The three-day 16th Energy Congress, which began yesterday in Berlin, held annually under the auspices of the largest German business newspaper Handelsblatt, coincided with the resumption of Russian gas supplies through the territory of Ukraine. This event gave acute relevance to discussions about trends in the development of European energy policy. Most of the high-ranking speakers who came to the microphone considered it their duty to express everything that had boiled over in the first weeks of the new year, when the main gas pipe from Russia to Germany was empty. “The gas dispute will change the energy political situation in Europe,” Bernd Ziesemer, editor-in-chief of Handelsblatt, emphasized in his welcoming speech. “The gas, as we all hope, has arrived, but discussions around it will continue.” And, in order to add “wood” to the discussion, he added: “The events of recent days have opened a window for nuclear energy in Germany.”
Until recently, Germany was considered something of a nuclear pariah within the European Union. The government coalition of Social Democrats and Greens, led by Chancellor Gerhard Schröder, initiated laws to phase out nuclear power plants in the German energy sector. Now in the highest echelon of German politics it is considered good form to remember the peaceful atom and its important role in the context of climate and environmental protection. The wind in the sails of the nuclear lobby, which is initiating a “exit” from nuclear energy, blew with renewed vigor from overseas. In his report at the congress yesterday, German Federal Minister of Economics Michael Glos referred to a recent statement by Barack Obama, the meaning of which boils down to the fact that the greatest danger to the climate is precisely the abandonment of nuclear power plants.
However, among the five factors under the influence of which the current Handelsblatt congress is taking place, according to Mr. Ziesemer, the gas crisis should be ranked only in fourth place. This rating opens, of course, with “the worst financial crisis in history,” which caused a fall in prices for natural resources and led to a decrease in investment. What follows is a crisis in the European and, not least, the German auto industry. The arrival of a new US president in the White House, the third factor influencing European energy policy, is associated with enormous expectations, in particular with the declared program of gigantic investments in energy. Further, following the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, the ranking was gracefully completed by the results of the state elections in Hesse last weekend, as a result of which the Social Democrats suffered a bitter defeat. They left a government that tabooed not only the return to nuclear power plants, but also the use of coal to generate electricity.
Michael Glos, despite this gradation, first of all expressed satisfaction that gas from Russia should again come to Germany. “Russia and Ukraine behaved unacceptable,” he continued. “I don’t want to be a judge, but I hope that words will be followed by deeds and every New Year we will not become unwitting participants in the discord between the two countries.” Minister Glos also recalled that three years ago he told Vladimir Putin that Russians and Ukrainians know each other better and they should not shift their differences onto the shoulders of other countries. “It’s good that in Germany we are only 37% dependent on gas supplies from Russia,” the Federal Minister of Economics sincerely rejoiced and thanked all the European and German companies that showed solidarity with some countries of Southern and Central Europe who were in energy trouble.
Michael Glos outlined his - and, accordingly, the federal government of Chancellor Merkel's - view on how to shape energy policy in Germany. First of all, we are talking about restoring “full equality” of its three most important components - reliability, efficiency and environmental friendliness. This will make it possible to obtain an optimal “cocktail” of energy resources, including not only renewable sources and gas, but also coal and, “of course,” nuclear energy. Regarding the latter, Minister Glos urged: “Germany should not follow a special path that leads to a dead end.”
It was for this kind of sedition, from the point of view of not only the “greens”, but also the “reds” (i.e., Social Democrats), that at the end of 2008, Michael Glos was awarded the “shameful” title of “Dinosaur of the Year.” Which he proudly reminded those gathered at the Handelsblatt congress. The title was established by the German Union for the Protection of Nature. “Despite all the warnings about the disastrous consequences of his policies on the climate, Minister Glos continues to be a stubborn brake on protecting the environment,” the nominee said.
However, as it turned out, the distance from “shame” to praise for calls for a renaissance of coal and nuclear power can be successfully covered in two to three weeks, during which the current gas crisis grew and unfolded. Now, no matter what energy carrier is discussed on the sidelines of German energy policy, the minister’s words said yesterday will be considered good form: “We will not further increase our dependence on gas, including in the construction of power plants.”
Diversification of not only energy resources, but also routes for their delivery to Germany and Europe continues to be the most important principle of energy policy. “Trust is good, diversification is better” - this was the slogan put forward by the minister yesterday from the rostrum of the energy congress. The new gas transportation projects being implemented - the Nord Stream gas pipelines (with the participation of Gazprom through the Baltic) and Nabucco (a project to deliver gas to Europe from the Caspian Sea, bypassing Russia) will remain of equal priority. “However, against the backdrop of this, we should not succumb to attempts at political blackmail,” the minister demanded, recalling that Turkish Prime Minister Recep Erdogan a day earlier announced his readiness for Turkey’s active participation in Nabucco only if there are clear prospects for this country’s accession to the EU.
Such demands, Mr. Glos said, must be countered by “European solidarity,” which only strengthened during the period of cessation of gas supplies from Russia. All these parameters of European energy must be based on the unified position of the EU countries, which, in turn, needs a reliable mechanism for resolving international crisis situations. To this end, Minister Glos called for the urgent creation of an “energy task force”, which should include an observer mission, ready to begin its activities in a short time if necessary. After the first Russian-Ukrainian gas crisis, calls from high European politicians for the creation of an “energy NATO” sounded in approximately the same tone. Apparently, given the acute allergy to this abbreviation in Moscow, the current definitions have been softened to “solidarity” and task force.
The head of the Federal Ministry of Economics also contributed to the discussion about the balance of market and state in the energy sector of Germany and Europe. He stated that he is the ideological disciple of the father of the social market, Ludwig Erhard, and for this reason he is categorically against delegating powers to the state in the economy, which are not at all characteristic of it. Mr Glos has unleashed his ire on Brussels officials who are pushing national governments and companies to unnecessarily increase the state's role in key industries. Nevertheless, he named possible areas for the state's efforts in the energy sector, for example, in implementing the idea of creating national and European gas reserves - following the example of oil reserves. In addition, the policy should provide all possible support for the development of liquefied natural gas (LNG) business. “If we have LNG technology and if a crisis comparable to the current one breaks out again, we will be able to purchase gas all over the world,” said Minister Glos.