| Russian ministries cannot distribute compensation to relatives of passengers of the downed Tu-154 Relatives of the passengers of the Tu-154 plane, shot down by Ukrainian air defense over the Black Sea on October 4, 2001, issued an open letter to Vladimir Putin and Mikhail Fradkov. The Russians have still not received the compensation awarded by the Ukrainian government, unlike the relatives of Israeli citizens who flew on that tragic flight.
As Boris Kalinovsky, chairman of the Fund for Assistance to Relatives of Passengers, told Vremya Novostei, the authors of the letter are complaining about Russian ministries. Although Ukraine has already allocated compensation, Russian officials cannot decide which of them should receive the money and distribute it among relatives. “The Ministry of Health and Social Development says it has not dealt with this issue and points to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs, in turn, says: if it comes to money, then the Ministry of Finance should deal with it. And the Ministry of Finance claims that the Ministry of Health and Social Development should deal with compensation issues,” the letter says.
Let us recall that Ukraine awarded compensation totaling $15.6 million—$200,000 for each of the 66 passengers and 12 crew members. This money is divided equally among all first-degree relatives - parents and children of the deceased, regardless of the citizenship of the deceased (remember, among them there were four Israeli citizens and 36 people with dual citizenship). The Israelis received their part of the compensation back in January.
The lawyer for the relatives of the dead passengers, Sergei Araslanov, says that at first the process of recognizing Ukraine’s guilt and paying compensation was delayed by the Ukrainian side. Last fall, the compensation agreement was signed by Ukraine, but in Russia the Duma and the government that were supposed to ratify it had just changed. Therefore, Russia ratified the agreement only this spring. But, for reasons that are not clear to the victims, Russian ministries still cannot decide through whom the money should go.
Pavel Kapchits, one of the relatives, believes that the whole point is the reluctance of officials to take responsibility: “This is a very complex issue, there are about a hundred relatives, and officials do not want to get involved with them. True, the condition for ratification of the treaty by Ukraine was a written refusal of further material claims, but the ministries are afraid of a possible scandal and lawsuits from those dissatisfied with the amount of compensation.” In addition, as Mr. Kapchits emphasizes, the end of the story has not yet been set - the victims are demanding the completion of the criminal case and the punishment of the perpetrators, and are even thinking about organizing a private investigation of the incident. After all, the version that the plane would have been shot down by a missile is still not recognized as official by Ukraine.
However, most likely the main reason for the ministerial confusion is that Russia still does not have a mechanism for receiving compensation. Boris Kalinovsky believes that it will also be difficult for the victims of the recent double terrorist attack against Tu-134 and Tu-154 planes that took off from Domodedovo airport to receive compensation. “If Russia had a well-functioning mechanism for paying compensation and the perpetrators bore serious financial responsibility, as in the United States, perhaps they would do everything in their power to prevent such situations from reoccurring. Perhaps planes would crash less often. Since officials, airlines and airports have no moral responsibility, we need to make them financially responsible,” says Mr. Kalinovsky. Dmitry VINOGRADOV, Novosibirsk |
|