Having announced a course towards modernizing the economy and developing high technologies, the Russian authorities began inviting global companies to the country. Representatives of the most innovative industry - electronics - were also invited. They came, but adequate conditions were created only for the simplest production - assembling televisions. Already there was a slowdown for computers. Officials cite the reluctance of computer brands to compete with the “gray sector” - small assemblers of smuggled components. Experts consider this argument unfounded and blame the government for the lack of will to modernize.
Progress and circumstances
According to the Director of Public Relations of the Russian Association of Trading Companies and Manufacturers of Electrical and Computer Equipment (RATEK) Anton Guskov, “gray sector” products, which brands are afraid of, are in demand among individual buyers. Legal entities (private companies, government organizations) prefer branded computers that have well-established service (this is confirmed by Andrey Korzhakov, director of Foxconn RUS). At the same time, progress is reducing the demand for desktop computers in favor of laptops, tablets, iPads, iPhones, etc. And this trend is developing fastest in the segment of individual buyers.
Anton Guskov is confident that soon individual demand for desktop computers will decrease to 10–15% of the market volume and will remain only in the segment of legal entity buyers. At the same time, the “gray sector” will shrink. If we think about the near future, then, according to Guskov, it’s time for brands to agree to the introduction of duties on the import of computers (a necessary condition for profitable assembly): “The government must offer a solution that will make assembly profitable, but will not increase smuggling.”
Nobody wanted to strain
Most experts blame the Russian government for the fact that conditions have not yet been created for even the simplest desktop computers. “Current officials do not know how and are not interested in changing anything, and the president and prime minister do not reach out to us,” says Eduard Voronetsky, president of K-Systems Irbis. Some experts hint at the selfish interests of individual officials overseeing smuggling flows.
Deputy Director of the Department of the Ministry of Economic Development Mikhail An admits the inertia and corruption of the bureaucratic machine, but places part of the blame on electronics engineers. He thinks they are not persistent enough. They object: if the authorities want to develop the electronics industry, they must, as in the cases with televisions and cars, make a strong-willed decision to introduce duties. “There must be the will of the government to introduce duties and direct imports,” Eduard Voronetsky is sure.
Mikhail An largely agrees with this: “Importers give a number of arguments against it. They are talking about an increase in gray imports and about an unacceptable increase in computer prices for the population.” We need a strong-willed government decision, motivated by a clear industrial policy. However, she is not there.
Import or produce?
With this attitude of the government towards the modernization of the Russian economy, it will not be possible to create modern electronic production in the country, even if the assembly of desktop computers is launched. Because when assembling more complex devices (laptop computers, phones, etc.), problems with components increase like an avalanche. If for televisions and desktop computers it is enough to zero out duties on one or two main components, then for phones and laptops there are about a dozen such main (in terms of contribution to cost) components. Many of them are used in various industries. Zeroing duties will make the Russian electronic components industry uncompetitive. And this is a matter of principle.
Most electronics manufacturers - both foreign and Russian companies - have long demanded the complete abolition of duties on electronic components (among other things, this will significantly reduce smuggling). Against - Ministry of Industry and Trade. Under pressure from the military-industrial complex, the Ministry of Industry and Trade demands that domestic developers and manufacturers of microchips be protected from foreign competition (in particular, the Zelenograd Mikron plant, controlled by AFK Sistema, which, with the support of Rusnano, promises to launch the production of 90 nm chips). The main argument is that national security considerations require that military equipment be provided with purely Russian chips in order to avoid dependence on foreign manufacturers.
Pull and push
Manufacturers of electronic equipment are against “rabid” protectionism for components. Their main argument is that the latter are unable to provide even for the needs of the military. “Duties on components are demanded by military-industrial complex enterprises that supposedly produce analogues, but they do not produce anything similar, especially in terms of quality,” says Eduard Voronetsky. “Confirmation of this is the recent scandalous interview with the general designer of missiles.” Manufacturers of “civilian” electronics, especially foreign ones, are not satisfied with the quality of Russian components either. “It’s getting to the point,” says Anton Guskov, “that German companies operating in Russia are forced to import even iron for the bodies of their products.”
Nevertheless, it is necessary to develop our own component production in Russia, Guskov is sure. It is difficult to make assembly, especially contract assembly, profitable based on the import of components. This is hampered by a clumsy bureaucratic machine. This is illustrated by a curious point: the modernization of computer components in the world is happening faster than the change in product codes at Russian customs. Officials do not have time to complete the paperwork for the previous model when the next one appears. Even Intel Corporation, with all its lobbying power, cannot cope with this problem, so its processors are regularly detained by customs.
You'll have to strain
There is no easy way out. We need both import and domestic production, and support for both. For example, zero duties on components that are not produced in Russia and will not be produced in the near future. Even more important is to reduce unproductive costs, for example, those associated with customs administration, connecting factories to energy networks, etc.
A depreciation of the ruble against the dollar and euro would seriously support both component manufacturers and assemblers, but in order to do so, it is necessary to abandon the fight against inflation by overvaluing the ruble.
In addition, the effective development of modern electronic production in the country is impossible without competition with global companies. Guskov believes that the government should stimulate the entry of global component manufacturers into the country. This will solve many of the current problems. But global companies need adequate economic conditions. But there are big problems with this in Russia.
Defects in the investment climate led to the fact that, when the global crisis reduced production volumes, contract manufacturers of electronics became completely bored. Elcoteq and Flextronics closed their projects and left Russia. Between the remaining ones (Jabil, operating in the Tver region, Foxconn and TPV Technology in St. Petersburg), fierce competition developed for the only profitable segment - the assembly of televisions. However, this direction is unpromising. The main share here is occupied by developers like Samsung and LG (they are the largest), who assemble their TVs themselves. You cannot build a serious business in Russia on the contract assembly of televisions from other brands (Sony, Panasonic, Philips, etc.) - the orders are too small.
The departure of foreign companies will further slow down the development of electronic manufacturing in the country. To prevent this from happening, the government must develop an industrial policy in the field of electronic production and begin to actively implement it.
Vladimir GRYAZNEVICH