| Experts discussed options for modernizing Russia A new word in Russian political geometry: the November 4 political action club wants to add a spiral of economic growth to the vertical of power. The last meeting of the club was devoted to discussing the relevant economic doctrine. True, the opinions expressed at it were so polar that it was time to talk not so much about a spiral, but about a sinusoid going to infinity.
Opening the discussion, the chairman of the club, editor-in-chief of Expert magazine Valery Fadeev said that “the vector outlined by the club five years ago is becoming clearer.” This meant a doctrine promulgated in 2005 called “Take Back the Leadership!” True, Mr. Fadeev kept silent about whether he managed to regain this leadership. But, apparently, this is not important, because the country has more important tasks. “It’s time for us to move from the doctrine of economic growth to the doctrine of deep socio-economic transformation and economic breakthrough,” noted the materials distributed to journalists. And from deep transformation to modernization is just a stone's throw away, so Tatyana Gurova, editor-in-chief of the Expert media holding, spoke loudly about modernization in her report.
From her words it followed that it was necessary to decide on a model of modernization: will it be an enclave or will it immediately cover the entire country to the very outskirts, will it become “organic, according to the Western version” or “violent, catching up,” which is supposedly more typical for developing countries. Deputy editor-in-chief of Expert Dan Medovnikov stunned listeners with the statement that “we have slept through the innovation race of the last 20-25 years.” But he immediately consoled: “For Russia this is a natural state, we harness it for a long time - we go quickly.” While many complain about the “oil and gas needle” that prevents the country from developing, Mr. Medovnikov found an example of successful development on such a needle - Norway: “This is an example of how to build a new innovation system using rich natural resources.” True, weak infrastructure and inertia of the system can hinder Russia in this good cause. But these, according to the expert, are solvable problems if they are dealt with by a government that is “strong, but not authoritarian.” It could, firstly, pursue a serious anti-monopoly policy, and secondly, establish “technological corridors for lighting devices and fuel standards.” Business will begin to comply with these corridors - this is the dawn of modernization.
“But is there demand for innovation?” - this question, which sounded rhetorical, was addressed to the audience by Valery Fadeev, having heard about the technological corridors. In response, Academician of the Russian Academy of Sciences Viktor Polterovich immediately dispelled the myth that lazy and inert domestic entrepreneurs do not understand the benefits of innovation. “Business is resisting not modernization, but the imposition of strategies that are unprofitable to it,” he said. Mr. Polterovich also spoke out against the “a priori choice of growth points”: “This does not lead to anything good; priorities must be set in the process of interaction between business and society.” Let us recall that such an “a priori growth point” should be the Russian analogue of Silicon Valley - Skolkovo.
The critical line was continued by the President of the All-Russian Association of Privatized and Private Enterprises Grigory Tomchin, who suggested that those wishing to modernize first discuss Soviet industrialization of the 30s, the post-war scientific and technological revolution and the lessons of these eras for today. Instead of taking an example from China, it has become fashionable to remember Chinese “modernization” as an example of successful economic growth under an authoritarian political system. “There is no need to turn our train either to China or to the Soviet past! - the expert got excited. “Because if you got on the wrong train, then all the stops will be wrong!”
HSE Vice-Rector Lev Yakobson also spoke out for non-violent changes: “Modernization is a project of serving what is growing from below, it is taking up the initiative.” And economist Igor Lavrovsky generally stated that he was ready to bet $200 that “with the current team around the Kremlin, there will be no meaningful modernization.” “Why only 200?” - asked Valery Fadeev. “I won’t give any more for her!” - Mr. Lavrovsky said in anger.
Mr. Fadeev, however, was not embarrassed by such intensity of modernization passions, and he courageously summarized the outcome of the meeting: “A fundamental consensus has been reached.” That's what they decided on. In the end, a spiral as a geometric figure does not imply completeness, and the discussion can be continued at any time. In a spiral. Natalia ROZHKOVA | |