About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
03/22/2004
Author
Hidden
Source
Novaya Gazeta Saint Petersburg
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Case No. 207

The voting results for the by-election of a State Duma deputy in the 207th district were approved by the district election commission. What lies ahead is confirmation (or non-confirmation) of this decision by the Central Election Commission. If the Central Election Commission considers the elections illegitimate, then the long-suffering district will have to elect a deputy again, for the third time. And if the elections are recognized as valid and Alexander Morozov is approved as a newly appointed Duma deputy, then his rivals in the election race will flood the City Court with applications to cancel the voting results due to the unprecedented violations that occurred on March 14. So “case No. 207” promises to be long and painful. How the intrigue will develop will become known at the beginning of this week.




On Friday afternoon, when I called the chairman of the regional election commission of the 207th district, Tatyana Komleva, she was just finishing preparing documents to send them to Moscow. So the CEC will begin considering them on Monday. On the same day, Morozov’s rivals will apparently complete the preparation of their claims to invalidate the voting results. Anna Markova is very determined. As Markova’s representative, lawyer Vita Vladimirova, confirmed to me, “there is no need to wait for the decision of the Central Election Commission.” So it is quite possible that the verdict of Mr. Veshnyakov’s department and Markova’s lawsuit will appear at the same time. Moreover, the matter will not be limited to one lawsuit. The draft statement of claim has already been prepared by Sergei Andreev, the same intention was expressed by Grigory Tomchin, not to mention the insulted Elvira Sharova and Andrei Elchaninov.
Meanwhile, in St. Petersburg in recent days, the opinion has been intensified that the election results are completely legitimate and there are no grounds for revising them. First of all, Alexander Morozov himself speaks about this, of course, and he is echoed by the leadership of the City Election Commission - Alexander Gnetov and Dmitry Krasnyansky. Well, Morozov’s activity, as an interested person, in this matter is completely obvious. But the zeal of the City Electoral Commission, which, by the way, is not directly related to the conduct of these elections, looks somewhat strange. Unless, of course, we take into account such an important nuance that the City Electoral Commission, like the city administration as a whole, is playing along with Morozov with all its might - just so as not to let Markova into the Duma.
Well, is there any reason to cancel the election results or not? Oddly enough, each of the conflicting parties is right in its own way. Moreover, both of them refer to the same law, citing different articles of it.
Let us recall the essence of the conflict. On voting day, March 14, at six polling stations in the 207th district, voters were given deliberately invalid ballot papers, where instead of one name, Igor Rimmer, who refused to participate in the elections, two more were crossed out - Elvira Sharova and Andrei Yelchaninov. As a result, the election results in these precincts were declared invalid, and the opinions of almost 13 thousand voters in these precincts were not taken into account.
This is where, as they say, the dog is buried. Supporters of recognition of the election results, referring to subparagraph 2 of paragraph 3 of Article 83 of the law “On elections of deputies of the State Duma,” argue that in order to recognize the elections as invalid and call re-elections, it is necessary that there are violations in more than 25% of polling stations. “There are 212 plots in the district, and 6 of them cannot account for 25%,” says Alexander Morozov.
Opponents, referring to subparagraph 1 of paragraph 3 of Article 83 of the same law, argue that the election results are canceled if it is impossible to reliably determine the results of the will of citizens. According to Anna Markova, the number of voters whose opinions were invalidated exceeds the difference in votes between the winner and the second-place “Against All” candidate. This situation does not allow us to reliably determine the true will of voters...
In short, the showdown following the election results in District 207, it seems, will be long and not at all obvious. A significant role will be played by what position the court will take in this case - upholding legal truth or political expediency. For which Anna Markova is persona non grata in our city. After all, she is to Smolny what a red rag is to a bull.

Nikolay DONSKOV
photo INTERPRESS