| The government and the Central Bank ignored the president’s instructions regarding preventing the strengthening of the ruble exchange rate
In the coming days, the State Duma at its plenary meeting will have to approve the “Main Directions of the Unified State Monetary Policy for 2007” introduced by the Bank of Russia. The document itself came out curious this year, since it actually did not take into account the president’s main requirement regarding the government’s monetary policy - curbing the rate of strengthening of the ruble exchange rate.
Vladimir Putin has repeatedly said in recent months that the situation with the strengthening of the ruble has become unfavorable for our economy. In particular, the president clearly said this during an online conference on July 6, when he answered the question of whether the dollar was in danger of collapsing to 17 rubles. The head of state noted that concerns about the growth of the ruble exchange rate are correct, since excessive strengthening of the national currency creates uncompetitive conditions for domestic producers. Putin spoke even more harshly on this topic during a meeting with Finance Minister Kudrin on August 22: “Statistics and the real situation in the economy show that the strengthening of the ruble may be critical this year for our national economy.”
Thus, Putin made it clear that the main task of the government and the Central Bank should be to contain the exchange rate of the ruble; this is no less important than the fight against inflation, which, as we know, largely ensures the strengthening of the national currency. And what do we see - the Central Bank submits a document to the State Duma, which states that “the growth of the real exchange rate of the ruble next year will be from 0 to 10%.” Not a bad corridor, that is, this is actually a rejection of what Putin spoke about, the policy of restraining the growth of the national currency and responsibility for the situation on the foreign exchange market as a whole. Moreover, First Deputy Chairman of the Central Bank Andrei Ulyukaev said that his department’s priority would not be to curb the growth rate of the ruble, but to reduce inflation.
What are we dealing with here? With deliberate sabotage of the president’s position or simply a lack of understanding of the consequences that may result from further policies aimed solely at fighting inflation? After all, one of the threats lurking in the continuing strengthening of the ruble exchange rate is a fall in the incomes of a significant part of the population, often the most economically active, who either receive salaries in dollars or keep their savings in them. And if we take into account that next year is both the year of elections to the State Duma and, in one way or another, the beginning of the presidential campaign, the question arises: are the government and the Central Bank aware of what their decisions in the field of monetary policy may lead to?
Just the other day, the Federal Reserve System and the US Department of the Treasury released a report, “The Use and Counterfeiting of US Currency Abroad.” This report is interesting to us because it says that about $80 billion is currently concentrated in Russia, that is, each citizen has an average of $550 in savings. Of course, these figures are probably exaggerated; according to the head of the Central Bank, Sergei Ignatiev, a year ago the Russians had about 20-30 billion dollars in their hands, but this is also not a small figure. It is possible that the truth is somewhere in the middle.
Let us now imagine the scale of the reduction in these savings in real terms in recent times. After all, since 2003, when the ruble began to strengthen, the dollar exchange rate has fallen against our national currency by more than 15%. Moreover, just since the beginning of this year, the real exchange rate of the ruble has strengthened by 8%. And if we add to this the rise in inflation, it turns out that people who receive salaries or keep savings in dollars have become significantly poorer in recent years. Keeping dollars in bank accounts also does not help, since no interest rates can compensate for the scale of the reduction in savings.
Of course, the fall of the dollar on world financial markets also plays a significant role here, but still its rate of decline in Russia is much more significant. Of course, the strengthening of the ruble from the point of view of the prestige of our state is very good; the Russian ruble is now considered even among the possible world reserve currencies. However, there are certain limits of strengthening, beyond which fraught with extremely unpleasant consequences for the economy. And here we need to talk not only about the fall in the incomes of citizens who rely on dollars, but what is even more important is the fall in the competitiveness of domestic producers and the decline in the rate of economic growth in general.
It's no secret that the steady economic growth of recent years is a merit not only of high oil prices, but also a consequence of the increased attractiveness of domestic industrial products, which became possible largely due to the low exchange rate of the ruble in the period 1999-2003. And now the situation is rapidly changing. Aleksey Kudrin said back in the summer of this year that Russia would face a slowdown in economic growth, and largely associated this with the strengthening of the real exchange rate of the ruble. However, for some reason, neither the government nor the Central Bank seem to intend to do anything to somehow combat this trend. Everyone seems to have simply forgotten about the goal of doubling GDP.
Further strengthening of the ruble leads to the replacement of domestic production with imports. The narrowing of sales markets due to the expansion of imports will mean stagnation of production, especially in non-resource manufacturing industries. And statistics show that in the nine months of 2006, import growth has already amounted to 29%, and production growth is only about 5%. In the near future, we can expect the gap between these indicators to widen.
A slowdown in industrial growth will lead to a decrease in the incomes of the population, not only those who receive salaries in dollars. Further, we can assume that the strengthening of the ruble will lead to a reduction in production at Russian enterprises, which will affect not only wages, but also employment, and this is a direct path to unemployment and social disasters. By the way, according to surveys, back in 2005, about 50% of enterprises were ready to resort to layoffs and wage cuts due to the appreciation of the ruble.
In general, the government and the Bank of Russia have something to think about. It seems that the government has simply relaxed, despite the increasingly frequent criticism of its work from the president. The White House either does not hear Putin’s warnings about the danger to the economy of the current rate of strengthening of the ruble, or will simply ignore them. Such self-confidence in one’s abilities is fraught; the president may get tired of simply pointing out the government’s mistakes every time. Andrey Lebedev, leading analyst at the Effective Policy Foundation
|