| Reducing VAT will lead to a decrease in the stabilization fund Today the Ministry of Finance is expected to present final proposals for the formation of a stabilization fund, which since 2005 should replace the financial reserve. However, it is already clear that the final version of the concept will differ significantly from the original one, published by the ministry in mid-February. The fact is that the Ministry of Finance proposes to increase the base price of oil from 18.5 to 20 dollars per barrel, above which revenues from the oil industry will be directed to the stabilization fund. This was stated last Friday by Deputy Prime Minister and Head of the Ministry of Finance Alexei Kudrin. This base price, he said, will exist at least in 2004 and 2005.
Thus, the “safety cushion”, which should save the country in the future, given unfavorable world oil prices for Russia, is significantly deflated. The initial version of the stabilization fund concept assumed the accumulation of approximately 1.1 trillion rubles, or 8.7% of GDP. This should have been enough to fully fulfill budget obligations for three years at an oil price of no more than $12 per barrel. According to the Ministry of Finance's calculations, such a stabilization fund could be accumulated in four years at a cut-off price of $18.5 per barrel. Now, when the threshold level is increased to $20 per barrel, you can forget about this. Now Mr. Kudrin’s subordinates must decide: either save much longer, or the stabilization fund will be significantly smaller than originally expected. Most likely the second option will be implemented. Many economists criticized the Ministry of Finance, considering it almost impossible for the price of oil to not rise above $12 per barrel for three years in a row.
Meanwhile, it was not such considerations that forced the Ministry of Finance to change the mechanism for forming the stabilization fund. As follows from the words of Alexei Kudrin, the stabilization fund became a victim of “accelerated tax reform in 2004.” According to him, an increase in the base price of oil is necessary to maintain non-interest expenses of the federal budget in real terms at this year's level (their expected increase of 170 billion rubles in 2004 is eaten up by inflation. - Ed. ).
The fact is that changes to the tax system planned for next year, for example a reduction in the VAT rate by 2%, will wash out more than 100 billion rubles from the federal budget.
However, according to a number of analysts, Mr. Kudrin was forced to “optimize” the stabilization fund not only by the desire to maintain non-interest expenses at the current level, but also by the very real threat of their growth. This is due to the upcoming elections, on the eve of which deputies, who will adopt the budget in the fall, are known to become especially generous. A little over a week ago, the country's chief financier acknowledged the threat. In a conversation with reporters, he said that the Ministry of Finance and the government may well be under pressure to increase non-interest budget expenditures. And then, by the way, Mr. Kudrin first spoke, albeit in very cautious tones, about $20 per barrel as the base price for forming a stabilization fund. It turns out that already in mid-April the Ministry of Finance realized the impossibility of forming a balanced budget for 2004 based on an oil price of $18.5 per barrel, while this year’s budget was calculated on the basis of a price that was $3 higher.
However, the country is unlikely to need funds from the stabilization fund in the coming years. According to the forecasts of the Ministry of Finance, next year the average annual price for Russian oil is planned to be $22 per barrel, and in 2005 - $22.5. However, speaking on Friday in the State Duma, the head of Mifina admitted that it is impossible to accurately predict the price of oil almost impossible. Thus, the IMF has already repeatedly revised its original forecast for 2004. “If someone guesses this price, the Ministry of Finance will pay him a bonus for it,” the Deputy Prime Minister promised.
The Ministry of Finance increased the forecast for the federal budget surplus in 2003 from 0.6 to 1.4% of GDP. This is stated in the ministry's materials for the government meeting on April 29, at which the three-year financial plan will be considered. The GDP forecast for 2003 has also been improved - to 13.1 trillion rubles. from the 13.05 trillion rubles envisaged in the budget law. As Alexey Kudrin reported, the federal budget surplus in 2004 is planned at 0.6% of GDP, in 2005 - 0.9% of GDP. Non-interest expenditures of the federal budget in 2004 are planned at the level of 12.4% of GDP. According to Mr. Kudrin, in 2005, even greater containment of non-interest spending, which is planned at 11.9% of GDP, will be required. Only with this level of spending in 2005 will we be able to reduce the effective UST rate by no less than 5%, the Deputy Prime Minister said. Mikhail VOROBYEV |
|