How the Roskachestvo undermines the trust in Russian manufacturers, and its leaders make money on this.
Since European products have disappeared from Russian supermarkets, the quality of domestic goods has arisen especially acutely. Finding a worthy analogue of many dairy and meat products is still difficult. The state is trying to help citizens figure out what from the "home" can be eaten, but what is not worth it, but does not always succeed in this.
Several organizations are responsible for the safety and quality of goods in Russia. The state structures of Rospotreb and Rosselkhoznadzor are engaged in everything: from the prevention of HIV to the compliance with GOST of canned meat. Four years ago, these public buildings had a competitor - Roskachestvo, who regularly publishes its ratings, insisting that they are absolutely independent. The "new" found that the company close to the leadership of the Roskatika get an advantage in the market.
The decision on the creation of the non-profit organization Russian Quality System (Roskanka) Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev signed in 2015-in the midst of sanctions wars. The composition of its founders, in addition to the Ministry of Industry and Trade, included more than a dozen associations of manufacturers and consumers. The government wanted to create a mechanism for monitoring Russian products and promoting trusted goods. Roskachestvo received the right to test almost everything, from sour cream to school uniforms, according to their own criteria and to make verdicts. “Within the framework of the program, store visitors receive information about high -quality Russian products, and goods marked with“ quality sign ”are allocated on shelves and using special stands,” the organization’s website says . If experts recognize the goods unsafe, the information will be transmitted to Rospotreb and Rosselkhoznadzor, who can start an official check.
The promotion of goods is paid by the Roskachestvo itself, and its budget is filled with subsidies of the Ministry of Industry and Trade. So, in 2015, for four years, the structure gave 893 million rubles for “organizing jobs, the purchase and creation of software products, as well as for the implementation of the main activities of a non -profit organization”. For 2019, 400 million rubles were allocated to Roskaclery.
Unlike Rosospotrebnadzor and Rosselkhoznadzor, whose certificates are required for all manufacturers, and conclusions have legal consequences, Roskachestvo ratings are advisory in nature. However, as the "new" manufacturers reported, its assessments, especially negative ones, significantly affect sales.
By the way, there is also a luxury - non -profit and non -state partnership, which also tests goods according to its own criteria, claiming objectivity. Although in the absence of the latter it is often reproached. So, in early July, Roskontrol recommended only one type of ham for use, and placed the others in the black list. A similar situation was a year ago, when the Roskomatism and Roskontrol showed the diametrically opposite results of the check of sour cream. Those brands that ended up in the top of the Roskatniki, Roskontrol placed the black list. At the same time, Roskontrol does not receive state subsidies.
Since 2015, the head of the Roskathesti has been businessman Maxim Protasov. Since the 1990s, he has been heading the P-Holding Group, which includes agro-industrial and salt companies, and since 2009 he has been managing the Association of manufacturers and suppliers of food products Rusprodsoyuz.
Maxim Protasov. Photo from the Roskathesti site
In the association there was a “high quality” unit, the tasks of which were similar to Roskanka. He was headed by Elena Sarattseva, who, together with the boss, went to work in Roskankosty and became his deputy.
Elena Sarattseva. Photo from VKontakte page
Since January 2018, Elena Sarattseva received another high position. She was appointed the acting general director of the Innovative Scientific and Production Center of Textile and Light Industry (TLP INPC), on the basis of which the Roskanka conducts its research and calls it the “main industry center in the Russian legend”. Now it is listed by the CEO of the company.
Despite the close cooperation of the Inpz and Roskachestvo, these organizations have repeatedly become competitors at public procurement. So, in 2017, both offered the maximum price of 3 million rubles in the Rosstandart competition for organizing a government award. The contract received Roskachestvo - except for him and the Inpz, there were no other applicants for the contract. Other was the outcome of the competition for the preparation of the examination for the Ministry of Industry and Trade in the same 2017. The INPC won the contract, reducing the price of one hundred thousand rubles - from 3 million to 2.9 million (3.3%). And again there were no other competitors.
The competition between friendly organizations in 2017 did not violate the law. But the purchases of 2018, when the INPC was already headed by Elena Sarattseva, could interest the federal antimonopoly service. Roskachestvo and the INPC twice participated in joint competitions for three contracts. That is, for three contracts, structures fought, in the leadership of which the same person appears.
