| Cases of split economic consciousness have been identified in Russia Not long ago, the president’s economic adviser, Andrei Illarionov, diagnosed the Russian economy as “drug addiction,” with which a “consilium” of ministers agreed a week ago at a regular government meeting. Yesterday, another disease was discovered, not in the economy, but in a part of Russian society directly related to the economy. The disease is called schizophrenia and it is expressed in split consciousness.
An additional diagnosis was made during a discussion at the Center for Strategic Research of the World Bank report (already the 27th in a row) on world development. The report, based on research conducted in 53 developing countries, addresses the challenges of creating a favorable investment climate.
True, the main author of the report, Warrick Smith, who presented this more than 250-page work, did not make any diagnoses. In an extremely correct form, almost without speaking specifically about Russia, he explained that, firstly, the quality of the investment climate is important not only for firms and companies, but also for society as a whole, since, for example, the number of workers directly depends on this factor places Secondly, investment plays a leading role in economic growth. Thirdly, investors see the main risks not even in high taxes and corruption, but in political instability, the unpredictability of the regulatory framework, the judicial system, which, according to Mr. Smith, “the state often forgets.” Fourthly, you cannot copy someone else’s, even successful, experience in creating a favorable investment climate; it is necessary to adapt it to local characteristics, otherwise “this can lead to disaster.” Fifthly, the state is obliged to pay attention to the basic aspects of creating an investment climate, forgetting about selective support for certain sectors of the economy, since such a policy leads to distortions in the market and a decrease in competitiveness.
As for Russia itself, summing up the assessments of World Bank experts, we can conclude that it is being asked to speed up transformations that will ensure effective protection of property, reduction of administrative barriers for business, improvement of tax administration, etc. In other words, exactly those measures that the Russian government has been proposing for a long time, but cannot implement in any way (as a result, a decrease in the growth rate of investment, growth in industrial production and GDP).
The discussion of the World Bank report resulted in a discussion on the general state of the Russian economy. It was opened by the head of the financial policy department of the Ministry of Finance, Alexey Savatyugin. It was he who, sharing his impressions of the “Business Russia” conference that took place the day before, made the discovery that the part of Russian society related to economics suffers from schizophrenia or split personality: liberalism and paternalism coexist simultaneously in the minds of representatives of this part of society. Their speeches, admitted Alexey Savatyugin, “are scary to listen to.” Moreover, business also suffers from this disease. This is expressed in his desire to work in the most liberal economic conditions with low taxes, but at the same time constantly demand money from the state for investment. “That is, the attitude of business to the state is approximately the same as the attitude of Ostap Bender to Koreiko: “Give me a million. Give me a million,” Mr. Savatyugin drew an analogy.
The rector of the Academy of National Economy, Vladimir Mau, corrected the Ministry of Finance official, noting that it was not Bender, but Panikovsky, who ended up like this in the Golden Calf. “But he was sent by Bender,” Mr. Savatyugin retorted.
However, Vladimir Mau did not argue with the essence of what Mr. Savatyugin said. “Inside every liberal one can find a paternalist,” the scientist-economist developed the theme. Thus, at a recent economic forum in St. Petersburg, many governors, declaring that they were liberals, immediately began asking to support certain sectors, “even agriculture,” Mr. Mau recalled. He also stated that the establishment of a favorable investment climate is impossible without basic political factors - an independent court, independent media, etc. In addition, according to him, before protecting property, it is necessary to protect the “individual”. Mr. Mau supported his opinion with an example from the history of the 20s of the last century, when wealthy Nepmen were asked to keep money in banks, guaranteeing their safety. “The NEPmen replied that they would not carry the money, since no one guaranteed the safety of depositors,” Vladimir Mau concluded the instructive story.
Meanwhile, the head of the expert council of Business Russia, Anton Danilov-Danilyan, apparently somewhat offended by Mr. Savatyugin for his unflattering review of the conference the day before yesterday, discovered the same schizophrenia among government members. “The economic bloc talks about itself as liberals, but makes paternalistic decisions. Here Zhukov (Deputy Prime Minister - Ed. ) spoke out against our completely liberal proposal to abolish import duties on equipment, citing the refusal as protection of domestic manufacturers, although we agreed with the Silaev structure (ex-Prime Minister of Russia Ivan Silaev now heads the Russian Union of Mechanical Engineers. - - Ed. ), - Mr. Danilov-Danilyan was indignant.
“Dualism in our heads is a legacy of our past,” Leonid Grigoriev, president of the Association of Independent Centers for Economic Analysis, tried to explain the situation. “Schizophrenia is a normal position for business,” said Evgeny Yasin, scientific director of the Higher School of Economics, in turn, meaning, apparently, on the one hand, the desire of entrepreneurs to work in a liberal economy, on the other hand, the desire to beg from the state preferences and benefits. Moreover, it seems that the development of this kind of schizophrenia is provoked by the government itself, which regulates economic relations with all its might and makes it clear that it can do anything.
This point of view is shared by the President of the Institute of the National Project “Social Contract” Alexander Auzan. “When the government provides services for certain...” - the end of his sentence hung in the air. Although it was not at all necessary to complete it.
However, the head of the expert department of the Center for Strategic Research, Vladimir Milov, is confident that confusion in people’s heads is not the main thing that prevents the “warming” of the investment climate. Much more dangerous, according to him, is that in the last year or two the gap between the officially declared and actually implemented economic policy has been growing. Vice-Rector of the Higher School of Economics Lev Yakobson aggravated the problem. According to him, the authorities have not yet made a choice on which path to take, and it is unlikely that it will be made in the coming years. "Unpredictability is even worse than bad choice. It's time to think about how to live in conditions of failed choice," says Mr. Jacobson.
The discussion was concluded by Kristalina Georgieva, World Bank Resident Representative in Russia. She shared her own discovery. It turns out that she previously thought that schizophrenia existed only outside of Russia in relation to Russia, which was expressed in the desire of foreign investors to invest in the Russian economy, despite the deterioration of the investment climate. “Today I learned that schizophrenia has spread much more widely,” Ms. Georgieva said. Mikhail VOROBYEV | |