions in St. Petersburg, and also proposes to convene “an energy forum that will focus on energy efficiency issues and new technologies.” The latest initiative comes from France. As is known, Paris has already put forward a similar idea during its presidency of the European Union, but the proposal to hold a special G8 forum became news. A member of the Russian delegation, representative of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Alexander Pankin spoke about this yesterday. According to him, “the nearest dialogue on the problems of production and consumption of energy resources may take place in the UK in the fall of this year.”
Regarding international finance, as Dmitry Medvedev said on the eve of the summit, both Russia and other countries, in particular the UK, have proposals. British Prime Minister Gordon Brown also announced the idea of giving the World Bank some of the functions of an “energy bank.” Yesterday Dmitry Medvedev explained: “We must first of all think about what the architecture of international economic relations will look like. What exists today no longer suits almost anyone. We need to think about how to shape this architecture for the future. We, in turn, have repeatedly said that countries that belong to the G8, and other states as well, should move away from purely national approaches; we should not think like economic egoists (what I said at the St. Petersburg Forum , and I repeated this phrase today): we must think about building global economic security. This includes measures to create new financial and economic institutions, bringing the goals and methods of work of existing institutions into line with the realities of the day.”
However, the final communiqué does not contain any revolutionary ideas of this kind. Apparently, the G8 leaders have a general agreement only in terms of dissatisfaction with the current situation, but there is no common understanding of what needs to be changed.
Vremya Novostey's source in the Russian delegation yesterday found it difficult to answer the question whether the proposals made by Mr. Medvedev are exhausted by those he told the press about. Although, perhaps, this is more than enough for the first participation in the G8 summit. In any case, Dmitry Medvedev himself yesterday looked confident and quite satisfied with the progress of the negotiations at Toyako. The successful premiere of the Russian president is one of the important results of the summit.
Among other results, it should be noted that the G8 recorded a political compromise on the problem of climate change, confirming the desire to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions by 50% compared to 1990 levels by 2050. The compromise is that the G8 countries are not declaring new commitments to reduce emissions, hoping to involve a wider range of countries in the new international agreement that will replace the Kyoto Protocol in 2012. “The solution to this global problem can only be achieved through joint efforts, in particular the contribution of all leading economies, in accordance with the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and taking into account available opportunities,” says the communiqué on ecology and climate change. Today, during discussions with representatives of these economies (Australia, Brazil, India, Indonesia, China, Mexico, Korea and South Africa), the G8 will try to convince them of the need to “take an active part in developing an effective framework document for the period after 2012.” The issue of the financial obligations of the G8 itself, which was the subject of controversy on the eve of the summit, is reflected in the communiqué quite diplomatically. The document notes that “to date” the club member countries have agreed to contribute approximately $6 billion to the climate investment funds created under the auspices of the World Bank (this amount, as is known, will be made up of contributions from only three countries - Japan, the USA and the UK ). Russia, we recall, expressed doubts about the advisability of new contributions, proposing first to determine how these funds would differ from already existing financial mechanisms. The communiqué adopted yesterday directly states that the new funds will “supplement” them.
The topic of the Southern Kuril Islands accompanied the entire lengthy preparation for the summit in Hokkaido - the Japanese authorities seriously intensified the corresponding propaganda, and it is now unrealistic to find in Japan a map where the islands would belong to Russia. Yesterday, the topic of bilateral relations between Moscow and Tokyo finally reached the level at which only it can be effectively discussed - negotiations between Dmitry Medvedev and the host of the G8 summit, Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda. Following their results, the press secretary of the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Kazuo Kodama, told reporters that the heads of state noted: deepening the coordination and cooperation of Russia and Japan in the Asia-Pacific region is necessary for stability and prosperity in the region, and the absence of a peace treaty between strategic partners, which are the two countries, is not benefits them, and this situation must be corrected as soon as possible. As one would expect, Russian sources commented on this meeting much more restrainedly, focusing on the important and stabilizing role of cooperation between the two countries in the Asian region. Still, the Russian-Japanese peace treaty is not as simple as restructuring the global financial architecture or fighting the global food crisis.