Prosperity Capital fund consolidated about 10% of Bashneft shares
The second largest shareholder of enterprises of the Bashkir fuel and energy complex, besides AFK Sistema, is the Prosperity Capital Management fund. This became known yesterday from the results of the fund's published reporting. According to these data, Prosperity Capital has consolidated about 10% of the shares of Bashneft and has shares in the Bashkir refineries - Novoil and Ufaorgsintez. According to fund manager Ivan Mazalov, the fund began purchasing these securities back in 2003 and since then has been constantly increasing its share, since it considered these shares to be undervalued. “For us, this is a portfolio investment,” Mr. Mazalov explained to a Vremya Novostey correspondent.
As is known, six enterprises of the Bashkir fuel and energy complex: ANK Bashneft, Bashkirnefteprodukt, Ufa Oil Refinery, Novoil, Ufaneftekhim and Ufaorgsintez changed owners in March of this year. Controlling stakes in these companies (in the amount of 65.8 - 87.2% of share capital) were bought by the holding company AFK Sistema for $2.5 billion. Representatives of the buyer noted that they were going to create a vertically integrated oil company based on these assets. It is expected that in the near future the company will issue an offer to minority shareholders of Bashkir fuel and energy complex enterprises to buy up the remaining shares. “According to the law, its price can be determined by the greater of two values: the weighted average price on the stock exchange over the last six months or the price of a past transaction,” recalls Dmitry Alexandrov, an analyst at Financial Bridge. According to unofficial data, Sistema is leaning toward the second option. In this case, 10% of Bashneft’s ordinary shares will cost $175 million, or $8.5 per share, estimates Veles Capital analyst Dmitry Lyutyagin. According to his calculations, the weighted average price of an ordinary share of Bashneft over the past six months at RTS trading is $4.84 per unit.
Prosperity Capital notes that they are not ready to talk about whether they will sell their stake to Sistema until they receive the terms of the offer. “Because of the crisis, the price of securities has fallen sharply (since May 2007, Bashneft’s quotes have fallen by 40%), and the current offer may be lower than the price at which the fund bought these shares,” says Lyutyagin. “In this case, the minority shareholder may not agree with the proposal of the controlling shareholder.” Investment analysts note that, according to some data, Sistema intends to pay a high share of profits in the form of dividends. Thus, the new owner is going to quickly return the funds spent on the transaction. “If this is really the case, then Prosperity Capital can wait for some time for a more generous offer, receiving good dividends,” states Lyutyagin.
It should be noted that Prosperity Capital Management has established itself as an active minority shareholder in the Russian market. The fund sued Severstal, tried to challenge the consolidation of Southern Kuzbass, and in 2008 sued one of the largest companies on the mineral fertilizer market in Russia, Uralchem, noting the illegality of the forced buyout of shares in one of its plants.