Such a pseudo -combination is usually arranged to disqualify an extraneous participant in the competition or, if only one participant has led to the auction to avoid purchasing from a single supplier: this is a difficult procedure on which the FAS can apply a veto.
In the spring of 2018, Rosstandart, as in 2017, was looking for a contractor to hold a government prize in the field of quality. In the first competition for a contract of 5.3 million rubles, Roskachestvo and JSC “All-Russian Research Institute of Certification” (VNIIS) fought. The competitor offered his services for just 4.13 million rubles, but the winner was the Roskazstvo, which did not reduce the initial price of the contract either by the ruble. As a result, the results of the competition were canceled due to errors in the documentation of the customer-Rosstandart-and announced a new purchase with a similar lot.
In the next competition, VNIIS did not participate, and the price of the contract increased to 5.5 million. Rosk between the Certificate and the Inpz entered the fight, whose leadership includes Elena Sarattseva. The center she head made an offer to the maximum - for 5.5 million rubles, and the Roskazy, in which she is the deputy head, - by 5 million. As a result, the contract left Roskacentia.
Another competition , in which two organizations with the same superiors clashed in the summer of 2018. The Ministry of Industry and Trade announced the purchase with two lots to prepare an expert opinion on customs and tariff measures and expert support for assessing the development of light industry. The Roskasm was not allowed to participate in this competition, after which the organizer - the Ministry of Industry and Trade - rejected all applications and recognized the competition as failed. In addition to the applications of the Roskathesti and the INPC, the application of LLC Orion was rejected due to the supposedly different signatures of the head of Orion (the Ministry of Industry and Trade conducted a handwriting examination). A second competition was immediately held . Only Roskachestvo and the Inpz fought for the second lot in it (for the first lot of the Inpz competed with an extraneous company). The center of Elena Sarattseva eventually won both lots totaling 10.4 million rubles.
The "New" made a request for the Federal Antimonopoly Service on a possible cartel conspiracy. The department considered that media requests are not enough to start checking.
On the website of the “Unified Registry” “Novye”, “Novy” found that after the auction described above, in November 2018-February 2019, the FAS conducted an unscheduled test of the Roskachestvo and found that the organization violated the federal law “On Competition” three times. The site does not specify what the violations were concluded, the FAS also did not reveal the new information. “Based on the audit, the FAS gave the autonomous non -profit organization“ Russian Quality System ”a number of recommendations for further improvement of activities as the National Institute of Quality,” explained Viktor Yevtukhov, deputy minister of industry and trade. According to him, measures or sanctions were not applied based on the results of this audit.
Meanwhile, as Russian manufacturers of clothing anonymously told anonymously, Roskanka imposes on them the Inpz as an organization where it is necessary to check their own products for compliance with high standards - and, accordingly, do not fall into the black list of the Roskachestvo.
The scheme resembles blackmail, but businessmen are afraid to openly object to the structure subordinate to the Ministry of Industry and Trade.
“In understandable business logic, the development [relationships with Roskankosty] is seen in force to pay [clothing manufacturers] to pay for the rating,” says the market representative.
In 2017, the Cyprus offshore RUSSALT LIMITED published data on his beneficiaries, in which Protasov was listed as a co -owner of the company. This offshore belongs to one of the largest salt producers in Russia - LLC Russol. Protasova’s wife Lilia is 100% owned by Russol-SZ company-distributor Roussley in the north-west. In addition to saline business, Protasov also owns the Tomatoprom canning holding. Finally, we recall that the businessman is headed by the Rusprodsoyuz Association.
It was necessary to remember the assets of Maxim Protasov in order to contact the list of products marked by the branded signs of the Roskathesti, thanks to which manufacturers receive additional places of sales, preferences on store shelves and even advertising - all this due to the Federal Agency for, or rather, the subsidies that the Ministry of Industry and Trade allocates him. By the end of 2018, 239 goods were marked with quality signs.
“New” studied the list of these goods - many of them were produced by companies, one way or another affiliated both with Protasov himself and with the Rusprodsoyuz and the Roskanka controlled by him (by the way, the actual addresses of these two organizations coincide: Moscow, Ovchinnikovsky per., 12). 28 products were produced either by Maxim Protasov’s companies, or the educational companies and members of Rusprodsoyuz and Roskachestvo. This is 11.7% of the number of all those who have received a “quality mark”.
