The case of the pioneer of domestic cooperation is closed
The Prosecutor General's Office dropped the criminal case against Viktor Naishuller, a man who was once one of the twenty richest people in Russia. He was accused of fraud with $4 million that belonged to the Kirovo-Chepetsk Chemical Plant (KCHP), and the businessman served more than a year in a pre-trial detention center. Now investigators have agreed that the oligarch is not guilty of that story.
Back in the mid-80s, Viktor Naishuller created one of the first cooperatives in the USSR called “Balchug”. Later it turned into a diversified holding that united more than 200 different enterprises, including Balchug Bank, the Office Club chain of stores, the international company Balchug Development, etc. And in 1994, the latter structure entered into a deal, which then attracted the attention of investigators.
Then KChHP received a $5 million loan from the state to upgrade equipment and purchase an expensive unit for the production of ammonia. The equipment supplier under the contract was to be Balchug-Development. Soon the company received $5 million, but, according to the case file, did not send the installation to the plant. Later, however, Balchug returned part of the money to KCHHP for the failed deal, but it amounted to only 20% of the contract amount.
The prosecutor's office of the Kirov region (on whose territory the plant is located) opened a criminal case, and for three years it was investigated rather sluggishly. And in April 2001, Mr. Naishuller was unexpectedly arrested in Moscow and sent to the Kirov pre-trial detention center. The businessman’s lawyers managed to get his case to be taken over by the Prosecutor General’s Office, and following the investigation materials, the businessman himself was escorted to Moscow. Mr. Naishuller spent more than a year behind bars, but was interrogated only once during this period. In May 2001, the ex-oligarch was released on his own recognizance, was periodically summoned for questioning, and the Prosecutor General’s Office constantly extended the investigation period in his case. As Mr. Naishuller’s defenders argued, they generally did not understand the essence of the claims against their client. He himself never personally managed the Balchug-Development company; it was just part of his holding, like several hundred other structures. And there were no signatures of Mr. Naishuller in the agreement with KCHHP. In the end, representatives of the Prosecutor General’s Office recently agreed with these arguments and decided that there was no evidence of the businessman’s involvement in the loss of factory money.