Tchaikovsky and Brahms from RNO and Alexander Lazarev
The Russian National Orchestra closed its Moscow season by inviting one of the most powerful Russian conductors, Alexander Lazarev, to conduct the final chord. Several years ago, Lazarev stood at the podium of the Pletnev orchestra for the first time, and this was not only the conductor’s first performance in Moscow after a long break, but also a phenomenal musical event, which many remember in detail and are not going to forget. The program then included Medtner's piano concerto (with Boris Berezovsky) and Rachmaninoff's "Symphonic Dances".
Lazarev built the current program in a conceptual spirit: the concert consisted of two Second Symphonies - Tchaikovsky and Brahms, very close in time of writing, but distant in thought and language. While rehearsing, the conductor told the musicians about the details of the relationship between Tchaikovsky and Brahms (they did not like each other), and that the audience should hear the difference in the development of Russian and Western European symphonic music. Explaining some details of the performance, he recalled the story of how Rostropovich and Shostakovich were driving a car, and then they ran out of gas. It was necessary to open a spare canister, but the key to it was lost. Rostropovich tried to knock down the castle with reinforcement. Shostakovich commented: “What a German does, a Russian will destroy! It will destroy!
Among musicians, Lazarev, who has already conducted several Moscow orchestras over the past couple of seasons, is famous for his rehearsal skills - intensity of work, humor, mastery of time, accuracy of explanations and ability to quickly convey his knowledge and understanding of music to the musicians.
Meanwhile, in the curious duel of the Second symphonies of Tchaikovsky and Brahms (let us note right away, it was a duel of “happy” ones; if Lazarev had chosen other symphonies, we would have had to compare the degree of suffering), by chance, another “third Second” intervened, namely Brahms’ Second, played in Saturday by the Bavarian Radio Orchestra and Maris Jansons. So all the liveliness and virtuosity of writing in Tchaikovsky’s Second was compared in the public’s perception with Brahms’s plasticity and sophistication. But the last one is also with herself, but in a different performance.
Lazarev himself appeared as the antipode of the “Bavarian” Jansons - the interpretations of both symphonies shone with bright, open emotionality, and the rapid tempos corresponded to the living life in the scores. Tchaikovsky, played orchestrally flawlessly, at the same time came out as a slightly straightforward, enthusiastic and somewhat naive author. The audience rushed to applaud after each movement (they sounded with such unrestrained fire), but the conductor, it seemed, had nothing against it, only with a gesture directed the applause to the musicians who masterfully coped with their task. In general, Lazarev, even while conducting, often glanced into the audience, as if persistently inviting listeners to participate in the dispute he had started.
The orchestral quality of the Pletnevists in Brahms, one must admit, lost to the “Bavarian” - not in the sense of purity and harmony, but in terms of the quality of the orchestral sound itself. Also, there was less transparency, audibility of texture and details, without which subtle Brahmsian drawings tend to turn into mush, in this execution. Although the Bavarians in Brahms (with their Jansons-inspired deep calm, deeply absorbed for a long time in every phrase, every shift of form) seemed to many to be insufficiently emotional, while Lazarev and RNO just breathed and played very lively and brightly (the whole symphony simply sounded faster and even louder) , in the “Russian” version, Brahms turned out to be less of a perfectionist than he could have been. If not to say that it was played almost “in Russian” - feverishly, enthusiastically, with generous culminations and some losses in the rigor that is not necessary for this music and in the clarity that is fundamental to it. A wonderful allusion to the coordinate system in which Brahms is a representative of the central line of European symphonism, and Tchaikovsky is a stormy “outlying European”, met here with the “resistance of the material” (or the manner of reading it).
So the focus of the comparison between the two symphony schools, the audience attraction arranged by the conductor with intelligence and courage, has become a riddle that does not imply clear answers. And taking into account the Bavarian replica, there were even more options for solving the problem.