One of the main trends of the past year is the expansion of the territory of art. Wherever it has leaked, it is ours. And to factory floors, and to banks, and to offices, and to the metro (the First Moscow Biennale opened with a demonstration of video art at the Vorobyovy Gory station). Many exhibition spaces were born. The first place behind the now famous “ARTStrelka” in the garages of “Red October” was a place called “Project_FABRIKA”. Several workshops of the technical paper plant turned into exhibition halls. Over the past year, curator Elena Kuprina has made several good exhibitions there, even visually supporting the brutal aesthetics of industrial workshops (the documentation of war photographs and film archives was especially good). Then the ArtPlay center appeared, occupying the workshops of the Red Rose plant. Moscow designers began to master industrial aesthetics with some success. Then there was the next act of artillery intervention in the topography of Moscow. Three more new locations opened almost simultaneously. Firstly, this is the gallery of the artist and gallerist Alexander Yakut on the territory of the Arma plant, which has existed since the 60s of the 19th century in the area of the Kursk railway station. The new Yakut gallery occupied a giant cylindrical gas storage tank - a gas holder. Secondly, a revival happened with the Moscow Arts Center on Neglinnaya Street. The owner, banker Alexander Smolensky, previously invited Marina Loshak to cooperate. Therefore, in the “old” MCI, the exhibitions were refined and sophisticated, greatly contributing to the emergence of new chapters in the still fragmentary history of the Russian avant-garde of the 10s-30s. Now the respectable MCI is occupied by young radicals looking for a new Gesamtkunstwerk at the intersection of street art (graffiti), actionism, and club culture. Thirdly, on Ostozhenka, Swiss entrepreneurs and collectors Nicola and Claire Savoretti opened a cozy hall “Modern City”, where they want to display non-commercial works of young artists.
How effective is the expansion of contemporary art into the city? The events of the end of last year and the beginning of this year provide little reason for optimism. On Neglinnaya, the suspended project of street graffiti artists “Why” has just been replaced by an exhibition of young Ukrainian artists “Hot/Cool Ukraine”. Contrary to the name, the exhibition itself is neither hot nor cold. She is unintelligible. They brought different works: bad, wow, and good (the latter includes a sculpture of Zhanna Kadyrova in the form of a crumpled cigarette pack - a phraseologically accurate thing). But the curators of the new exhibition would like to ask the question remaining after the previous exhibition of graffiti artists: “Why?” Why combine in one impressive gallery space a languid painting with copulating snowmen from Ksenia Gnilitskaya (otherwise we don’t have our own Batynkov), a foam plastic “Tower” resting on the ceiling of the gallery by Vladimir Kuznetsov (reminiscent of a cast of a decorative lotus at the casino in front of the Pushkinsky cinema), video with social provocations on the streets of Kyiv from the group “R.E.P.” (“revolutionaries of the experimental space” provoke nationalists or force passers-by into a minibus to watch contemporary art, but the meaning of the experiments is not readable, since instead of speech there is mooing, and the work of the cameraman is extremely bad)? What is the message of such an exhibition? To show that in Ukraine artists love pop art, value social art, and are marching in step with the Russian “Radeks” (a group of young radical performance artists) as a pioneer left march? Boring...
The exhibition at the MCI was rejected by the very space of the venerable gallery. The exhibition is in no way consistent with the expectations and references that determined the image of the former Center on Neglinnaya in the memory of Muscovites. Inadequate.
The same inadequacy occurred in the relationship of art with the unusual, now fashionable industrial territories of the city. The well-started “Project_FABRIKA” is still stalling. ArtPlay has become simply an office center for designers and a network of expensive art boutiques. In the Yakut gas holder, the exhibitions are weak, in no way commensurate with the gigantic, “ancient Roman” rotunda of the gas storage facility, which with its design and texture a priori becomes the main exhibit of the gallery. Pleasant exceptions are the Center for Contemporary Art on Zoologicheskaya and ARTStrelka. It won’t be enough... We, as always, in an emergency mode, adapted the Western tradition of revitalizing wasted, problem areas of the metropolis. In Europe and America, museums (for example, the Vienna Museum of Decorative Arts MAK) and gallery districts are actually built in old, useless, ruined warehouses, factories and factories. The infrastructure is being revitalized, dangerous and criminal places are disappearing. But in order for us to succeed as in the West, it is not enough to simply scrape off the dirt from the smoke-stained walls, make cosmetic repairs, install two or three fashionable stands, set up lights, organize a bar counter, hang pictures and invite the press. It is necessary to think about how this, most often inaccessible place, will be able to communicate with the non-vernissage public. Both gallery owners and curators more often understand that the public is still ignoring new addresses. And since it is much more difficult to educate than to trade, the exhibition policy is gradually being phased out. And extravagant places are gradually being reformatted either into commercial showrooms or into halls for one-day presentations (in the gas tank, in particular, last Friday a photographic Internet portal noisily celebrated its birthday).
And another inadequacy is to feverishly combine contemporary art with the anemic, sterilized interiors of business offices. At the end of last week, the State Center for Contemporary Art imported works by fashionable Moscow artists into the interiors of the advertising company BBDO. He set up an “Artoteka” there. That is, the company’s employees sit at their computers, come up with new enticing videos, slogans for chewing gum, fizzy drinks and eau de toilette, communicate in meeting rooms, and modern art everywhere sticks to their eyes and stimulates them to work better, more creatively, more inspired. The only trouble is that for the BBDO offices, the works of our masters (Shutov, Chelushkin, Chernysheva, even those fascinated by advertising brands Vladislav Efimov and Aristarkh Chernyshev) suit a cow like a saddle, like a reproduction of Ingres’ “Turkish Baths” over the table of a teacher of ethics and psychology of family life (well How, for example, can you hang melting, nerve-searing paintings by Gore Chahal in a meeting room, where, by definition, the atmosphere should be calm and focused?). That is, again, a precedent for matrix thinking: we have art, you have offices. We will mechanically connect them and get something like the Deutsche Bank with its legendary collection of works by masters of contemporary art in the corridors and offices of the administrative building.
The trouble is that contemporary art in Russia suddenly became fashionable, but it never became a basic cultural value. Therefore, all fashionable gestures of expanding arterial territory still resemble some kind of fetish, ritual spells. And in European capitals, communication with contemporary art is the norm, it’s everyday life. This is the correct organization of the visual image of space. This is adequate.