The investigation into fraud regarding the illegal sale of confiscated property has been completed
The Moscow department of the Investigative Committee, as Vremya Novostei learned, has completed an investigation into the scandalous case of fraud in the sale of goods illegally seized from Moscow companies, in which a number of employees of the capital’s police and prosecutor’s office were involved. In the coming days, the Moscow prosecutor's office is expected to approve the indictment and send the case to court. According to the investigation, the criminal group included 17 participants: businessmen Roman Chubatov, Boris Lisagor, Stefanovsky, Parinov, Chizhuk and Zayats, former prosecutor of the North-Western Administrative District (NWAD) Valery Samoilov, former prosecutor of the Tushino Interdistrict Prosecutor's Office Boris Nersesyan (on the wanted list ), former investigator for especially important cases (OVD) of the same prosecutor's office Pavel Kirillin, deputy head of the OBEP - head of the 3rd operational investigative unit (ORCh) of the Internal Affairs Directorate for the North-Western Administrative District Volodin, deputy head of the OBEP - head of the 1st ORCh Ryabukha, deputy chiefs OBEP Lukyanov, Davydov and Korensky, senior detectives for the Department of Internal Affairs of the 1st ORCh Zakharov and Klinov and expert of Property Expertise LLC Natalya Gegechkori.
All of them are charged with fraud. In addition, Chubatov and Lisagor are charged with organizing a criminal community (OCS), and Samoilov, Nersesyan, Kirillin, Volodin, Davydov and Korensky are charged with participation in it. All law enforcement officers are also accused of malfeasance, Kirillin is also accused of falsifying criminal cases, and Gegechkori is accused of falsifying examinations. According to the investigation, the damage from their actions amounted to more than 551 million rubles.
As the Vremya Novostei newspaper has already reported , the Moscow prosecutor's office opened this case on May 30, 2007, based on materials from inspections of a number of other criminal cases investigated by district prosecutors' offices. Investigators found that, under the pretext of investigating smuggling cases, police officers and prosecutorial investigators who were part of this group seized and then stole goods (computer and household appliances, clothing, etc.) from companies that had nothing to do with these criminal cases.
The investigation began with statements from the heads of three companies - Components and Systems LLC (KiS) (operating under the Pirit trademark), Fazar LLC and Geyser LLC, from which it was seized, and then with the permission of representatives of the Russian Fund Federal property (RFFI) under the guise of confiscation, goods worth several tens of millions of dollars were sold. Operational support for the investigation of the new case was entrusted to employees of the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia for the Central Federal District (GU MVD for the Central Federal District).
As follows from the case materials, Chubatov and Lisagor created an organized criminal group in 2006-2007, clearly distributing responsibilities among the group’s accomplices. Thus, Chubatov was responsible for providing and paying for warehouse space for storing confiscated goods, and paid intermediary companies on whose behalf he sold confiscated goods. One of these structures, according to investigators, was Ekon+ LLC, which had a corresponding agreement with the Russian Federal Property Fund. The general director of this company, Alexey Fedin, is a witness in the case. For the use of company details, according to investigators, he paid from 20 thousand dollars. In addition, Chubatov’s “subordination”, as the prosecution believes, included so-called intelligence officers - among themselves they were also called “raiders” - who were searching for potential victims .
Lisagor, according to investigators, was responsible for contacts in law enforcement agencies - the capital's prosecutor's office and the police. It was he who found suitable criminal cases initiated under Art. 188-1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (smuggling) in relation to unidentified persons, and agreed with the investigators “to establish several more warehouses allegedly related to this case.” After this, the “hijackers” got into action.
They looked through all advertisements in the media and the Internet, looking for companies selling the most marketable products - household and computer equipment, cars, etc. Also, the duties of the “hijackers” included infiltration into the selected company under the guise of buyers and obtaining its details and seal. Then false stamps, invoices and invoices were made, on which the seals of the victim companies were affixed. Then these documents were planted in the selected company, which were later confiscated from warehouses during searches by “their” operatives of the North-Western Economic Crimes Department and included in the investigation of smuggling cases as “irrefutable evidence.” The police presented a warrant to search the premises, having “discovered” counterfeit documents, despite the presence of real ones, sealed the warehouses and took the goods to the warehouse of a trusted company that had an agreement with the Russian Federal Property Fund for storage and its further sale.
As follows from the case materials, the operation of “dekulakization of companies” - inspection and execution of documents necessary for the seizure of goods - took place, as a rule, within just one day. At the same time, according to the investigation, Chubatov and Lisagor were personally present during the loading of the confiscated goods. The investigation found that most often the seized goods were loaded into the warehouses of Stealth LLC (its general director was Chubatov), after which they arrived on store shelves throughout the country, and at reduced prices. At the same time, as witnesses in the case said, the “defective goods” were not of interest to the persons “who took part in the search, nor were the documents for them.”
