The Constitutional Court allowed lawyers to freely defend citizens
There has been a real revolution in Russian criminal proceedings. From now on, every inmate of the pre-trial detention center has the right to see his lawyer at any time. And no permission from the investigator is required for this anymore. This is what the Constitutional Court ruled yesterday, recognizing the sixteenth article of the Law “On the detention of suspects and accused of crimes” as inconsistent with the Basic Law of the country.
Today, in order for a lawyer to visit his client, he must obtain from the investigator leading the case a kind of permission to visit - admission to participate in a criminal case. Moreover, this document is often of a one-time nature, and for each new meeting the defense attorney must contact the investigator every time. This is what is required by the instructions of the owner of all prisons and pre-trial detention centers - the Ministry of Justice, written on the basis of the now recognized unconstitutional article of the law “On Detention...”. Lawyer Yuriy Kostanov, who applied to the Constitutional Court, was able to convince the judges that thanks to this article, the authorities in charge of this or that criminal case have more than enough opportunities for arbitrariness. And the right to qualified legal assistance given to citizens by the Constitution is significantly infringed with the help of this article, both for objective (the absence of the investigator at the workplace) and subjective (his reluctance to allow a lawyer to visit) reasons. The Constitutional Court could not but agree with Mr. Kostanov’s position.
There is no limit to the jubilation of the legal community. “I didn’t expect any other decision from the court,” lawyer Henry Reznik told a Vremya Novostei newspaper correspondent. “The unconstitutionality of this provision was obvious.” “This decision ties the hands of those investigators who until now considered themselves not the procedural side of the prosecution, but the bosses in criminal cases,” the head of the Antiproizvol public center, lawyer Sergei Zamoshkin, told a Vremya Novostei newspaper correspondent. According to Mr. Zamoshkin, yesterday’s decision of the constitutional judges will acquire especially revolutionary significance for newly detained suspects, especially those in need of protection. And only lawyer Semyon Ariya did not share his colleagues’ delight, saying that he does not expect a bright streak in life from the decision of the Constitutional Court. Perhaps he is right. After all, recognizing the inadmissibility of procedural inequality between the prosecution and defense, the judges still considered that “the legislator has the right to determine organizational, legal and other conditions, as well as elements of the procedure for admitting a lawyer to participate in a case, without, however, making such participation dependent on the permission of the person or the body in charge of which the criminal case is pending.” That is, the investigator’s right to issue permits for visits was taken away and given to someone else, for example, the Main Directorate for the Execution of Punishments of the same Ministry of Justice. He will rewrite his instructions and establish that lawyers will have to obtain permission to visit their clients not from the investigator, but from the head of the pre-trial detention center. And everything will start all over again, fortunately a start has been made.