| Lawyers managed to defend their independence Having listened on Thursday, April 18, to the annual presidential message in the Kremlin and German Gref’s report on the government’s new approaches to reforming housing and communal services in the Duma, deputies will consider the law “On advocacy and the legal profession” in the second reading. The first version of the law presented by the presidential administration caused violent indignation among the wider legal community. Lawyers accused the Kremlin of trying to “build” the legal profession by creating a system of strict subordination of the legal community to the authorities. The administration made a compromise. During the preparation of the law for the second reading, a conciliation commission made up of state representatives, lawyers and deputies removed from the bill “On advocacy and the legal profession” many of the provisions that caused the greatest dissatisfaction.
Firstly, the police and the prosecutor's office are deprived of the right to conduct operational activities against a lawyer without court permission. Secondly, the independence of defense attorneys is guaranteed by the provision of immunity “for opinions expressed during the exercise of advocacy”; thirdly, the law obliges internal affairs bodies to protect the safety of defense attorneys. The draft now includes a chapter on bar associations, the liquidation of which was envisaged in its first edition. According to the legal community, the existence of colleges and the preservation of their non-profit status is one of the main guarantees of the independence of the legal profession. Finally, defense lawyers, and not representatives of the state, will be in the majority in the qualification commissions that take examinations of applicants for the title of lawyer and consider complaints against colleagues.
In general, lawyers have a positive attitude towards the draft, adjusted for the second reading. According to the deputy chairman of the State Construction Committee Sergei Popov (Yabloko), “the main thing is that we managed to preserve the bar association, because the bill in the first reading destroyed everything to the ground. The administrative interference of the Ministry of Justice in the work of lawyers has been reduced.” Deputy Oleg Utkin (Unity) said: “It is important that the presidential side agreed that the board could have branches in other territories and regions.” According to the chairman of the presidium of the Inter-Republican Bar Association, Nikolai Klen, “the state wanted to have a strong hand in the legal profession, and therefore the proposed law did not suit anyone.” “The conciliation commission managed to find a good compromise. The basic principle - the independence of the legal profession from the state - has been preserved. We hope that the new law will better ensure the right of citizens to protection. It will be very difficult for an incompetent person to become a lawyer,” says Nikolai Klen.
The head of the Moscow Regional Legal Consultation, Sergei Kruglyakov, agrees with him: “Complicating the procedure for becoming a lawyer is justified, since the quality of our personnel, due to the breadth of the emerging boards, was not up to par.” In his opinion, “the first edition gave more questions than answers, but any new law will be better than now. We still use socialist documents and cannot properly fit our activities into the Tax Code.”
But not all changes pleased lawyers. According to Mr. Popov, some amendments worsened the bill: “In the original version, it was proposed to provide free assistance to pensioners, veterans and disabled people; the federal budget was supposed to pay for lawyers. The government found the money, but at the suggestion of Deputy Utkin, an amendment was introduced to significantly reduce the volume of free assistance. This is a blasphemous amendment. I will seek its abolition." Mr. Klen is also dissatisfied with the amendment. According to him, the issue of remuneration for appointed, free lawyers has not been resolved - “the state is in no hurry to pay.” Mr. Utkin believes that “the amendments provide an exhaustive list of persons entitled to receive free legal assistance. The state does not have the ability to provide it to a wide range of people.”
Most likely, the discussion of the bill in the Duma will still not be easy. But, as lawyer Genrikh Padva said, “the most egregious points have been eliminated,” and lawyers seem ready to put up with other shortcomings of the law. Pavel APTEKAR |
|