On November 11, 2017, the Russian Government excluded the construction of the BREST-300 nuclear reactor in Seversk from the Federal Target Program “New Generation Nuclear Energy Technologies for the Period 2010 - 2015 and for the Future until 2020.” The corresponding resolution was published on November 15 on the Russian official Internet portal of legal information. According to this resolution, only a module for preparing fuel for the reactor and a module for reprocessing spent fuel will be built in Seversk. The BREST-300 reactor itself will not be built. How final is this refusal? Does this mean that the most advertised Tomsk nuclear project in recent years will never be implemented? TV2 cites the opinions of the project manager for the construction of the reactor, Evgeniy Adamov, the ex-general director of the Siberian Chemical Combine, Vladimir Korotkevich, and also reminds its readers of the chronology of events around BREST.
Photo: USO SKhKThe “Proryv” project, within the framework of which it was planned to build an experimental nuclear reactor in Seversk, at the site of the Siberian Chemical Plant (along with modules for preparing fuel and reprocessing it after use in the reactor), was presented to the public in 2012 . Since the talk about “Breakthrough” and the beginning of its implementation coincided with the reduction of existing production facilities at Siberian Chemical Combine, then, accordingly, the project itself was presented as a kind of universal lifesaver that would more than compensate the Siberian Chemical Combine for all losses from these reductions.
In January 2017, it became known that back in August and September 2016, Rosatom agreed with the Russian Ministry of Economic Development on a draft government resolution, according to which it was necessary to abandon the start of construction of the BREST investment project until the economic situation in the country stabilized. This is exactly the wording that was given in the explanatory note to the government resolution:

Later, the author of this explanatory note, Deputy Head of Rosatom Alexander Pershukov, told a TV2 correspondent that there was no talk of abandoning the construction of BREST-300:
Alexander PershukovIt’s not like that there,” said Pershukov. - I know, because I both wrote and signed. This is the situation there. There are recommendations from our government not to start global construction projects during the three-year period [2017 - 2019], but to complete those construction projects that already exist... And if we have risks regarding BREST, then we have decided to further reduce the impact of these risks . Therefore, we did not stop, did not stop, did not exclude, but decided to optimize.
In August of this year, the head of Proryv, Evgeny Adamov, spoke to deputies of the Legislative Duma of the Tomsk region and told them about the bright prospects of this project. However, some facts that Adamov spoke about gave rise to doubts that the reactor would actually be built. First of all, I was surprised by the dispersion of “official points of view” on the number of new jobs that the implementation of “Breakthrough” will create. According to Adamov, this is 1,090 vacancies, but this number is likely to decrease. A week before Adamov’s speech, General Director of Siberian Chemical Combine Sergei Tochilin spoke about 1,400-1,500 jobs, and earlier, Governor of the Tomsk Region Sergei Zhvachkin, speaking to reporters together with TVEL President Yuri Olenin, called the figure 2,000. Such vague ideas about the number of future jobs are quite justified doubts that the project is really thought out and calculated, and that they are actually going to implement it.
The second “wake-up call” in Evgeniy Adamov’s speech to the deputies was his admission that the “Breakthrough” project would be unprofitable, that is, it would not be able not only to make a profit, but also to pay for itself, which is an unaffordable luxury in the current economic situation in the country.
After it became known on November 15, 2017 about the exclusion of reactor construction from the federal target program, TV2 turned to Evgeny Adamov for comment:
Evgeniy Adamov During 2016 - 2017, says Adamov’s commentary, continuous financial optimization of the Breakthrough project was carried out, within the framework of which priority tasks for the coming years were determined. In the construction sector, such a priority is the construction of a fuel complex at the ODEK site. This is a technical, intermediate solution. We are now considering a set of measures for the construction of the BREST-300 power unit, which could actually begin as early as 2018 using Rosatom’s own funds. We plan to begin preparatory work for the construction of the block next year.
If we talk about the resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation, which approved changes to the Federal Target Program “New Generation Nuclear Energy Technologies for the period 2010–2015 and for the future until 2020”, then they are talking, first of all, about bringing the parameters of budgetary financing of the Federal Target Program into compliance with the budget 2016 - 2017.
General Director of Siberian Chemical Combine Sergei Tochilin also looks positively at the prospect of building the BREST-300 reactor in Seversk. According to the Seversk information portal “ZATO We Are Talking,” on November 17, Tochilin assured journalists that the implementation of “Breakthrough” was proceeding according to schedule. According to him, the first stage - the construction of a fabrication production facility - is already coming to an end. The next stage is the construction of the reactor. At the moment, the documentation is in Glavgosexpertiza and Rostechnadzor. Licenses must be obtained. This is expected to happen in the first quarter of 2018. Afterwards, a competition will be announced for the construction of the reactor, which should also begin next year.
The exact opposite point of view is shared by the former general director of Siberian Chemical Combine Vladimir Korotkevich, who primarily speaks not even about the financial side of the issue, but about the fact that now in Seversk there are simply no personnel capable of launching and operating a new generation reactor:
Vladimir KorotkevichLet me remind you,” says Korotkevich, “that this idea was first proposed by Evgeniy Olegovich Adamov, who headed the Ministry of Atomic Energy in 1998-2001. But then, for various compelling reasons (Adamov was arrested in Switzerland and then convicted by a Russian court - editor's note), he was unable to “push through” this project in a timely manner.
