| The minister decided to classify agriculture
Whoever owns the information owns the world. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Agriculture Aleksey Gordeev decided to prove the fairness of this rule by signing an order according to which almost all data on the state of affairs in the agro-industrial complex becomes closed to market participants. They, in turn, believe that having a monopoly on all the necessary information, the Ministry of Agriculture will be able to take control of the market itself.
Order No. 6 of January 5, 2001, which was at the disposal of the Vremya Novostei newspaper, defines a list of restricted information - materials, “the open publication of which is considered inappropriate.” Such information is prohibited “to be communicated orally or in writing to anyone, unless it is caused by official necessity. When preparing materials for open publication, it is prohibited to use “information of a secret nature and limited distribution.” The Ministry of Agriculture confirmed the existence of the order to the correspondent of the Vremya Novostei newspaper, but urged not to look for “sensations in some ordinary document.”
However, now any detailed information about the situation in the agricultural sector can become a sensation.
Neither society nor market participants can openly and freely obtain, for example, “up-to-date information on sown areas, gross yields of grain and oilseeds” or “balances of resources and use of grain” or learn about “the use of funds from the Special Fund for lending to agricultural organizations on preferential terms." Inaccessible to an ordinary citizen and an ordinary subject of the agricultural market will be “contracts and agreements in which the Ministry is one of the parties”, “a list (register) of federally owned objects of the agro-industrial complex system (enterprises, organizations and institutions, joint-stock companies with blocks of shares located in federal property)”, “information about the planned construction in Russia of facilities that will be equipped in whole or in part with imported equipment”, etc.
According to a representative of one of the large grain companies, “attempts to hide information will allow the Ministry of Agriculture to more quickly respond to market events through its affiliated structures, because it will have more complete information.”
This fits into the concept of grain market development proposed by Mr. Gordeev’s department, according to which all state stakes in agricultural enterprises are transferred to the Federal Agency for Regulation of the Food Market and the same agency becomes responsible for commodity purchasing interventions and other methods of regulating grain prices.
In fact, the Ministry of Agriculture is suddenly becoming the main player in the market with almost unlimited lobbying opportunities and complete control over information flows.
General Director of the Institute for Agricultural Market Studies Elena Tyurina, in a conversation with a correspondent of the Vremya Novostey newspaper, called the document “an attempt to hide information about the real state of affairs.” According to Ms. Tyurina, “one of the goals that the Ministry of Agriculture declares towards the development of the grain market is its transparency; by hiding data on grain production, they contradict themselves.”
Mr. Gordeev’s order has not yet become widely known even in his department. For example, the head of the food markets department, Arkady Zlochevsky, who is in charge of the grain market, refused to comment, citing the fact that he was not familiar with the document (although the order, signed a month and a half ago, instructs “the heads of structural divisions to organize work on studying the List all employees").
In general, the attitude of market participants to Mr. Gordeev’s order can be assessed as alarmingly skeptical. And the first news about the document causes nervous laughter. “Go to the US Department of Agriculture website, they have been predicting everything for a long time. The error is two percent. This is done all over the world - they take pictures from space and say what the yield will be. Some kind of baby talk,” says Alexander Kheifets, project coordinator for the Zerno-On-Line Internet exchange.
The head of the Sovekon analytical center, which conducts marketing research on the grain market, Andrei Sizov told the Vremya Novostei newspaper that such documents bring back sad memories of the recent past: in Soviet times, all information about grain production was classified as “secret.” “With the current administrative laxity, data is leaking and will continue to leak.” Their spread is technically quite difficult to limit. There are such things as aerial photography and space photography, which allow us to obtain fairly accurate information. This means that instead of turning to Russian data, the business world will appeal to American data. The cost of information will simply increase, but this will not affect decision-making in any way,” says Mr. Sizov.
Elena Tyurina, in turn, believes: “They (the Ministry of Agriculture. - Ed. ) simply do not have the right to hide this information: in order to have adequate information about the market, the opinions of several experts are needed. If this information is hidden, then it turns out that the Ministry of Agriculture may receive a monopoly on analytics.” Ms. Tyurina agreed with her colleagues who believe that there is an attempt by some officials to make money on information: “There has already been information repeatedly that the Ministry of Agriculture is trying to create its own analytical structure. trying to create more favorable market conditions.”
However, according to the director of the Institute for Agricultural Market Studies, even if you do not turn to foreign information about the state of affairs in the agro-industrial complex, it will be possible to obtain enough information: “In fact, of course, if this information is still closed, it will be possible to receive it - - talk with farm managers, see what they advance, but this will be much more long-term and painstaking work.”
The regulation “On the procedure for handling official information of limited distribution in federal government bodies,” approved by government decree in 1994, allows ministries and departments to limit access to information. As the correspondent of the Vremya Novostei newspaper was told in the department of registration and control over departmental acts of the Ministry of Justice, orders to limit the dissemination of certain information exist in many executive authorities. And ministries and departments are not always in a hurry to register them with the Ministry of Justice. The order of the Minister of Agriculture has not been registered either. “Ministries apply for examination and registration if they believe that the internal documents they issue affect the rights and freedoms of citizens,” an informed source in the Ministry of Justice told a Vremya Novostei newspaper correspondent. “If they believe that they do not affect, then the only way for us to conduct an examination is to request them on the basis of a complaint from a person interested or affected by the internal instructions.”
If we talk about the order of Mr. Gordeev “On approval of the list of information of limited distribution by the Ministry of Agriculture of Russia,” then any citizen can be an interested person whose right to information is violated, since the first lines of the list say that information of limited distribution includes materials , “the open publication of which is considered inappropriate.” Such information must be marked “for official use”, and Ministry of Agriculture officials are prohibited from publishing it. At the same time, there are obvious inconsistencies with the government decree. For example, according to the resolution, information on emergency, environmental, sanitary and epidemiological situations, as well as data on budget execution and the use of government resources cannot be classified as official use. In the order, the materials of audits and inspections of regulatory authorities (that is, information about the execution of the budget and the use of resources) are classified as official. Summary data on the epizootic situation in the country are also not subject to publication. Anfisa VORONINA, Gleb CHERKASOV, Svetlana MIKHAILOVA
|