The architectural mass represented by the Studio-44 was compared with the porridge that poured out.
In a well -known fairy tale, it was enough to shout in time: "A pot, not cook!" In real life, neither the city authorities, nor serving the appetites of investors, architects show the desire to besiege the greedy to the Navar of developers. Even when it comes to such a responsible place as the core of Kamennoostrovsky Prospekt.
In place, at the intersection of Kamennoostrovsky and Karpovka, as an example of “negligence of the ruler of Petrograd”, Lukomsky also indicated, in 1916. Outraged, as “near the street intended for skating and walking” on one corner - a wooden tavern, on the other - a teaspoon in an old mansion, the third - a ruined house and a wasteland near it. An unconditional mistake was the appearance of here since the middle of the XIX century. Factory buildings, located in the proximity of the proxy that are not appropriate for them (No. 27 in Karpovka, Arch. E. F. Anikin - for a factory of lamps and bronze products of Jean Grizar, then rebuilt by V.V. Shaub for the furniture production of Meltser, and No. 18–20 on sand, now professor Popov Street - Arch. V.V. Shaub and military engineer E. F. Meltser).
Benois called the Kamennoostrovsky “one of the most impossible streets in the world” and ranked “unforeseen the importance of such a city artery” to examples of “lack of a state view of construction”.
The mayors changed, and the state system itself over the past century has changed more than once. And this place still remained an example of the negligence of the authorities, who did not realize either its significance or special value.
Since 1988, production housings have been empty. The buildings of the strict classicism of the 1820s-the two-story house of Korlyakov (until recently, the attributed KGIOP as a built architect D. Adamin, and now sorted to buildings with not established authorship) and one-story neoclassical outbuilding, adapted in 1912-1913, were slowly destroyed. Arch. A. Ya. Romasko for cinema "Grand Palace".
In the new millennium, this territory entered with the stigma of "problematic". Thank you for not the “damned”-which was supplied with her visas on the other side of the avenue, with a thirty-year-old almost long-term construction-the Northern Crown hotel, where Metropolitan John went into the coffin of the St. Petersburg Bank, barely bringing his hand for the blessing of Lyudmila Borisovna Narisova.
This is how Korlyakov’s house looked in recent years ...
Until he was hidden by painted false facades. Photo by Peter Gradov and Mikhail Maslennikov
A reasonable decision of the city authorities would be to declare a competition of ideas and concepts to begin: in order to determine which particular option for the development of this territory meets the interests of St. Petersburg, the requirements of its urban planning logic, and determine the boundaries of the permitted. But this did not happen - another puncture of the strategy. And now it is not the city that orders the music again, but the business (this time - the Scandinavian company NCC). The leitmotive is unchanged - to squeeze from the site to the maximum.
Nevertheless, on the last city council, where the developments of the architectural workshop of Nikita Yavein Studio-44 were presented, they found what the designers were praised for. The reviewer Sergei Oreshkin noted the excess of norms in parking spaces (as much as 280 instead of the necessary 170) and landscaping (19 versus 15 %). And they could, they say, for the sake of the investor to build everything up with a continuous. Others gasped: you just look, they do not even propose to demolish all this small nonsense of the 19th century that is confused underfoot! Thirds did not at all hide their indignation with this regrettable fact and, jumping up from the places, demanded to demolish both the root of Korlyakov and the outbuilding of this “false Adami”, which would dare to hell a hundred years ago, and now, they will declare high classics and the “sacred cow”. Especially the dancing of more than one jig on the bones of historical buildings.
Design proposals of the Studio-44 architectural workshop.
With some caution, the new KGA chairman Oleg Rybin showed his solidarity with this approach, who recognized the unacceptable situation when, instead of working with the ensemble, there is an examination and to tact with city -defenders; And the one who has been accumulated in the struggle for a cultural heritage in all cities - be it Petersburg, Moscow or Nizhny.
Boldly battered by this struggle, Nikita Yavein, nevertheless, quite naturally demonstrated humility before the demand of the law, assuring: "There was never any talk about any demolition." Boris Kirikov, who performed a historical and cultural examination, also insisted on the inviolability of the buildings of the 19th century with the same convincing. Her conclusions, presumably, were completely arranged by the customer: in the list of protection items from former cinema, one facial wall remains, from the house of Korlyakov - only the first floor.
The declared preservation of all the cultural heritage sites available on the site (mentioned two buildings of the XIX century, the industrial building on the embankment and two - along Popov Street, plus the factory pipe) does not fit with the proposed development option. When imposing a plan of the future complex to the scheme of territories of cultural heritage objects, it is clear that new buildings crawl to four of them very significantly (minus the pipes that are proposed to transplant to the roof of two -level parking).
The architect Evgeny Gerasimov, who was not even particularly scrupulous towards the historical context, was not even distinguished by a particularly scrupulous attitude to the historical context, saying that: if these houses are recognized as monuments (although he personally considers their value to be very dubious), it is impossible to “run into” them.