Salt of the Astrakhan Territory, salt cook iodized iodized iodized "Iletskaya", salt Gated Drill -Military "Iletskaya", salt Gated food ground SEA SALT - all these are the products of "Russol". Canned peas of "gardeners" was manufactured by Kuban Canning Combine LLC for the Tomatotrome canning holding. A dozen more products from the list were made by companies - members of the Rusprodsoyuz Association, headed by Maxim Protasov.
Roskathesti, of course, has the opportunity not only to promote some manufacturers, but also to complicate the life of others. So, in August 2018, after studying school uniforms and sattures, the organization told Rospotrebnadzor of Moscow and the media about unsatisfactory results. Rospotrebnadzor conducted his own verification on the complaint and found out that "the information of the Roskacality is misleading consumers."
Screenshot from the Roskazhery site
Representatives of the supervisory authority visited all twelve points of sales, where the Roskanka allegedly purchased clothes for verification, and found that there were simply no indicated stores at six addresses. In addition, Rospotrebnadzor also criticized the procedure for conducting an audit of the Roskachestvo.
The ambiguous procedure for checking the goods was the reason why Roskachestvo last year had to remove the material from the site that Salmonellosis was found in the chickens of the Stavropol Broiler company. The Broiler through the court recognized this information to not true: the Roskanka could not prove that the study of the products that were purchased by the Rosk between the store were received for the study for his experts.
In early June 2019, the Roskanka shocked the Russians with the results of the study of tea. The organization’s website indicates that in ten types of tea, experts found the intestinal stick and mold. The head of the Association of Tea Manufacturers and Coffee "Roschaikof" Ramaz Canturia explained to "new" that it was not customary to check tea for the presence of E. coli in international or Russian practice: like mold, it is not dangerous and killed by hot water. “These are all meaningless fried facts,” says Canturia. “Rosk between consumer fears, and the consumer ceases to believe that tea can be bought without fear.” The head of the Antonin Tsitsulin Association of Children's Products, who believes that the Roskachestvo in its publications, puts violations that is not a violation, also told about the same “new”.
“Today, the Roskanka is acting against the spirit of its constituent document -“ strategic areas of the Roskachestvo activity, ”says one of the market participants. - “directions” suggest that certification (and verification) is carried out voluntarily if the manufacturer wants to stand out from the total mass. In fact, it checks everything that comes to hand: from tea and jackets to gasoline and smartphones, not taking into account the desires of manufacturers.
Screech of the rating from the Roskathesti website
Roskachestvo has developed its standards independently, and for manufacturers they are optional. But about such subjective verification of goods that have not passed, it is still reported that they "do not comply with the standards."
“We do not see measures aimed at supporting and promoting high -quality domestic goods,” says the manufacturer. “Their goal is to scare consumers as much as possible in order to prove their need for the state and receive more subsidies: the more parameters and products they“ study ”, the more financing they can demand,” says the interlocutor of “New”.
The manufacturers who suffered from the publications of the Roskathesti reported that it was not possible to turn the situation in many ways because business representatives are afraid to make joint statements or take joint actions. The attack allegedly can turn into a problem with the distribution of goods in retail networks, which have the influence of the Ministry of Industry and Trade that founded Roskachestvo.
Two years ago, at that time, the former chief sanitary doctor of Russia Gennady Onishchenko said that the incorrect results of the examination of the Roskachestvo are due to the fact that the structure has no own laboratories. Deputy Minister of Industry and Trade, Viktor Yevtukhov, rejected these claims in the “New” response. “Roskachestvo does not have its own testing laboratories for the testing of products,” the official admitted. “However, based on international practice, it implements the mechanism for selecting the best accredited testing laboratories competent for a different type of test.” He also stated that "none of the studies of the Roskacality was recognized as false."
However, there is another opinion. “Information from them comes from them [Roskataskiy,” Mikhail Orlov said on a round table in TASS in TASS. - We must react anyway, this is considered by us as an appeal. Unfortunately, they must state that the research is often made crookedly. ” In such situations, the supervisory authority conducts its own audit, the results of which are often refuted by disappointing examinations of Roskachestvo.
But, as they say, the spoons were found, but the sediment remained.
The Federal Antimonopoly Service answered the requests of Novaya Gazeta for the relevant claims to Roskachestvo (asked to send a complaint through the form on the FAS website) and the Ministry of Industry and Trade, which oversees and finances the activities of the Roskachestvo. Rospotrebnadzor did not answer the request of the New.