During the search and seizure of goods, as follows from the case materials, a representative of an independent appraiser company, working together with this group, on behalf of the investigators, gave an opinion, underestimating the value of the goods by tens of times. These conclusions were attached to the criminal case of smuggling, and then within its framework a decision was made on the impossibility of further storage of the confiscated goods and its sale. These documents were sent to the RFBR, which gave its sanction, and that was the end of it. Criminal cases were suspended immediately after the sale of goods under various pretexts, and the owners of the confiscated goods who demanded their return were simply kicked off.
During such operations, as the investigation established, the accused used pseudonyms and assigned serial numbers for radio communication. So, Chubatov was assigned No. 1, Lisagor - No. 2 and the pseudonym Barin, Davydov was known by everyone under the nickname Balamut, Korensky was White, Nersesyan - Narcissus, and Samoilov was designated by the abbreviation V.N. For purposes of conspiracy, their mobile phones were used for communication “exclusively between individual accomplices.” Thus, Lisagor had one mobile phone intended only for communication with Nersesyan, and the other for communication with Chubatov and Samoilov. In addition, as follows from the case, it was Chubatov, Lisagor and Samoilov who distributed the proceeds from the sale of confiscated goods among the members of the group.
In 2007, according to the investigation, policemen Zakharov, Klinov, Lukyanov, Ryabukha and Volodin “received 68 thousand dollars from Chubatov for four days of so-called investigative actions,” expert Gegechkori - 40 thousand dollars, Samoilov - 200 thousand dollars, Lisagor, Nersesyan and Kirillin - 1 million dollars for three, Chizhuk - 10 thousand dollars, “Korensky and Davydov and other accomplices received funds from Chubatov, the amounts of which amounted to 60 thousand dollars "
During the preliminary investigation, it was established that in March 2006, the Zelenograd prosecutor's office opened a criminal case of smuggling against unidentified persons regarding the movement of a batch of built-in household appliances belonging to Vineta LLC across the customs border of Russia. Then, about 5 thousand units of equipment were discovered and seized at the company’s warehouse at 5 Zapadny Proezd. When the owner of the goods brought to the prosecutor's office the necessary documents confirming the legality of its import into the country, it turned out that the investigator had already issued a resolution on the sale of the confiscated goods through Transit North-South LLC, which has an agreement with the Russian Federal Property Fund, at a reduced price. While the product itself cost $100 million, the intermediary company sold it for only $240 thousand, citing some kind of expert assessment. Then the businessman wrote a complaint to the Moscow prosecutor's office, which, after carefully studying the case materials, entrusted further investigation to the Tushino prosecutor's office.
At first, nothing new could be found there, and the case was suspended. But a year later, employees of the Tushino prosecutor’s office suddenly discovered two more warehouses with allegedly smuggled goods - household appliances that belonged to Fazar LLC and KiS computers. As part of these two operations, 15 thousand units of household appliances worth almost 150 million rubles were seized from Fazar, and computers worth 250 million rubles were seized from KiS. In addition, in both companies (this was the pretext for the search), detectives found counterfeit seals planted by the “printers.” After this, the “Vineta” case was again suspended, and all the confiscated goods were taken to the warehouses of Stealth LLC on Zhivopisnaya Street, 46, building 20, Vvedenskogo Street, 4-a, and in Khimki, Ivakino quarter, to the territory of OJSC CMS “Olympian” "and implemented. The Fazar product sold for 12 million rubles. through “Econ+”, and “KiS” - for 42 million rubles.
Soon, Chubatov and Lisagor received information that the prosecutor’s office of the Central Administrative District (CAO) was investigating a suspended criminal case regarding the discovery of goods allegedly imported in violation of customs legislation at Spaccio-B LLC. As a result, an investigator from the Central Administrative District Prosecutor's Office resumed the investigation of this case and issued a resolution on illegal searches at the warehouses of the Sports House and Vector companies in Korolev, which had nothing to do with Spaccio-B. Further, as the investigation established, the investigator decided to transfer the confiscated property for safekeeping. After this, the criminal case was also suspended, and forged documents were attached to it stating that the goods were allegedly taken out for storage in Naro-Fominsk. However, the investigation established that in fact all the confiscated goods were sent to Stealth warehouses, where they were prepared for sale at a reduced price, without even waiting for an expert assessment and a decision to transfer the confiscated goods to the Russian Federal Property Fund. True, the swindlers no longer had time to sell this “boot.”
During the investigation into fraud with confiscated goods, all smuggling cases through which the scams were carried out were found to be falsified and closed.
Almost all of the accused refused to testify after their arrest and did not admit guilt. However, the investigation came to the conclusion that “the actions of all accomplices had a clearly mercenary motive, which refutes their version of non-involvement in the crimes.”
Since the former Tushino prosecutor Nersesyan absconded from the investigation, the case against him was separated from the main one into a separate proceeding. As for the remaining members of the criminal group, despite the fact that the case will soon be brought to court, the investigation itself against them has not been completed, since the investigation has revealed a number of similar scams.