Of the four options presented by the developers, the city council preferred the latter. The option, appreciated by the participants of the meeting as “thoughtful and solid”, in terms of resembles the number VI; The interval between the first and second numbers is served as "typical for the Petrograd side of Kurdoner." Although the kurdoners are actually not at an angle to the street that we go out (which we see here), and in terms of their layout, this is an elongated stocking of 80 meters deep into something-rather a dead end, an optical trap for the eye than open to the Street "Fulfilling Court" (Fr. Cour d'Honneur). 16,000 square meters are assigned to the residential function. m; For commercial, offered for placement in the first floors behind historical facades, - 3000, in appendage - a couple of family -type kindergartens, for 10-12 people. The designers put themselves in the merit that the new complex will not exceed 28 m-with a maximum of 64 m permitted here. However, it should rather regret the parameters that were unacceptable for this place under Valentina Ivanovna-imagine how appropriate on the Kamennostrovsky 20-story building.
The developer of the preceding and much more strict high-altitude regulations Boris Nikolashchenko believes the height proposed by the “studio-44” quite reasonable, and the presented architecture is “not the worst”, although a few “rude”, requiring further improvement. Boris Vasilievich considers both proposed decoration options to be unacceptable: “There are absolutely neither bricks nor yellow. The textured plaster is gray or dark gray-this is what suits this avenue. ” Much more experiences are caused by Nikolashchenko news of the calls that sounded at a meeting of calls to sacrifice the Korlyakov house to a sacrifice of a certain urban planning super -task.
“This is a beautiful building, a miracle domik, thanks to which the place is so extraordinary, where we can see the layering of times. It is amazing that the city council advocates his demolition, ”Boris Vasilievich laments. And he recalls how, in the Soviet years, two houses of the 18th century, included in the ensemble of the Square of Alexander Nevsky and allegedly disharmonious with the new construction, were in the same way. “But still then they made a wise decision, retained those two houses, and the new ones were slightly pushed away, put it away. And here it would be possible to do the same, an extremely responsible place - because for Kamennoostrovsky, as for Nevsky Prospekt, with the ensembles of the area of Ostrovsky, Moika or Fontanka, transverse prospects are also important. It should be careful to work with the context, ”the expert is convinced.
It is not surprising that Boris Nikolashchenko with such an approach has no place in the current city council (prudently deleted at Mityrev), more and more reminiscent of the interest club, a collection of divisions in one glade of practicing architects, sensitive to the general circle of needs. As they say, “today you, and tomorrow I” ... The word “context” in most of them causes them only heartburn. The block of another elite, a brownish heap of a heap, falling on Kamennoostrovsky Prospekt, is a convincing illustration. Here you have - to your context.
At city -protection forums, the project is inclined in all ways, calling who is “bunker”, who is “a dead end of Jave”, accusing the author’s team of “architectural extremism with elements of vandalism”. It is difficult not to see in the "studio-44" decision of the decision of signs of a conscious provocation involved on exorbitant ambitions. Under the guise of law -abiding preservation of historical buildings, an option is proposed, as if deliberately brought to the point of absurdity: a massive block that grows behind the old facades visually crushes the houses of the century before last, presses them into the ground. If the author sought to create a anthem of meaninglessness, absurdity and doom of the struggle to preserve genuine St. Petersburg, he achieved this goal. You demand that you maintain all historical buildings, have been embarked on stupid laws - Nate, get, cry and exaggerate.
Member of the Presidium of the St. Petersburg VOOPIK, Architect Pavel Nikonov evaluates the presented approach as an imitation of the preservation of cultural heritage objects, turning out of the abuse of them: “According to Article 59 of Federal Law No. 73, the planning structure with its elements, the volume-planning structure, the ratio of free and built-in urban spaces, recalls, recalls recalls. Expert. - And here there is a detonation of our urban planning traditions - the composition characteristic of St. Petersburg streets is violated, the principle of the red line is ignored, the structure of the avenue breaks. The complex is not placed along it, but at an angle to the main compositional axis, new buildings are randomly scattered, as it hit, as if boxes dumped in the warehouse. Korlyakov’s house, crushed by a mass overhanging over it, loses its attractiveness, is reduced to the level of some kind of absurdity. The illusion of the presence of several front facades in one row is created: formally, historical remains on the first line, but in fact, the new volume stands behind it. And he is not commensurate with anything - he falls out, like a porridge from a pot, which is nobody to order to stop.
Pavel Nikonov draws an analogy with Vladimir Square, where with the advent of the ugly community of the regent-Hall business center (by the way, reckoned by Mr. Yavoyn to one of the most catastrophic urban planning errors), Delvig's house was reduced to the level of a barely noticeable detail-and now some kind of lack of compha than the fitter is represented. As in the case with Marinka-2, and with a “recreated” fragment of the Lithuanian market, which received the role of a second-rate absurdity on this scene, a miserable squalor.
... according to the religious-magical belief that existed among some wild tribes, who ate part of the body of another person acquires the inherent quality, masters his vital force. However, it will not help the absorption of historical houses given to the Bleaning Studio-44 project. This life will not breathe into it. And how to produce a zombie-maybe it’s not too late to switch to the capable architect to create something more human, humane in relation to the city and its inhabitants? ..
A