And later (in the summer of 2012), the very proposal to move production from the site of the Beloyarsk NPP, where the BN-600 fast reactor was already operating and work on the BN-800 was being completed, was signed, during a visit to the Tomsk region, literally “on the knee” by the former head of Rosatom Sergei Vladilenovich Kiriyenko with the wording “Transfer to Tomsk...”, which simply caused me bewilderment because of its illogicality and inexpediency.
Vladimir Korotkevich recalls that the last uranium-graphite reactor at the Siberian Chemical Combine was shut down back in 2008. In his opinion, in 2021-2022, when it was planned to launch the BREST-300 reactor, it would be simply naive to talk about the presence of reactor specialists in Seversk. He says that over the past five to six years there have been virtually no remaining reactor operating workers left at the plant. Korotkevich also points out the failure of Proryv from an economic point of view:
But the reasoning of former TVEL President Yuri Olenin, published in the media, is that a complex of three processing units (a module for the fabrication of dense nitrite fuel, the BREST-300 reactor itself and a module for reprocessing spent fuel from this reactor) after startup and testing will be sold all over the world , as a commercial project, did not evoke anything except irony and sarcasm. Since it is clear that a reactor with a declared power of 300 MW, and even burdened with two additional expensive modules, such a reactor is simply not able to compete in terms of the cost of produced kilowatt-hour of electricity with a reactor with a capacity of 1000 or 1200 MW. It is no coincidence that the state corporation Rosatom has now initiated the development of a fast reactor with a capacity of 1200 MW.
Let us recall that the second stage of the project - the BREST-300 reactor itself - was excluded from the federal target program, and the first stage - the fuel fabrication module (buildings for which are being built according to schedule) and the third stage - the spent fuel reprocessing module - are still in the government's plans . But Vladimir Korotkevich also questions the prospect of building the third stage of the project:
The exclusion from the federal target program for the construction of the BREST-300 reactor, in my opinion, also raises the question of the economic feasibility of creating at the Siberian Chemical Combine a module for processing spent nuclear fuel, because it is known that at the MCC site in Zheleznogorsk, Krasnoyarsk Territory, commissioning work on the creation of already the third stage of an experimental demonstration complex for handling spent nuclear fuel from reactors based on the most modern technologies.
Photo: USO SKhKOnce again we draw your attention (because this seems important) to the words of Vladimir Korotkevich about the shortage of reactor specialists to launch and operate the BREST-300 reactor. This assessment, unfortunately, coincides with the assessment that we received from other sources (including from former Siberian Chemical Combine reactor workers): the loss of highly professional personnel is a problem that is relevant throughout the country. For example, according to our interlocutors, at one time there were serious problems with the launch of the fourth power unit at the Beloyarsk NPP (BN-800 reactor). And the BREST-300 reactor is a more complex device than the BN-800. And personnel in this matter really decide everything.
The issue of personnel, or more precisely, jobs, is also the main negative consequence of the refusal to build the BREST-300 reactor. As mentioned above, the reactor was presented to the public as a new production facility that could replace the closing and downsizing facilities of the Siberian Chemical Combine. True, according to Evgeniy Adamov, the new project envisaged the creation of only a thousand new jobs, which is not very much compared to the 3.5 thousand current employees of the Siberian Chemical Combine. Now, after the construction of the reactor has been abandoned, even these thousand can be forgotten. Now the only Proryv facility that has at least some chance of being completed and launched is the first stage of the project, the fuel fabrication module. According to experts, the number of jobs at this facility could range from 150 to 250 people.
Speaking about the development of the situation around BREST-300, one cannot help but note a certain (voluntary or involuntary) deceit on the part of the official curators of this project. This deceit is reflected in the two-fold spread in the number of jobs that this project will provide, and in the statement that Rosatom intends to invest billions of rubles in an economically unprofitable project... The persistence with which we are convinced of the implementation of “Breakthrough” is very reminiscent of the situation with Severskaya Nuclear power plant. Ironically, this project was also supervised by Sergei Tochilin, although not in the status of general director of the Siberian Chemical Combine, but in the status of deputy governor of the Tomsk region . Then, for several years, Tochilin assured the public that construction of the Seversk NPP was about to begin, although many experts said from the very beginning that the project was not feasible from an economic point of view. Anyone can familiarize themselves with the chronology of that “construction of the century” on the website “Nuclear Energy of the Tomsk Region” .
And one more consideration. Precisely due to the fact that the construction of the BREST-300 reactor, or rather the talk about such construction, was intended to relieve socio-economic tension in Seversk against the background of the reduction of the Siberian Chemical Plant, this project has long moved from the economic plane to the political plane. Therefore, we assume that until March 2018, that is, before the presidential elections in Russia, no one will officially tell the residents of Seversk and the entire Tomsk region that BREST-300 will never be built.