| The widow of a man who died on the operating table demands a million rubles for the doctors' blunder Yesterday, in the court of the Moscow region city of Khimki, a trial began on the claim of a woman accusing surgeons of the Khimki Central Medical and Sanitary Unit No. 119 (KB TsMSCh) of neglect of their duties, which is why her husband died on the operating table. She demands to pay 1 million rubles. as compensation for moral damage caused to her. Evgeniy Zakharov, who died during the operation, was given an incorrect diagnosis; in addition, he was transfused with the wrong blood. The hospital lawyer shrugs his shoulders in bewilderment - in his opinion, there is nothing unusual in this case.
In December 1997, 60-year-old Evgeniy Zakharov decided to undergo examination at the Central Medical Hospital on the recommendation of his attending physician, who diagnosed him with prostatic hyperplasia. “Before he left for the hospital, he joked all the time, he was so cheerful and cheerful. And then, like a bolt from the blue, this call from the hospital,” says widow Larisa Markovna. Hospital staff reported that Zakharov was diagnosed with “clear cell carcinoma of the left kidney and a giant parapelvic cyst of the right kidney.” By decision of the doctors, an operation was performed, during which the patient died. At the same time, the doctors did not bother themselves to obtain written consent for surgical intervention from either the patient himself or his relatives, although in accordance with the basic legislation of the Russian Federation on protecting the health of citizens, such consent must be obtained. Zakharov's wife Larisa is a general practitioner by training. The assurances of surgeons Boris Voskresensky and Oleg Troitsky that they had done everything possible to save the patient’s life immediately seemed suspicious to her. “During the operation, my husband’s left kidney was removed, where a cancerous tumor was allegedly discovered, and then he started bleeding. Only then did the doctors realize that my husband’s remaining kidney was not functioning at all,” explained Larisa Markovna. Evgeniy Zakharov urgently received a blood transfusion. They did not take into account only one thing - the patient’s blood group was the first with a negative Rh factor, and they transfused him with blood with a positive Rh factor. The incompatibility of these two Rhesus factors led to the instant death of the patient. “During the autopsy, the pathologist began to cut the severed kidney in layers and at first he was scared to death when he saw that it was healthy. Only in the very middle of it did he actually discover a small malignant tumor. If the diagnosis had been carried out properly, then we could have been confronted with the question of implanting an artificial kidney, but the doctors did nothing of the kind,” the Zakharovs’ son Sergei shared with a Vremya Novostei correspondent.
The relatives of the deceased could not come to terms with the fact that their husband and father had become a victim of a medical error, and turned to the Prosecutor General's Office for help. A forensic examination was carried out, and two years later, in January 1999, a case was opened under Art. 109 of the Criminal Code (causing death by negligence). Six months later, the case against the surgeon Troitsky was closed under an amnesty. Larisa Zakharova managed to get another criminal case initiated based on newly discovered circumstances (due to improper blood transfusion). But a new examination did not find any violations in the actions of the hospital employees, and the case was closed for lack of evidence of a crime. But Larisa Zakharova does not give up, demanding compensation for moral damages in civil proceedings.
“The illegal actions of the doctors, which resulted in the premature death of my trustee’s husband, caused her physical and moral suffering, which was expressed in the deterioration of her health, insomnia, and mental and moral distress. Therefore, the amount of compensation for moral damage we are requesting is completely justified,” says lawyer Petr Dombrovitsky.
“Zakharov actually died in December 1997 during an operation. But all the doctors’ actions were in accordance with medical science and practice. The operation was preceded by careful preparation, and the doctors fought for the life of their patient to the last. The examination showed that the patient died not because of a medical error, but because of a pathology of the right kidney. Therefore, the hospital is not at fault,” says the defense to the claim by the lawyer representing the interests of the hospital. At the same time, the defender, who did not want to introduce himself to journalists, is very surprised by such close attention of the press to the process. “This is an ordinary, unremarkable case, dozens of such cases are heard every day in Moscow courts, and there are hundreds and thousands of them across Russia,” he told Vremya Novostey. Ekaterina BUTORINA |
|